BUSINESS LAW INTERNATIONAL
Volume 10       Number 3       September 2009

Speedread
201

Use of Creditor Committees in Sovereign Debt Workouts
Lee C Buchheit
205

Revlon Redux: Reconciling the BCE case in Change of Control Transactions—Is Lyondell the 
Better Way?
Nicholas Dietrich
218

At Last the United Kingdom Confronts Bribery: Will the Draft Bribery Bill be Enough to Silence its 
Critics?
Monty Raphael and Ben Summers
242

New Regulations for the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States—Disclosures of 
Cyber Security Plans and Dealings with Sanctioned Countries Remain Uncertain
Warren G Lavey
253

The Role of the Judiciary in International Arbitration—The Benefits of Support: Recent English 
Experience
J William Rowley QC and Sudhanshu Swaroop
272

Treatment of Hybrid Entities and Financial Instruments in the OECD Model Convention: Impact on 
the Structure of Foreign Investments
Leonardo Freitas de Moraes e Castro
280

IBA Submission to the European Commission on Regulation (EC) No 44/2001
Working Group on the Report from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council and 
the European Economic and Social Committee (COM(2009) 174 Final) and the Green Paper on the 
Review of Council Regulation (EC) No 44/2001 on Jurisdiction and the Recognition and 
Enforcement of Judgments in Civil and Commercial Matters—IBA Arbitration Committee Paper 
Submitted to the European Commission
302

Book Reviews
322

General Index
326



CANADIAN BUSINESS LAW JOURNAL
Volume 48       Number 1       September 2009

EDITORIAL
1

ARTICLES AND SYMPOSIA
On Lemons and Leather: Liability for Misrepresentations of Forward-looking Information in Danier 
Leather
Edward M. Iacobucci
3

Legal Privilege as a Defining Characteristic of Charity
Adam Parachin
36

COMMENTARIES
Unjust Enrichment and the Supreme Court of Canada: Two Comments on B.M.P. Global 
Distribution Inc. v. Bank of Nova Scotia
Mistake, Forged Cheques and Unjust Enrichment: Three Cheers for B.M.P. Global
John D. McCamus
76

B.M.P. Global Distribution Inc. v. Bank of Nova Scotia: The Unitary Action in Unjust Enrichment
Mitchell McInnes
102

Priority Disputes between Marine Mortgages and Ontario PPSA Security Interests in Watercraft: 
Royal Bank v. 1132959 Ontario Ltd.
Jeffrey Alpert
125

Muscutt Misplaced: The Future of Forum of Necessity Jurisdiction in Canada
Janet Walker
135

REVIEW ESSAYS AND BOOK REVIEWS
Annotated Securities Transfers Act, 2006, by Members of the Canadian Securities Administrators’ 
USTA Task Force, with additional comments by John Cameron and Robert Scavone
Bradley Crawford, Q.C.
144

Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Law: Bill C-55, Statute c. 47 and Beyond, by Stephanie Ben-
Ishai and Anthony Duggan
Andrew Keay
154

Structure and Justification in Private Law: Essays for Peter Birks, by Charles Rickett and Ross 
Grantham, eds.
Elisa Bant
164



HEALTH LAW REVIEW
Volume 18       Number 1       2009

Field Notes
3

Public Health Protection and Drinking Water Quality on First Nation Reserves: Considering the New 
Federal Regulatory Proposal
Constance MacIntosh
5

Assessing A Public Health Justification For Reducing Whale Consumption in Northern Canada
Cameron Jefferies
12

Using Food and Beverage Price Interventions to Address Obesity
JoAnne Sauder
21

Exploiting the Fiduciary Relationship: The Physician as Information Intermediary on Assisted Human 
Reproduction
Vanessa Gruben
29

New Frontiers For Electronic Health Records and Research Databases—Alberta’s Bill 52: 
Submission of the Health Law Institute on Bill 52
Tracey M. Bailey
37



INTERNATIONAL REVIEW OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY AND COMPETITION LAW
Volume 40       Number 6       2009

Editorial
Freedom to Compete and the More Economic Approach—Limits Imposed by Law Articles
R. Zäch
623

Articles
Implementing an International Instrument for Interpreting Copyright Limitations and Exceptions
C. Geiger
627

Public Policy Exception to Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Cases of Copyright 
Infringement
M. Trimble Landova
642

The Copyright Term “Work”—European Harmonisation at an Unknown Level
C. Handig
665

The Use and Misuse of Well-Known Marks Listings
K.-C. Liu, X. Tao and E. Wang
685

Smell Marks—A Singapore Study and the Implications for the Commercial Use and Exploitation of 
Non-Traditional Trade Marks
A. Samtani, F. Chiam, J. Lim and J. Wee
698

Decisions
Patent Law and Civil Procedure
EPO—President
23 Oct. 2008
Programs for computers—Patentability of—Exclusion of claim under Art. 52(2)(c) and (3) EPC—
Technical character of claim—Referral by the President of the EPO to the EBA Regarding 
Divergent Decisions of Two Boards of Appeal—Case pending under G 3/08—“Referral—G 3/08”
715

