THE CAMBRIDGE LAW JOURNAL
v.67     no.1    March 2008

CASE AND COMMENT
Administrative law – control orders
Secretary of State for the Home Department v. JJ
Secretary of State for the Home Department v. MB; AF
Secretary of State for the Home Department v. E
1

Deprivation of liberty – control orders
Secretary of State for the Home Department v. JJ
Secretary of State, for the Home Department v. MB; AF
Secretary of State for the Home Department v. E
4

Human Rights Act 1998 – territorial scope
R (Al-Skeini and others) v. Secretary of State for Defence
(The Redress Trust and others intervening)
8

Human rights and public order – protest
Austin and Saxby v. The Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis
10

Judicial review – prerogative Orders in Council 
R (Bancoult) v. Foreign Secretary (No. 2)
12

Human rights – civil liability on public bodies
Van Colle v. Chief Constable of Hertfordshire Police
15

Criminal law: causation and manslaughter
R v. Kennedy (No. 2)
17

Land law – right to park
Moncrieff v. Jamieson
20

Commercial law – trusts of debts
Barbados Trust Co. v. Bank of Zambia 
23

Arbitration – proof of foreign law
Tamil Nadu Electricity Board v. ST-MIS Electric Company, Private Ltd.
25

Tort – risk of future disease as damage
In re Pleural Plaques
28

Freezing terrorist assets
Sison v. Council; Stichting Al-Aqsa v. Council
31

Family law – adoption and duty of local Re C (a Child)
33

SHORTER ARTICLE
From Contract to Umbrella Agreement
STEFANOS MOUZAS AND MICHAEL FURMSTON
37

Kelsen's Endgame
NEIL DUXBURY
51

Auditors' Liability and its Impact on the European Financial Markets
WALTER DORALT, ALEXANDER HELLGARDT ET AL
62

ARTICLES
The Widening Gyre: Counter-terrorism, Human Rights and the Rule of Law
ARTHUR CHASKALSON
69

A Normative Account of Defences to Restitutionary Liability
ROSS GRANTHAM AND CHARLES RICKETT
92

Regulation in a Changing World: Review and Revision of Environmental Permits
COLIN T. REID
126

Competing Conceptions of Modern Desert: Vengeful, Deontological, and Empirical
PAUL H. ROBINSON
145

Sham Trusts
MATTHEW CONAGLEN
176



THE COMPANY LAWYER
Volume 29       NO.5    2008

COMMENT
129

ANALYSIS
Managerial models during the corporate reorganization period and their governance effects: the UK 
and US perspective
131 

Regulating insider trading effectively: lessons from New Zealand
141

NEWS DIGEST
150

BRIEFING
155

INTERNATIONAL
156



THE CRIMINAL LAW REVIEW
Issue 5             May 2008 

Editorial
337

ARTICLES
Causing Death by Driving and Other Offences: A Question of Balance
Michael Hirst
339

Public Nuisance Injunctions Against On-Street Sex Workers?
Tracey Sagar
353

"Up-Skirts" and "Down-Blouses": Voyeurism and the Law
Alisdair A. Gillespie 
370

Case and Comment
383

Global Digest
409



JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION
Volume 25       April 2008        Number 2

SPECIAL ARAB NUMBER
Guest Editor's Note
Nadia Darwazeh 
201

Arbitration in the Arab World: An Interview with Professor Ahmed Sadek El-Kosheri
Nadia Darwazeh and Professor Ahmed Sadek El-Kosheri 
203

The DIAC Rules and the New U.A.E. Arbitration Law Arbitration 
Essam Al Tamimi and Emma van Son 
211

Arbitration in Jordan: From Old to New
Omar M.H. Aljazy 
219

ICC Arbitration in the Arab World
Lara Hammoud and Sami Houerbi 
231

Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards in Maghreb Countries
Ahmed Ouerfelli 
241

How Bilateral Investment Treaties Can Protect Foreign Investors in the Arab World or Arab 
Investors Abroad
Robert T. Greig, Claudia Annacker and Roland Ziadé 
257

Arab Arbitration v. International Arbitration? The Case for a Reconciliation Towards a Reflexive 
Sociology of the Arbitration Field in the Arab World
Jalal El Ahdab and Ruth Stackpool-Moore 
275

Towards a Reflexive Sociology of the Arbitration Field in the Arab World
Abdulhay Sayed 
289

INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION EVENTS CALENDAR
295



WORLD TRADE AND ARBITRATION MATERIALS
Volume 20       April 2008        Number 2

WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION (WTO)
WTO Dispute Settlement

United States- Measures Affecting the Cross-Border Supply of Gambling and Betting Services 
Recourse to Arbitration by the United States under Article 22.6 of the DSU
Decision by the Arbitrator
5

Brazil — Measures Affecting Imports of Retreaded Tyres
Report of the Appellate Body
103

