CAMBRIAN LAW REVIEW
Volume 39       2008

Preface
iv

Notes on Contributors
v

Introduction
vi

Articles
Compulsory Care-Giving: Some Thoughts on Relational Feminism, The Ethics of Care And 
Omissions Liability
Neil Cobb
11

Reconsidering the Good Samaritan: a Duty to Rescue?
Gavin Dingwall and Alisdair A. Gillespie
26

Acts and Omissions — a Distinction Without a Defence?
Tracey Elliott and David Ormerod
40

Conduct and Complicity: Liability Based on Omission and Risk
Robert Sullivan
60

Acts And Omissions In Treatment Withdrawal: Conceptual Problems And Policy Decisions
Glenys Williams
75

Book Reviews
Becker, P. & Wetzell R. F. (eds.), Criminals and their Scientists: the History of Criminology in 
International Perspective
Bellany, Alastair, The Politics of Court Scandal in Early Modern England News Culture and the 
Overbury Affair 1603-1660
Holzman-Gazit, Yifat, Land Expropriation in Israel
Kennedy, David, Of Law and War
Okafor, Obiora Chinedu, The African Human Rights System: activist forces and international 
Institutions
Sloth-Nielsen, Julia (Ed.), Children's Rights in Africa, A Legal Perspective
Xanthaki, Alexandra, Indigenous Rights and United Nations Standards
Ziccardi Capaldo, Giuliana, The Pillars of Global Law
Armstrong, D. & Farrell, T. & H. Lambert, International Law and International Relations, and 
Simmons, B. A. & Steinberg, R. H. (eds), International Law and International Relations
95

Devolution and the New Legislative Bodies in the UK 2007-2008
A bibliography compiled by Jacqueline Woollam
117



COMPANY AND SECURITIES LAW JOURNAL
Volume 27       Number 4       June 2009

EDITORIAL
201

ARTICLES
A rapid response to questionable trading: Moving towards better enforcement of Australia's 
securities laws
Janet Austin
203

Australian court shoots down British Eagle
Michael Lishman
219

The insider trading "generally available" and "materiality" carve-outs: Are they achieving their aims?
Gill North
234

Litigation funding at another cross-roads
Robert Baxt AO
255



CRIMINAL LAW REVIEW
Number 7       July 2009

Editorial
477

Articles
Bribery: Corporate Liability under the Draft Bill 2009
Celia Wells
479

Drink, Drugs and Law Reform. A Review of Law Commission Report No.314
John Child
488

More Thoughts about Unlawful and Dangerous Act Manslaughter and the One-punch Killer
Barry Mitchell
502

Case and Comment
512



GRIFFITH LAW REVIEW
Volume 18       Number 1       2009

Symposium — In Dissent: Queering the Voice of Law
Queer, Antinormativity, Counter-Normativity and Abjection
Aleardo Zanghellini
1

Closet Cases: 'Conscientious Objection' to Lesbian and Gay Legal Equality
Carl F Stychin
17

Judging a Book by Its Cover: The Deployment (and) Unsettling of Familial Images on Family Law 
Textbook Covers
Sarah Beresford
39

General Articles
‘Things Fall Apart, the Centre Cannot Hold'
Sandra S Berns
53

Sociobiology, Racism and Australian Colonisation
Allan Ardill
82

Punishing Welfare: Genealogies of Child Abuse
David McCallum
114

Copyright, Governmentality and Problematisation: An Exploration
Chris Dent
129

Griffith, Isaacs and Australian Judicial Biography: An Evolutionary Development?
Sarah Burnside
151

Governing Pets and Their Humans: Dogs and Companion Animals in New South Wales, 1966-98
Fiona Borthwick
185

REVIEW
Property: Meanings, Histories, Theories
Margaret Davies
Review by Allan Ardill
202

INFORMATION FOR AUTHORS
205



INDUSTRIAL LAW JOURNAL: INCLUDING THE INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
Volume 30       January 2009