EPO-EBA
2009 OJ EPO 167
Language of proceedings—Choice of Language on entry into regional phase before EPO where 
international patent application filed and published under Patent Cooperation Treaty—Use by EPO, 
in written proceedings, of official language other than language of proceedings used for 
application—EPC, EOC 1973, Patent Cooperation Treaty—Communication from the EBA 
concerning Case G 4/08—“Communication—G 4/08”
716

China
Shanghai Higher People’s Ct.
18 April 2008
Renumeration of employee’s invention—Inventor’s contribution to invention in respect of product 
actually sold or bundle of technologies actually licensed to be taken into account—Increasing 
percentage of contribution where employer has taken steps in bad faith to have patent invalidated—
Patent Act, Sec. 16; Implementing Regulations, Secs. 7476—Wong Like v. Shanghai “EV” Fuel 
Injection Co. Ltd—Fuel Injection Pump”
Comment by X. Yuan
716

Japan
Sup. Ct.
24 April 2008
Patentee whose patent has been regarded as in valid by courts—Argument that patent was upheld 
in amended form in correction trial before Patent Office—Admissible only if trial conducted without 
unreasonable delay—Patent Act, Secs. 104ter, 123, 128; Code of Civil Procedure, Sec. 338—
“Knife-Processing Device”
Comment by C. Heath
721

Copyright Law
Australia
High Ct.
22 April 2009
Copyright protection for collections of information (databases)—Reproduction of substantial parts—
“Information/expression dichotomy”—“Skill and labour” doctrine—Copyright Act (1968), Secs. 
10(1), 32, 14(1)(b)—2009 HCA 14—IceTV Pty Limited v. Nine Network Australia Pty Limited—
“IceTV v. Nine Network”
727

Intellectual Property and Consumer Protection Law
France
Caen Dist. Ct.
30 April 2008
Sale of computers with preinstalled software—Whether in breach of Article L. 122-1 of Consumer 
Code—Practice is in consumers’ interests—Vendors may be required to disclose price of hardware 
and software separately—91-07-000172—H.R. v. SARL Asus France—“H.R. v. Asus France”
729

France
Paris Dist. Ct.
24 June 2008
Sale of computers with preinstalled software—Whether in breach of Article L. 122-1 of Consumer 
Code—Practice is in consumers’ interests—Vendors may be required to disclose price of hardware 
and software separately—06/17972—UFC Que Choisir v. Éts Darty et Fils—“Que Choisir v. Darty”
731

France
Sup. Ct.
5 June 2008
Sale of computers with preinstalled software—Whether in breach of Article L. 122-1 of Consumer 
Code—Practice is in consumers’ interests—Vendors may be required to disclose price of hardware 
and software separately—06-21.514—FD, Gérome Cresp v. SARL Asus France and Sté Relais 
FNAC—“Gérome Cresp v. Asus France and FNAC”
734

Trade Mark Law
EU-ECJ
11 Dec. 2008
Community trade mark “Activy Media Gateway”—Earlier marks including word sign “Gateway”—
Absence of similarity of signs—Lack of likelihood of confusion—Taking into account of renown of 
earlier marks when carrying out global assessment of opposing sign—EC Reg. 40/94, Art. 8(1)(b), 
(5)—C-57/08 P—Gateway, Inc. v. Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (Trade Marks and 
Designs) (OHIM) and Fujitsu Siemens Computers GmbH—“Gateway/Activy Media Gateway”
735

EU-ECJ
18 Dec. 2008
Community word mark “Mobilix”—Earlier Community and national word mark “Obelix”—Review of 
legality of decisions of OHIM’s Boards of Appeal by CFI—Assessment of facts—Appeal to indicate 
elements of judgment which appellant seeks to have set aside and legal arguments advanced in 
support of appeal—Documents included as annex to application as new evidence before CFI—EC 
Reg. 40/94, Arts. 8(1)(b), (5), 63, 74—C-16/06 P—Les Éditions Albert René Sàrl v. Office for 
Harmonisation in the Internal Market (Trade Marks and Designs) (OHIM) and Orange A/S—
“Obelix/Mobilix”
735

Germany
Sup. Ct.
10 April 2008
If trade mark registered for agent without proprietor
S authorization—Claims regarding cancellation, assignment, prohibition of use and damages—
Meaning of principle—Claims against third parties—Agency relationship—Trade Mark Act, Secs. 11, 
17; Paris Convention, Art 6septies—I ZR 164/05—“Audison”
736

Trade Mark and Unfair Competition Law
Germany
Sup. Ct.
30 April 2008
Determination of whether contested three-dimensional get-up used as trademark—Distinctive 
character of plaintiff’s trademark—Competitive individuality—Range of products as totality of 
products with common features in terms of purpose and design—Deception as to origin—In item 
offered for sale comprising number of products—Trademark Act, Sec. 14(2) No. 2; Act Against 
Unfair Competition, Secs. 3, 4 No. 9a—I ZR 123/05—“Ribbed Case”
742

Book Review
Jaeger, Pohlmann, Rieger an Schroeder (eds.)
Frankfurter Kommentar zum Kartellrecht, 1982/2006 (incl. 64th delivery)
Fikentscher
747