ARBITRAL DECISIONS
International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID)

Azurix Corp v. The Argentine Republic Annulment Proceeding
223

Enron Corporation and Ponderosa Assets, L.P. v. Argentine Republic Decision on Claimants' 
Request for Rectification and/or Supplementary Decision of the Award
243



CIVIL JUSTIC QUARTERLY
Volume 27        Number 2        2008

EDITOR'S NOTE
Finality of Litigation—Setting Aside a Final Judgment
Adrian Zuckerman
151

NOTES
Service—Eliminating Post-Collier v Williams Doubt: Hoddinott v Persimmon Homes (Wessex) Ltd
John Sorabji
158

Contempt of Court for Breaching Mareva Injunction—With a Difference!
David Capper
168

Stubbings v Webb "Stubbed Out"
David Capper
172

ARTICLES
Access to Justice in Courts and Tribunals Compared—Residential Tenancy Disputes in Sydney 
(1971-2004)
Brendan Edgeworth
179

Group Litigation, Class Actions and Lord Woolf's Three Objectives—A Critical Analysis
Susan M.C. Gibbons
208

Mega-Litigation: Towards a New Approach
Justice Ronald Sackville
244

Out With the Owners! The Eurasian Sequels to JA Pye (Oxford) Ltd v United Kingdom
Oliver Jones
260

BOOK REVIEWS
277



EUROPEAN HUMAN RIGHTS LAW REVIEW
Issue 2        2008

OPINION
Human Rights and the Struggle against Terrorism in the United Kingdom
Steven Greer
163

BULLETIN
173

BULLETIN: COUNTER-TERRORISM AND HUMAN RIGHTS
176

ARTICLES
Reparation for Violations of Human Rights under the European Convention and Restitutio in 
Integrum
Loukis G. Loucaides
182

Housing Rights: Positive Duties and Enforceable Rights at the European Court of Human Rights
Dr Padraic Kenna 
193

Breaches of the European Convention on Human Rights Resulting from the Conduct of 
International Organisations
Guglielmo Verdirame
209

Human Rights Adjudication under the ECHR between Value Pluralism and Essential Contestability
Gunnar Beck
214

CASE ANALYSIS
Roma Children and Education in the Czech Republic: DH v Czech Republic: Opening the Door to 
Indirect Discrimination Findings in Strasbourg?
Gemma Hobcraft
245

CASES AND COMMENT
Perry v Latvia (Application No.30273/03)
261

El Majjaoui and Stichting Touba Moskee v Netherlands (Application No.25525/03)
264

DH v Czech Republic (Application No.57325/00)
267

Gault v United Kingdom (Application No.1271/05)
271

Brecknell v United Kingdom (Application No.32457/04)
274 

Wolkenberg v Poland (Application No.50003/99) Witkowska-Tobola v Poland (Application 
No.11208/02)
279

Dickson v United Kingdom (Application No.44362/04)
282

Maumousseau and Washington v France (Application No.39388/05)
285

Stoll v Switzerland (Application No.69698/01)
289

BOOK REVIEWS
294



EUROPEAN LAW REVIEW
Volume 33        Number 2        April 2008

EDITORIAL
Cut off from Europe—the fog surrounding Luxembourg
135

ARTICLES
The Treaty of Lisbon: Process, architecture and substance
Paul Craig
137

Services of general economic interest and universal service in EU law
Wolf Sauter
167

Going local? EU Law, localism and climate change
Chris Hilson
194

Regulatory perspectives on the future of interactive gambling in the internal market
Alan Littler
211

ANALYSIS AND REFLECTIONS
Constitutional conflicts and the third pillar
Dorota Leczykiewicz
230

National normative implementation of EC Regulations: An exceptional or rather common matter?
Richard Král
243

Allocation of jurisdiction and the internet in EU law
Dr Youseph Farah
257

BOOK REVIEWS
271



FEMINIST LEGAL STUDIES
Volume 16        Number 1        April 2008

ENCOUNTERING HUMAN RIGHTS: GENDER/SEXUALITY, ACTIVISM AND THE PROMISE OF 
LAW

Edited by Emily Grabham and Rosemary Hunter

Special Issue - Encountering Human Rights: Gender/Sexuality, Activism and the Promise of Law
EMILY GRABHAM, ROSEMARY HUNTER
1

Faith in the State? Asian Women's Struggles for Human Rights in the U.K.
PRAGNA PATEL
9

A "Quick and Dirty" Approach to Women's Emancipation and Human Rights?
SARI KOUVO
37

The Right to Culture and the Culture of Rights: A Critical Perspective on Women's Sexual Rights in 
Africa
SYLVIA TAMALE
47

Rape as `Torture'? Catharine MacKinnon and Questions of Feminist Strategy
CLARE MCGLYNN
71