HIGHLIGHTS OF THE INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
iii

ARTICLES
Sidumo v Rustplats: How Have the Courts Dealt with It?
Anton Myburgh
1

Conciliation, Arbitration and Enforcement: The CCMA's Achievements and Challenges
Paul Benjamin
26

The Meaning of ‘Worker' and the Road Towards Diversification: Reflecting on Discovery, SITA and 
'Kylie'
Rochelle Le Roux
49

In Transit: The Position of Illegal Foreign Workers and Emerging Labour Law Jurisprudence
Dawn Norton
66

NOTES
Human Rights Protection of Foreign Nationals
Jonathan Klaaren
82

INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
TABLE OF CASES
91

ANNOTATIONS
92

INDEX
98

JUDGMENTS
High Court
Tsika v Buffalo City Municipality (E)
105

Labour Court
Jafta v Ezemvelo KZN Wildlife
131

Kopeledi (Pty) Ltd v Madontsela & others
158

Marsland v New Way Motor & Diesel Engineering
169

SA Bank of Athens Ltd v Cellier NO & others
197

SA Transport & Allied Workers Union & others v Ikhwezi Bus Service (Pty) Ltd
205

Score Supermarket KwaThema v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration & others
215

Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration
Mabena and Blue Pointer Trading 341 (Pty) Ltd t/a Immediate Response (2009)
222

Richard Rentals (Pty) Ltd and National Bargaining Council for the Road Freight Industry (2009)
229

Private Arbitration
Sofiadelis & another and Amazulu Football Club
238



INTERNATIONAL FAMILY LAW
June 2009

Newsline
The Malta Judicial Conference
82

Social Justice and European Family Law
82

Marital Agreements and Private Autonomy: Research Project and Conference
83

UK-Pakistan Protocol
84

Family Law Centre
84

Family Courts in Ireland
85

Greek Law on Cohabitation
85

Commonwealth Conference Hong Kong
86

Annual International Lecture
87

Features
The Autonomy of the Citizen in the Context of Family Law Disputes
Mr Justice Ryder
88

When 'Happily Ever After' is Not: Dissolving Same Sex Marriages in the USA
Joan Catherine Bohl
94

Work of the Office of International Family Justice
Delia Williams
97

Financial Provision: England and Wales v France
Laurence Endre
102

Forum Shopping: Ireland and England
Eugene Davey and Justin Spain
106

The Convergence of Matrimonial and Cohabitee Law in Australia
Ewan Hall
111

Briefings
Law Society Brussels Bulletin: The Fight Against Trafficking and Child Sexual Abuse
Susan Clements
114

The Malta Declaration
Permanent Bureau of the Hague Conference
118

The Council of Europe 7th European Conference: International Family Mediation
Lisa Parkinson
123

School of Natural Law in Serbia
Penny Booth
126

Placement of Children in Jersey
Barbara Corbett
127

Book Review
129

International Websites
130

Diary
136



INTERNATIONAL REVIEW OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY AND COMPETITION LAW
Volume 40       Number 3       2009

Editorial
The Google Book Settlement
H.L. MacQueen
247

Articles
Patent Law's Role in the Protection of the Environment - Re-Assessing Patent Law and Its 
Justifications in the 21st Century
E. Derclaye
249

Seeking a Balanced Interpretation of the Three-Step Test - An Adjusted Structure in View of 
Divergent Approaches
H. He
274

Opinions
European Commission - Green Paper: Copyright in the Knowledge Economy - Comments by the 
Max Planck Institute for Intellectual Property, Competition and Tax Law
R.M. Hilty, S. Krujatz, B. Bajon, A. Früh, A. Kur, J. Drexl, C. Geiger and N. Klass
309