JOURNAL OF CORPORATE LAW STUDIES
Volume 9       Number 2       October 2009

Articles
Conflicts of Interest in Securitisaton: Adjusting Incentives
Christoph Kumpan
261

Liability for Missatements to the Market: Some Reflections
Paul Davies
295

Are US-style Investor Suits Coming to the UK?
Eilís Ferran
315

Personal Liability of Officers in US Securities Class Actions
Michael Klausner
349

Civil Enforcement in Canadian Securities Law
Christopher C Nicholls
367

Public and Private Enforcement of Disclosure Breaches in Australia
Elizabeth Boros
409

The Mismatch between Litigation Intensity and D&O Protection in Cross-border Securities Law 
Enforcement
Priya Cherian Huskins
439



LAW & JUSTICE
Number 162       Hilary/Easter 2009

Editorial
2

Main Articles
Church-State Relationships: An Overview
Frank Cranmer and Javier García Oliva
4

The Place of Religious Arguments for Law Reform in a Secular State
Jonathan Chaplin
18

Religion, Human Rights and the Council of Europe: a note
Frank Cranmer
36

Religion and the state in the United States at the turn of the twenty-first century
W. Cole Durham, Robert T. Smith
47

Law and Religion in Latin America
Carmen Asiaín Pererira
62

Law and Religion Scholars Networks
79

Book Reviews
Samantha Currie, Migration, Work and Citizenship in the Enlarged European Union
Javier García Oliva
82

Casebook
Coleman v Attridge Law & anor [2008]
85

English v Thomas Sanderson ltd [2008]
85

Eweida v British Airways plc [2008]
87

Helow v Secretary of State for the Home Department and anor [2008]
89

L v Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority & anor [2008]
90

London Borough of Islington v Ladele [2008]
91

Mosley v News Group Newspapers ltd [2008]
93

Purdy, R (on the application of) v Director of Public Prosecutions * ors [2009]
94

Saini v All Saints Haque Centre & ors [2008]
96

Our Contributors
98



MONASH UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW
Volume 35       Number 1       2009

ADDRESSES
The parameters of Constitutional Change
The Hon Sir Gerard Brennan AC KBE
1

Remarks on the Occasion of the 19th International Symposium on the Forensic Sciences
The Hon Chief Justice Marilyn Warren AC
19

The Move towards Pre-emption in the Criminal Law
The Hon Justice Mark Weinberg
25

ARTICLES
The Quit Rent System in Colonial New South Wales
Enid Campbell AC OBE
32

Implied Fetters on the Exercise of Discretionary Contractual Powers
Dr Jeannie Marie Paterson
45

Keeping It in the Neighbourhood? Neighbourhood Courts in the Australian Context
Sarah Murray
74

The Recovery of Wages: Legal Services and Access to Justice
Chris Arup and Carolyn Sutherland
96

Food Advertising and Obesity in Australia: To What Extent Can Self-regulation Protect the Interests 
of Children?
Sarah Mackay
118

Who Is Entitled to Parental Responsibility? Biology, Caregiving, Intention and the Family Law Act 
1975 (Cth): A Jurisprudential Feminist Analysis
Dr Aleardo Zanghellini

BOOK REVIEW
Ron McCallum, McCalllum’s Top Workplace Relations Cases: Labour Law and the Employment 
Relationship as Defined by Case Law
Karen Wheelwright
183

Nadine Behan, How to Run Your Own Court Case: A Practical Guide to Representing Yourself in 
Australian Courts and Tribunals
Ross Hyams
187



UNIVERSITY OF TASMANIA LAW REVIEW
Volume 27       Number 2       2008

Articles
‘For Want of Evidence’: Initial Impressions of Indigenous Exchanges with the First Colonial Superior 
Courts of Australia
BRENT SALTER
145

Clear and Empathic: The Separation of Church and State under the Australian Constitution
LUKE BECK
161

The Use of Enforceable Undertakings by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission
MARINA NEHME
197

Practice Note
The Hostile or Unfavourable Witness
MARTIN HINTON AND NERISSA SCHWARZ
229

Book Reviews
Crimes against Nature: Environmental Criminology and Ecological Justice
JENNIFER SALLANS
239

Looking South: Australia’s Antarctic Agenda
RONAN FENTON
241



WINDSOR REVIEW OF LEGAL AND SOCIAL ISSUES
Volume 27       May 2009

Introduction: Defining an Identity
William A. Bogart
1

Reflection: Twenty Years of the Windsor Review of Legal & Social Issues
Mary P. Reilly
3

Corporate Environmental Responsibility in the Wake of the Supreme Court Decision of BCE Inc. 
and Bell Canada
Jeffrey Bone
5

And Social Justice for All: A History of the University of Windsor, Faculty of Law
Annette Demers
31

Creating a Culture of Professional Responsibility and Ethics: A Leadership Role for Law Schools
Bruce P. Elman
93

Bedeviled by Delay: Straight Talk about Memory Loss, Procedural Delay and the Myth of Swift 
Justice
Brian Manarin
117

 “Judicial Ratbags or Men of Principle? The Trials and Tribulations of Maverick Colonial Judges in 
19th Century” or “A Funny Way to Run an Empire”
John McLaren
145