“We Cannot Claim Any Particular Knowledge of the Ways of Homosexuals, Still Less of Iranian 
Homosexuals ...": The Particular Problems Facing Those Who Seek Asylum on the Basis of their 
Sexual Identity
BARRY O'LEARY
87

INTERVIEW
"It's Another Way of Making a Really Big Fuss" Human Rights and Women's Activism in the United 
Kingdom: An Interview with Tania Pouwhare
TANIA POUWHARE and EMILY GRABHAM
97

BOOK REVIEWS
Catharine A. MacKinnon: Are Women Human? And Other International Dialogues
Reviewed by OLGA PALEVICH
113

Hilary Lim, Anne Bottomley (eds.): Feminist Perspectives on Land Law
Reviewed by CAROLINE HUNTER
117

Richard Collier, Sally Sheldon (eds.): Fathers' Rights Activism and Law Reform in Comparative 
Perspective
Reviewed by TONY HOBBS
121

Judy Fudge, Rosemary Owens (eds.): Precarious Work, Women, and the New Economy: The 
Challenge to Legal Norms 
Reviewed by REBECCA GREENLAND
125

Sarah van Walsum, Thomas Spijkerboer (eds.): Women and Immigration Law: New Variations on 
Classical Feminist Themes
Reviewed by PATRICIA TUITT
129

Jasmina Luki?, Joanna Regulska and Darja Zaviršek (eds.): Women and Citizenship in Central and 
Eastern Europe
Reviewd by ANNELI ALBI
133

Books Received in 2007
SIMONE WONG
137

ERRATUM
Domestic Abuse, Civil Protection Orders and the `New Criminologies': Is There Any Value in 
Engaging with the Law?
CLARE CONNELLY and KATE CAVANAGH
139



INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LAW, POLICY AND THE FAMILY
Volume 22          Number 1        April 2008

The Best Interest of The Child as an Argument in Assessments of Parent Potential in Sweden
Judith Lind
1

Obligations Between Adult Partners: Moving From Form to Function?
Lisa Glennon
22

Family, Social Inequalities, and the Persuasive Force of Interpersonal Obligation
Lucinda Ferguson
61

Trends in Non-Muslim Divorces in Singapore
Wing-Cheong Chan
91

Choice of Law in International Child Support Obligations: Hague or Vague, and Does it Matter? - An 
American Perspective
David S . Rosettenstein
122

Children's Rights to Representation: A Comparison Between Sweden and England
Eva Ryrstedt and Titti Mattsson
135



THE SYDNEY LAW REVIEW
Volume 30        Number 1        March 2008

SPECIAL ISSUE: CONSTITUTIONAL LAW

ARTICLES
The Constitutional Jurisprudence of the High Court: 1989–2004
Michael McHugh
5

Constitutional Issues Regarding Same-Sex Marriage: A Comparative Survey — North America and 
Australasia
Geoffrey Lindell
27

The Separation of Powers and Legislative Interference in Pending Cases
Peter Gerangelos
61

Comment
Anthony Mason
95

Preserving Due Process or Warehousing the Undesirables: To What End the Separation of Judicial 
Power of the Commonwealth?
Patrick Keyzer
101

Comment
Elizabeth Handsley
115

Some Observations on the Common Law and the Constitution
Pamela Tate
121

Still Call Australia Home: The Constitution and the Citizen's Right of Abode
Helen Irving
133

Judicial Appointment
Ruth McColl
155

Judicial Appointment
Stephen Gageler
159

High Court Appointments: The Need for Reform
George Williams
163

BOOK REVIEW
The Assignment of Contractual Rights by Greg Tolhurst
J D Heydon
171



CRIMINAL LAW JOURNAL
Volume 32        Number 2        April 2008

EDITORIAL
Australia's ongoing response to the terrorism threat
69

ARTICLES
Preventative detention in Australian law: Issues of interpretation
Claire Macken
71

Proscribing terrorist organisations: Legislation and practice in five English-speaking democracies
Roger Douglas
90

German perspectives on the right to life and human dignity in the "war on terror"
Saskia Hufnagel
100

CASE AND COMMENT
Thomas v Mowbray
Dr Greg Martin
114

DIGEST OF CRIMINAL LAW CASES
120



DALHOUSIE JOURNAL OF LEGAL STUDIES
Volume 17        2008

ARTICLES
The Buck Stops Where? A Critique Of Vicarious Liability In The Medical Malpractice Context
C.J. Colwell
1

"This Is What The Others Have Done": The Impact Of Confederation On The Use Of Precedent In 
Newfoundland Supreme Court Decisions From 1932-1958
Krista M. Atkins
41

The Role Of Dignity In Canadian And South African Gender Equality Jurisprudence
Andrew Foster
73

Shushing The New Aesthetic Vocabulary: Appropriation Art Under The Canadian Copyright Regime
Karen Lowe
99