A Hungarian Chapter to the Budweiser Saga
C. Heath
328

Decisions
Patent Law
Canada
Sup. Ct.
6 Nov. 2008
Patents - Medicines - Selection patents - Validity Whether selection patent is invalid on grounds of 
anticipation, obviousness or double patenting - Anticipation - Two-step approach to anticipation - 
Requirements of "prior disclosure" and "enablement" - Obviousness - Four-step approach to 
obviousness - When "obvious to try" test appropriate - Double patenting - Whether doctrine of 
selection patents invalid on ground of double patenting Canadian Patent Act, Sec. 27(1) - 2008 
SCC 61 — Apotex Inc. v. Sanofi-Synthelabo Canada Inc. — "Apotex v. Saneti-Synthelabo"
337

France
Sup. Ct.
26 Feb. 2008
Monopoly cannot be claimed for general principle of functional device already known as such — 
Scope of patent limited to specific manner of implementation — Protection of function described in 
new form and with new means specified in patent — Equivalent infringement — Intellectual 
Property Code, Arts. L. 612-5, L. 613-2 — Jacques Bourgeois and Bourgeois SA v. Pimas 
Orthopédie SA and Braun Corp. (USA) – "Bourgeois v. Pimas"
338

France
Sup. Ct.
26 Feb. 2008
Ruling — Holding that person skilled in the art has professional knowledge from specialism other 
than his own — Setting aside thereof — Intellectual Property Code, Art. L. 611-14 — Newmat SAS 
v. Normalu SA and Thierry Haguenier — "Newmat v. Normalu"
339

Germany
Sup. Ct.
30 Jan. 2008
Valid recourse with respect to priority right — Whether prevented by fact that patent granted on 
subsequent application claims technical effect not indicated in application enjoying priority — Where 
person skilled in the art considers effect obtained self-evident when reproducing disclosed 
invention — EPC, Arts. 87(1), 88(4) — X ZR 107/04 — "Concrete Road Finisher" 
(Betonstraßenfertiger)
340

Copyright Law
USA
CAFC
13 Aug. 2008
Copyright infringement — Scope of open source license — Whether terms of Artistic License are 
both covenants and conditions or merely covenants — Whether terms governed by copyright or 
contract law — Right to exclude — 2008-1001 — Robert Jacobsen v. Matthew Katzer et al. —" 
Jacobsen v. Katzer"
Comment by T. Jaeger and J. Gebert
345

Trade Mark Law
EU — ECJ
27 Nov. 2008
Trade marks with reputation — Protection against use of later identical or similar mark — Use which 
takes or would take unfair advantage of, or is or would be detrimental to, distinctive character or 
repute of earlier trade mark — Directive 89/104, Art. 4(4)(a) — C-252/07 — Intel Corporation Inc. v. 
CPM United Kingdom Ltd. — "Intel/Intelmark"
Comment by D. Slopek
348

Law Relating to Indications of Origin
Hungary
Sup. Ct.
21 March 2007
Applicable provisions on appellations of origin, such as designation of region, locality or country - 
Narrow interpretation - Product name may be added to appellation of origin - Does not apply to 
other statements such as invented designations like brewery location or abbreviation of 
geographical name - Lisbon Agreement for the Protection of Appellations of Origin and Their 
International Registration, Arts. 2, 5(4); Hungarian Trade Mark Law, Sec. 118 - 
Pfv.IV.21.962/2006/5 - Anheuser Busch Inc. v. Budéjovicky Budvar - "Bud"
353

Hungary
Sup. Ct.
28 March 2007
Jurisdiction of national authorities/courts to cancel appellations of origin registered for other 
countries under Lisbon Agreement - Subject-matter of appellation of origin - Beer - Question 
whether place name is official name in relevant national language or name otherwise capable of 
indicating geographical origin - Relevance to eligibility of indication of origin for protection - Lisbon 
Agreement for the Protection of Appellations of Origin and Their International Registration, Art. 2; 
Hungarian Trade Mark Law, Sec. 118 - Pfv.IV.21.153/2006/7 and Pfv.IV.21.165/2006/8 - Anheuser 
Busch Inc. v. Budéjovicky Budvar - "Budweis Beer"
357

Book Reviews
Intellectual Property, Public Policy, and International Trade (Grosse Ruse-Khan)
Govaere and Ullrich (eds.)
362