Food for Tort: Giving the Casino Some Consideration, A Continued Defence of the Gaming 
Industry
Emir A. C. Mohammed
169

Defining Justice in Afghanistan: Development of a National Legal Aid System
Ele Pawelski
185
CRIMINAL LAW REVIEW
Number 11       November 2009

Editorial
755

Articles
Mens Rea and Defendants Below the Age of Discretion
Francis Bennion
757

Public Attitudes to Sentencing Purposes and Sentencing Factors: An Empirical Analysis
Julian V. Roberts, Mike Hough, Jessica Jacobson, and Nick Moon
771

Cash Forfeiture Following Acquittal: An "Affront To Public Perception" or a Breach of a 
Fundamental Human Right?
Klentiana Mahmutaj
783

Current Topic
Professional Conduct and the Solicitor Advocate
By Robert S. Shiels
794

Case and Comment
798



DENNING LAW JOURNAL
Volume 21       2009

Obituary
Lord Slynn of Hadley

ARTICLES
The Creation Story of Kashmiri People: The Right to Self-Determination
Fozia N Lone
1

Raising our Heads above the Parapet? Societal Attitudes to Assisted Suicide and Consideration of 
the Need for Law Reform in English and Wales
Karen Dyer
27

Forced Marriage: Bifurcated Values in the UK
Mary Welstead
49

The Evidence of Anonymous Witnesses in Criminal Courts: Now and Into the Future
Alan George Ward
67

The Changing Face of the City
Ann Halpern
93

CASE COMMENTARIES
Unincorporated Associations: Properties Holdings, Charitable Purposes and Dissolution
James Brown
107

“Dog-Leg” Claims Kicked into Touch: Beneficiaries Exposed?
Rowena Meager
119

Pre-nuptial Agreements under Scrutiny
Judith Bray
131

Who has First Claim on “The Loyalty of the Law”?
Carol Brennan
141

Unhappy Families and Use of Article 8 for Failed Asylum Seekers
Charlotte Walsh
153

Remoteness of Contractual Damages
John Halladay
173

BOOK REVIEW
McCoubrey & White’s Textbook on Jurisprudence 4th Edition
James Slater
183

The University of Buckingham
189

Buckingham Law School
191



EUROPEAN LAW REVIEW
Volume 34       Number 5       October 2009

Editorial
Visa-free Travel–Foreign Policy in the Making
669

Articles
The Community Code on Visas: Harmonisation at last?
Annalisa Meloni
671

A case study of "soft law" in EU external relations: The European Neighbourhood Policy
Bart Van Vooren
696

Contracts beyond the scope of the EC procurement Directives—who is bound by the requirement 
for transparency?
Marek Szyd?o
720

Analysis and Reflections
Of holidays, work and humanisation: a missed opportunity?
Alan Bogg
738

Extending the reach of the AETR principle: Comment on Commission v Greece (C-45/07)
Marise Cremona
754

Undue assistance? An analysis of the legal basis of Regulation .1257/96 concerning humanitarian 
aid
Morten Broberg
769

Autonomous regions, taxation and EC state-aid rules
Rosa Greaves
779

Book Reviews
794



EUROPEAN REVIEW OF PRIVATE LAW
Volume 17       Number 5       2009

Editorial
EWOUD HONDIUS
745

Articles
To What Extent Can the Notion of 'Reasonableness' Help to Harmonize European Contract Law? 
Problems and Prospects from a Civil Law Perspective
STEFANO TROIANO
749

The Tort Law Industry
JEROEN KORTMANN
789

Tying the Knot in European Private Law
IVAN SAMMUT
813

The Theoretical Foundations of the Common Core of European Private Law Project: A Critical 
Appraisal
NIK J. DE BOER
841

The Contribution of Law and Economics as a Method of Legal Reasoning in European Private Law
MICHAEL SCHILLIG
853

National and International Dimensions of Copyright Law in the Internet Age Harmonizing 
exemptions: The Case of Orphan Works
ALLARD RINGNALDA
895

European Securities Regulation, Private Law and the Investment Firm-Client Relationship
OLHA O. CHEREDNYCHENKO
925

Book Reviews
Christiane Holzmann, Brüssel IIa VO: Elterliche Verantwortung und internationale 
Kindesentführungen
By CHRISTINE BUDZIKIEWICZ
953

List of Contributors
957



JOURNAL OF WORLD TRADE
Volume 43       Number 5       October 2009

Evolution in India's Regional Trading Arrangements
V.S. Seshadri
903

The WTO Law and the EC's GSP+ Arrangement
Dr Umut Turksen
927

Governments' Interventions into the Real Economy under WTO Law Revisited: New Tendencies of 
Governmental Support of the Automobile Industry
Prof. Dr Rolf H. Weber and Mirina Grosz
969

Services in Doha: What's on the Table?
Batshur Gootiiz and Aaditya Mattoo
1013

Permanent Group of Experts under the SCM Agreement
Jun Kazeki
1031

EC Liability for Non-compliance with Decisions of the WTO DSB: The Lack of Judicial Protection 
Persists
Armin Steinbach
1047