Stepping Forward Or Stumbling Back? Command Responsibility For Failure To Act, Civilian 
Superiors And The International Criminal Court
Daniel Watt
141

Valuing Companion Animals: Alternatives To Market Value
Jessica Dellow
175



EUROPEAN REVIEW OF PRIVATE LAW
Volume 16        Number 2        2008

Articles/Articles/Aufsätze

The European Convention on Human Rights and Environmental Nuisances
SABRINA PRADUROUX
269

The Common Denominator of the Trafigura Case, Foreign Direct Liability Cases and the Rome II 
Regulation
LIESBETH ENNEKING
283

Recent developments/développements r?cents/Aktuelle Abläufe

Gutgläubiger Eigentumserwerb als gesetzliches Limit des verfassungsrechtlich gewährleisteten 
Rechts auf Eigentum
PETRA J. PIPKOVA
313

La loi de la Féderation de Russie relative aux biens culturels deplaces en URSS dans le cadre de la 
Seconde guerre mondiale
DMITRYA. PENTSOV
323

Comments on Form and Function of Legal Precedents
KONSTANTINOS D. KERAMEUS
333

Case notes/Annotations/Entscheidungsanmerkungen

House of Lords 3 May 2006, UKHL [2006] 20, Barker v. Corus. Neue Impulse für das Europäische 
Deliktsrecht vom House of Lords
By CONSTANTIN KRUSE and STEFAN GEIGER
339

ECHR 30 August 2007, Pye v. United Kingdom. A Technical Retreat from Private (Property) Law
By J.M. MILO
353

Book reviews/Comptes rendus/Buchbesprechungen

Marcus Lutter e.a., Legal Capital in Europe - European Company and Financial Law Review Special 
Volume 1, Berlin, 2006
By HAN VAN MANEN
363

Josef Wolff, Trust, Fiducia und fiduziarische Treuhand (zugl. Diss. Universität Salzburg), Peter 
Lang Verlag, Frankfurt am Main 2005, S. 387
By MIKE WIENBRACKE
365

Willem H. Van Boom and Marco Loos (eds), Collective Enforcement of Consumer Law: Securing 
Compliance in Europe through Private Group Action and Public Authority Intervention, Europa Law 
Publishing, Groningen 2007
By W.C.H. ERVINE
371

Report/La vie du droit/Erfahrungsbericht

Conference 'CFR and Existing EC Contract Law', Münster, 10-11 December 2007
By ANNA VERENA LAUBER
375

IV International Congress 'European Private Law Beyond the CFR', Lleida, 25-26 October 2007
By JOAN M. RIUS RIU
381

Index 2007
383

List of Contributors
389



INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EDUCATION
Number 11       July 2007

Foreword
5

Articles
"How do you feel about this client?" A commentary on the clinical model as a vehicle for teaching 
ethics to law students
Kevin Kerrigan
7

Clinical Legal Education in the Law University: Goals and Challenges
Margaret Martin Barry
27

Clinical legal education and Indigenous legal education: what's the connection?
Anna Cody and Sue Green
51

Clinical Practice
Constructing a Clinical Legal Education Approach for Large Multicultural Classes: Insights from the 
Nigerian Law School
Ada Okoye Ordor
65



INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISCRIMINATION AND THE LAW
Volume 9       Number 2       2007

CONTENTS

Editorial
71

'Modernising Discrimination Law': Proposals for a Single Equality Act for Great Britain
Maleiha Malik
73

Discriminating Material? Legal Liability of Employers for Job Advertisements
Sam Middlemiss
95

Withholding Party Funding from a `Discriminating' Political Party
Marjolein Busstra and Jogchum Vrielink
113



JOURNAL OF ENERGY & NATURAL RESOURCES LAW
Volume 26        Number 1        March 2008

Special Issue: Indigenous and Local Peoples and Resource Development: International 
Comparisons of Law, Policy and Practice
Co-Editors: Lee Godden, Marcia Langton, Odette Mazel and Maureen Tehan

Introduction: Accommodating Interests in Resource Extraction: Indigenous Peoples, Local 
Communities and the Role of Law in Economic and Social Sustainability
Lee Godden, Marcia Langton, Odette Mazel and Maureen Tehan
1

Poverty in the Midst of Plenty: Aboriginal People, the 'Resource Curse' and Australia's Mining Boom
Marcia Langton and Odette Mazel
31

Indigenous Employment in the Australian Mining Industry
David Brereton and Joni Parmenter
66

Corporate Social Responsibility, Legislative Reforms and Mining in South Africa
Henk Kloppers and Willemien du Plessis
91

Development Forum in Papua New Guinea: Upsides and Downsides
Colin Filer
120

Five Principles for the Management of Natural Resource Revenue: the Case of Timor-Leste's 
Petroleum Revenue
Jennifer Drysdale
151

General Index
175