The Emerging Principles of International Competition Law (Podszun)
Noonan
368



JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL BANKING LAW AND REGULATION
Volume 24       Number 7       2009

Opinion
The Brazilian Sovereign Wealth Fund
WALTER STUBER AND ADRIANA MARIA GÖDEL STUBER
333

Articles
New German Licensing Requirements for Funds Marketed in Germany
BERND M. GEIER
336

Moves Toward Credit Card Industry Reform in the United States
DAVID H. LANE AND MARK A. FOX
348

The Use of Colleges of Regulators under European Union Banking Law
DUNCAN ALFORD
355

Fraud Loss under the Australian Electronic Funds Transfer Code: is it Efficient?
ROBIN EDWARDS
361

Legal Analysis
Nationwide Building Society (Cheshire Building Society) v Dunlop Haywards & Cobbetts
MICHAEL ISAACS
368

Argentina's Central Bank New Regulation on "Combating Money Laundering and Other Illicit 
Activities" and News Regarding Repatriation of Capitals
MARIA VICTORIA PAZ
371

Inbound Investments into India—Structuring the Deal!
ANJALI AGARWAL
375

Book Reviews
The Law of International Finance
TIMOTHY PARSONS
380

Managing International Financial Instability: National Tamers versus Global Tigers
CHIKA B. ONWUEKWE
380

News Section
An International Review of Recent Cases and Legislation
N-63



SRI LANKA JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL LAW
Volume 20       Number 1       2008

The Exercise of Jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court: A Legal and Political Compromise 
which Renders its Effective Functions a rather Complicate Matter
Carlo Tiribelli
1

International Fair Trial Protections in Criminal Trials
Roger Gamble, Noel Dias
25

Same-Sex Couples Marriage in Spain: Conscientious Objection of Judges and Mayors
Salvador Pérez Álvarez
53

Woolmington v Lord Cochrane : A Misdirection of Law and Fact
Lakshman Marasinghe
67

Punishing the Innocent Victim: The Concept of Illegitimacy. A Case for Law Reform
Rose Wijeyesekera
125

Democracy and Participation in Singapore: A Case Study
Mia Mahmudur Rahim
143

The Implications of Trade Agreements Between The U.S. and Arab Countries           With Particular 
Reference to Jordan: A Critique of the Current Legal Framework
Haitham A. Haloush, Bashar H. Malkawi
175

International Legal Personality: Panacea or Pandemonium? Theorizing about the Individual and the 
State in the Era of globalization
Christopher Barbara
243



STELLENBOSCH LAW REVIEW
Volume 20       Number 1       2009

Guidelines for Contributors
1

Outeursinligting
2

Transformative Constitutionalism: Its Implications for the Law of Contract
Dikgang Moseneke
3

The Right to Diplomatic Protection, the Von Abo Decision, and One Big Can of Worms: Eroding the 
Clarity of Kaunda
Dire Tladi
14

Section 39(2) and Shadows of History over the Post-apartheid Constitution [Discussion of Zuma v 
National Director of Public Prosecutions [2009] 1 All SA 54 (N) and National Director of Public 
Prosecutions v Zuma [2009] ZASCA 1]
Wessel le Roux
31

Ensuring Contractual Fairness in Consumer Contracts after Barkhuizen v Napier 2007 5 SA 323 
(CC) — Part 2
PJ Sutherland
50

E-Commerce: a Critique on the Determination of a "Permanent Establishment" for Income Tax 
Purposes from a South African Perspective
Annet Wanyana Oguttu & Sebo Tladi
74

Excess "Other Insurance" Clauses: to Contribute or Subrogate? [Discussion of Samancor Ltd v 
Mutual & Federal insurance Co Ltd 2005 4 SA 40 (SCA)]
Durand M Cupido
97

One Heart, Two Patients: Who Gets a Donor Organ?
Magda Slabbert
124

Ownership of Minerals under the New Legislative Framework for Mineral Resources
HM van den Berg
139

Reviews and Legal Publications Received
159