Health Protection at the World Trade Organization: The J-Value as a Universal Standard for 
Reasonableness of Regulatory Precautions
David Collins
1071

The Equity of Levelling the Playing Field in the Climate Change Context
Julia O'Brien
1093

National Climate Change Mitigation Measures and Their Implications for the Multilateral Trading 
System: Key Findings of the WTO/UNEP Report on Trade and Climate Change
Ludivine Tamiotti and Vesile Kulaço?lu
1115



NORTHERN IRELAND LEGAL QUARTERLY
Volume 60       Number 3       Autumn 2009

Criminal law as a preventative tool of environmental regulation: compliance versus deterrence
Patrick Bishop
279

Adverse possession and informal purchasers
Una Woods
305

A consensus on the reform of the House of Lords?
Mark Ryan
325

Justice without mercy
Sean Coyle
343

A pandisability analysis? The possibilities and pitfalls of indirect disability discrimination
Olivia Smith
361

Book review: Consociational Theory by Rupert Taylor
Kate Blomfield
381



RES PUBLICA
Volume 15       Number 3       Fall 2009

Special Issue on Rules and Exemptions: The Politics and Difference Within Liberalism
Guest Editors: Maria Paola Ferretti and Lenka Strnadová

Rules and Exemptions: The Politics of Difference Within Liberalism
M.P. Ferretti & L. Strnadová
213

Just Procedures with Controversial Outcomes: On the Grounds for Substantive Disputation Within a 
Procedural Theory of Justice
E. Ceva
219

The Exemption that Confirms the Rule: Reflections on Proceduralism and the UK Hybrid Embryos 
Controversy
E. Rossi
237

Beyond the Conflict: Religion in the Public Sphere and Deliberative Democracy
E. González, J.F. Lozano & P.J. Pérez
251

Exemptions for Whom? On the Relevant Focus of Egalitarian Concern
M.P. Ferretti
269

REGULAR PAPER
The Nature and Disvalue of Injury
S. Lazar
289

BOOK REVIEWS
The Nature of Customary Law
N. Roughan
305

Democracy After Deliberation
B. Saunders
315



WORLD TRADE AND ARBITRATION MATERIALS
Volume 21       Number 5       October 2009

World Trade Organization (WTO)
WTO Dispute Settlement
United States—Measures Relating to Zeroing and Sunset Reviews
Recourse to Article 21.5 of the DSU by Japan
Report of the Appellate Body
18 August 2009
1063

Arbitral Awards
International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID)
Waguih Elie George Siag & Clorinda Vecchi v. The Arab Republic of Egypt
Award
1 June 2009
1171
ARAB LAW QUARTERLY
Volume 23       Number 4       2009

When EU Law Meets Arabic Law: Assessment of Anti-Corruption Law in Morocco and Some 
Proposed Amendments
Bryane Michael and Abdelaziz Nouaydi
353

Evolution in the Canonical Sunni Hadith Body of Literature and the Concept of an Authentic Hadith 
During the Formative Period of Islamic Thought as Based on Recent Western Scholarship
Adis Duderija
389

Criminal Justice under Shari?ah in the 21st Century—An Inter-Cultural View
Michael Bohlander and Mohammed M. Hedayati-Kakhki
417

Arbitrating Individual Labour Disputes in Jordan: Has the Policy of Promoting Arbitration Been 
Misplaced?
Mohammed Hussein Bashayreh
437

The Perspective of Moral and Financial Rights of Intellectual Property in Islam
Qais Ali Mahafzah, Basem M. Melhem and Hitham A. Haloosh
457

The Role of Intention (Niyya) Under Saudi Arabian Hanbali Law
Nabil Saleh
469



EUROPEAN HUMAN RIGHTS LAW REVIEW
Number 5       2009

OPINION
Achievements and Challenges—Insights from the Strasbourg Experience for Other International 
Courts
James A. Goldston
603

BULLETIN
611

BULLETIN: COUNTER-TERRORISM AND HUMAN RIGHTS
616

ARTICLES
The Extraterritorial Reach and Applicability in Armed Conflict of the International Covenant on Civil 
and Political Rights: A Rejoinder to Dennis and Surena
Sir Nigel Rodley
628

Religion and International Law: Friends or Foes?
Mashood A. Baderin
637

Sentencing the Religious Defendant
Peter W. Edge
659

Do Minimum Age Requirements Violate the Right to Stand for Election under the European 
Convention on Human Rights?
Achilles C. Emilianides
670

CASE ANALYSIS
Opuz v Turkey: Confirming the State Obligation to Combat Domestic Violence
Bonita C. Meyersfeld
684

CASES AND COMMENT
Kenedi v Hungary (Application No.31475/05)
694

Bigaeva v Greece (Application No.26713/05)
696

Szuluk v United Kingdom (Application No.36936/05)
699

Standard Verlags GmbH v Austria (No.2) (Application No.21277/05)
702

Opuz v Turkey (Application No.33401/02)
704

Shukla v United Kingdom (Application No.2526/07)
709

Al Saadoon and Mufdhi v United Kingdom (Application No.61498/08)
711

Verein Gegen Tierfabriken Schweiz (VgT) v Switzerland (No.2) (Application No.32772/02)
716

BOOK REVIEW
721



INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION LAW REVIEW
Volume 12       Number 5       2009

Articles
The Arbitration Exclusion in Regulation 44/2001 after West Tankers
ALEXIS MOURRE AND ALEXANDRE VAGENHEIM
75

The Appointment and Challenge of Arbitrators Under the Rules of the Australian Centre for 
International Commercial Arbitration
GABRIËL MOENS AND SAM LUTTRELL
84

International Commercial Arbitration: Hurdles when Confirming a Foreign Arbitral Award in the 
United States
DANIEL E. GONZÁLEZ AND MARÍA EUGENIA RAMÍREZ
96

Lawyer-Client Privilege in International Arbitration-a Blurred Area Prone to Unpredictability or Useful 
Flexibility?
JANE PLAYER AND CLAIRE MOREL DE WESTGAVER
101

Arbitration and Electronic Communications: public policy
NORBERT HORN
107

News Section
An international review of recent cases and developments
N-61



INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL ON MINORITY AND GROUP RIGHTS
Volume 16       Number 3       2009

Articles
Regional National Autonomy under Challenge: Law, Practice and Recommendations
MARIA LUNDBERG, YONG ZHOU
269

Legal Predicament of Combining ‘Regional’ and ‘National’ Autonomy: A Group Rights Perspective
YONG ZHOU
329

Hunting-Prohibition in the Hunters’ Autonomous Area: Legal Rights of Oroqen People and the 
Implementation of Regional National Autonomy Law
MARIA LUNDBERG, YONG ZHOU
349

Regional National Autonomy and Minority Language Rights in the PRC
MARIA LUNDBERG
399

Written Language Reform and Regional Autonomy of Dai Nationality in Xishuangbanna
ZHANG XISHENG
423

Negotiable Rights? China’s Ethnic Minorities and the Right to Freedom of Religion
KOEN WELLENS
433

Nationality Townships— An Endangered Species?
GÖRAN LEIJONHUFVUD
455

Academic Debate
Interpreting Human Rights Violations in Ethiopia: A Rejoinder to Getachew Assefa
KJETIL TRONVOLL
475

Recent Books on Human Rights and Groups
Review Essay
The Law and Politics of International Cultural Rights: E. Stamatopoulou, Cultural Rights in 
International Law; F. Francioni and M. Scheinin (eds.), Cultural Human Rights
PATRICK MACKLEM
481

Book Reviews
G. Letsas, A Theory of Interpretation of the European Convention on Human Rights
STEVEN GREER
503

S. Fredman, Human Rights Transformed: Positive Rights and Positive Duties
RORY O’CONNELL
506



JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION
Volume 26       Number 5       October 2009

ARTICLES
Defining the Indefinable: Practical Problems of Confidentiality in Arbitration
Michael Hwang S.C. and Katie Chung
609

The Group of Companies Doctrine in International Commercial Arbitration: Is There any Reason for 
this Doctrine to Exist?
Pietro Ferrario
647

Arbitrators Granting Antisuit Orders: When Should They and on What Authority?
Rahim Moloo
675

Turkey: Soon to Face a Wave of International Investment Arbitrations?
Steffen Hindelang, Stephan Wilske and Ismail G. Esin
701

Compensation for Non-expropriatory Breaches of International Investment Law—The Contribution 
of the Argentine Awards
Pierre-Yves Tschanz and Jorge E. Viñuales
729

NOTES AND CURRENT DEVELOPMENTS
Arbitrability of Corporate Disputes in Ukraine
Yuliya Chernykh
745

INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION EVENTS CALENDAR
751



MELBOURNE UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW
Volume 33       Number 1       2009

Articles
Still Paying the Price for Benign Intentions? Contextualising Contemporary Interventions in the 
Lives of Aboriginal Peoples
Peter Billings
1

Credit Rating Agencies: A Regulatory Challenge for Australia
Tin A Bunjevac
39

Cross-Examination in Child Sexual Assault Trials: Evidentiary Safeguard or an Opportunity to 
Confuse?
Annie Cossins
68

The Charter's Irremediable Remedies Provision
Jeremy Gans
105

The Professional 'Tug of War': The Regulation of Foreign Lawyers in China, Business Scope 
Issues and Some Suggestions for Reform
Andrew Godwin
132

National Litigation and International Law: Repercussions for Australia's Protection of Marine 
Resources
Natalie Klein and Nikolas Hughes
163

The Nature of Torrens Indefeasibility: Understanding the Limits of Personal Equities
Kelvin F K Low
205

Change of Position and Restitution for Wrongs: 'Ne'er the Twain Shall Meet'?
Paul A Walker
235

Critique and Comment
The False Analogy between Vilification and Sedition
Katharine Gelber
270

‘Storyline Patents': Are Plots Patentable?
Ben McEniery
292

Case Note
Lumbers v W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (in liq) Restitution for Services and the Allocation of Contractual 
Risk
Michael Bryan
320

Books Received
332



NOTTINGHAM LAW JOURNAL
Volume 18       Number 1       2009

EDITORIAL
Tom Lewis
v

ARTICLES
“She got past knowing herself and didn't know how many there were": Uncovering the Gendered 
Brutality of Gang Rapes in Victorian England
Kim Stevenson
1

Irrationality, The Human Rights Act and the limits of Merits—Review
Ian Turner
18

CASE AND COMMENT
Defaulting Structured Investment Vehicles: Are Some Creditors More Equal Than Others? In the 
matter of Sigma Finance Corporation (in Administrative Receivership)  
Paula Moffatt
37

BOOK REVIEWS
Alison Clarke and Paul Kohler, Property Law: Commentary and Materials, Cambridge University 
Press, 2005
Graham Ferris
41

James Chalmers. Legal Responses to HIV and AIDS, Oxford, Hart Publishing, 2008
Peter McTigue
46

PRACTICAL APPLIED LEGAL THEORY
Introduction
Graham Ferris
48

The Relevance of Faith Integration in Legal Education
Scott A Taylor
49

NOTTINGHAM MATTERS
A Corporate Approach to Legal Practice
Keith Gaines
55

TABLES
Table of Cases
vii

Table of Statutes
ix

Table of EU Legislation
x

European Convention on Human Rights
x



SYDNEY LAW REVIEW
Volume 31       Number 3       September 2009

Articles
The Authority of International Law: Lifting the State Veil
Samantha Besson
343

Australian Censorship Policy and the Advocacy of Terrorism
David Hume & George Williams
381

Procedural Due Process under the Australian Constitution
William Bateman
411

Water Rights in NSW: Properly Property?
Michael McKenzie
443

Before the High Court
Mind the ‘Evidential Gap': Causation and Proof in Amaca Pty Ltd v Ellis
David Hamer
465

Case Note
R v Tang: Developing an Australian Anti-Slavery Jurisprudence
Irina Kilodizner
487

Book Review
Thinking Like a Lawyer A New Introduction to Legal Reasoning by Frederick Schauer
Irene Baghoomians
499
ADVOCATES’ QUARTERLY
Volume 36       Number 1       September 2009

ARTICLES
Special Problems Posed by Leased or Rented Vehicles: Common Pitfalls for Lawyers and How to 
Avoid Them
Stephen R. Moore
1

Muscutt v. Courcelles Revisited: The Court of Appeal for Ontario Takes Another Look
Vaughan Black and Mat Brechtel
35

Serial and Independent Concurrent Causes in Insurance Law
Hillel David and Gary Caplan
57

Reproductive Choice in Canadian Courts: An Evidence-Based Call for a Move to Relational 
Autonomy
Chris Kaposy and Jocelyn Downie
86

Dunsmuir v. New Brunswick: A New Era in Judicial Review and Procedural Fairness?
Ivan G. Whitehall Q.C. and Julie Thibault
105

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE
Is Summary Judgment Available in the Ontario Small Claims Court?
J. Sebastian Winny
128

CORRESPONDENCE
Should the Supreme Court Cite Living Judges? A Comment on Professor Mohammed
Andrew Botterell
138



ASIA-PACIFIC JOURNAL ON HUMAN RIGHTS AND THE LAW
Volume 8       Number 2       2007

ARTICLES
Reappraising the Right of Self-determination in the People's Republic of China
Xia Chunli
1

A Review of the Legal Framework for Human Rights Protection in Viet Nam
Hao Duy Phan
20

Trafficking of Mainland Chinese Women into Hong Kong's Sex Industry: Problems of Identification 
and Response
Robyn Emerton, Karen Joe Laidler & Carole J. Petersen
35

SELECTED HUMAN RIGHTS DOCUMENTS
ASEAN Declaration on the Protection and Promotion of the Rights of Migrant Workers
85

Final Report: Reference on the Right to Education, Asia Pacific Forum of National Human Rights 
Institutions' Advisory Council of Jurists
90

Statement of the Establishment of the ASEAN Committee on the Implementation of the ASEAN 
Declaration on the Protection and Promotion of the Rights of Migrant Workers
112

Universal Declaration of Human Rights in Fijian
115



COMPANY AND SECURITIES LAW JOURNAL
Volume 27       Number 7       October 2009

EDITORIAL
409

ARTICLES
False trading and market rigging in Australia
Emma Armson
411

Should claims held by misled and deceived shareholders rank with rather than behind claims held 
by other unsecured creditors of insolvent companies?
David Pompilio
426

COMPANY LAW
Robert Baxt AO

The costs of corporate litigation in Australia
Asjeet S Lamba and Ian M Ramsay
448

DIRECTORS' DUTIES AND CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
Geof Stapledon and Jon Webster

Director termination benefits and superannuation under the Corporations Act
John Sartori
458



INDUSTRIAL LAW JOURNAL: INCLUDING THE INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
Volume 30       August 2009

HIGHLIGHTS OF THE INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
iii

INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
TABLE OF CASES
1717

ANNOTATIONS
1719

INDEX
1725

JUDGMENTS
Supreme Court of Appeal
Kriel v Legal Aid Board & others
1735

Lebowa Platinum Mines Ltd v Viljoen
1742

High Court
Mozart Ice Cream Classic Franchises (Pty) Ltd v Davidoff & another (C)
1750

Random Logic (Pty) Ltd t/a Nashua, Cape Town v Dempster (C)
1762

Young v Coega Development Corporation (Pty) Ltd (1) (ECP)
1776

Young v Coega Development Corporation (Pty) Ltd (2) (ECP)
1786

Labour Appeal Court
Minister of Justice & Constitutional Development & another v Tshishonga
1799

Labour Court
AG's Distributors v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration & others
1810

Chemical Energy Paper Printing Wood & Allied Workers Union & another v Le-Sel Research (Pty) 
Ltd
1818

David Crouch Marketing CC v Du Plessis
1828

Democratic Nursing Organisation of SA & another v Director- General, Department of Health & 
others
1845

NASUWU & others v Pearwood Investments (Pty) Ltd Va Wolf Security & another
1852

National Union of Metalworkers of SA on behalf of Members v General Motors of SA (Pty) Ltd
1861

National Union of Mineworkers v De Beers Group Services (Pty) Ltd & others
1880

Radebe & another v Marshoff, Premier of Free State Province & others
1900

Ramsammy v Wholesale & Retail Sector Education & Training Authority
1927

Sondolo IT (Pty) Ltd v Howes & others
1954



JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL BANKING LAW AND REGULATION
Volume 24       Number 1       2009

Opinion
Leading Federal Court of Justice Case on Fees Clauses in Banks' General Terms and Conditions
HERBERT WIEHE
545

Articles
Consequences and Responses to the Madoff Fraud
DR TRACEY A. ANDERSON, DR H. LANE DAVID AND DR MARK A. FOX
548

The Governance of Derivatives in Islamic Finance
ANDREAS A. JOBST AND JUAN SOLÉ
556

A Presentee Bank's Duty When Examining a Tender of Documents under the Uniform Customs and 
Practice for Documentary Credits 600
EBENEZER ADODO
566

Legal Analysis
Guaranteeing Certainty
GAGTAM BHATTACHARYYA, GEORGE HOARE AND VICTORIA WALKER
580

Alitalia & Qantas: A Tale of Two National Airlines Confronting the Challenges of Change and 
Globalisation
ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR TONY CIRO AND DR BRUNO MASCITELLI
584

Going Global through the Alternative Investment Market: Listing of Indian Securities
ANJALI AGARWAL
590

Book Reviews
Goode on Legal Problems in Credit and Security
ORESTES PASPARAKIS
596

Corporate Borrowing Law and Practice, 4th Edition
DAVID STOKES
596

News Section
An International Review of Recent Cases and Legislation
N-91



JOURNAL OF WORLD INVESTMENT & TRADE
Volume 10       Number 5       October 2009

Human Rights of the Population of the Host State in International Investment Arbitration
Ursula Kriebaum
653

The Global Food Crisis and Lacklustre Agricultural Trade Liberalisation: Demystifying their Nexus 
Underpinning Reform
M. Rafiqul Islam and Md. Rizwanul Islam
679

Protected Investors Nationality
Jan Schokkaert and Yvon Heckscher
699

International Commercial Arbitration Award Enforcement at the Crossroads of Sharia Law and Ordre 
Public in the MENA: Paving the Golden Path towards Harmonisation
Mary B. Ayad
723

Beyond Hallmarks and Formal Requirements: a "Jurisprudence Constante" on the Notion of 
Investment in the ICSID Convention
Paolo Vargiu
753

The 14th Geneva Global Arbitration Forum
Jacques Werner
769

Will State Emergency Measures Trigger WTO Disputes?
What Prospects Exist for Reforming the Dispute Settlement System of the WTO—Professional 
Panellists, Retroactive, Remedies, Monetary Compensation?
Charles C. Adams, Jr.
771

Stuart Harbinson
777

Gary Horlick
781


Jayashree Watal
785



UNIVERSITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES LAW JOURNAL
Volume 32       Number 2       2009

Editorial
Julia Roy
337

COMMENTS
Foreword: Welcome to the Real World
The Hon. Michael Kirby AC CMG
338

How the American Dream Became a Global Nightmare: an Analysis of the Causes of the Global 
Financial Crisis
Michael Legg and Jason Harris
350

The Intellectual Foundations of the Global Financial Crisis: Analysis and Proposals for Reform
Frank Jan De Graaf and Cynthia A Williams
390

Diversity and Resilience: Lessons from the Financial Crisis
Ankoor Jain and Cally Jordan
416

Dancing the Derivative Deux Pas, The Financial Crisis and Lessons for Corporate Governance
Janis Sarra
447

The Global Financial Crisis and the Financial Stability Board: Hardening the Soft Law of International 
Financial Regulation?
Douglas W Arner and Michael W Taylor
488

Regulating Investment Risk: Individuals and The Global Financial Crisis
Dimity Kingsford Smith
514

The Lehman Minibonds Crisis in Hong Kong: Lessons for Plain Language Risk Disclosure
Andrew Godwin
547

The Export Credit Renaissance: Challenges for Ecologically Sustainable Development in the Global 
Economic Crisis
Scott Hickie
587

Debt-for-Development Exchanges: An Innovative Response to the Global Financial Crisis
Ross Buckley
620