CANADIAN JOURNAL OF WOMEN AND THE LAW
Volume 21       Number 1       2009

Law, Film and Feminism

Editorial

Editorial "Take Two"

Articles
Rapport minoritaire: La dissidence fait juge
Marie-Claire Belleau, Valérie Bouchard et Rebecca Johnson
1

Women in Prison Movies as Feminist Jurisprudence
Suzanne Bouclin
19

High: Marijuana, Women, and the Law
Susan C. Boyd
35

Penguins and Polyamory: Using Law and Film to Explore the Essence of Marriage in Canadian 
Family Law
Gillian Calder
55

“We Walk Among You”: Trans Identity Politics Goes to the Movies
Sharon Cowan
91

North Country’s Hero and Her Cinematic Lawyer: Can “Lawyer Films” and “Women’s Films” Merge 
to Launch a New Feminist Sub-Genre?
Orit Kamir
119

Putting a Dominatrix in Her Place: The Representation and Regulation of Female Dom/Male Sub 
Sexuality
Ummni Khan
143

The Cook, the Mediator, the Feminist, and the Hero
Jennifer L. Schulz
177

Using Film in the Classroom: The Call and the Responses
197

Film Review
Expiation: les aggressions sexuelles et les fausses perceptions
Louise Langevin
211

About the Contributors
215

Information for Contributors
219

Renseignements généraux
223



GRIFFITH LAW REVIEW
Volume 18       Number 2       2009

Symposium: The Lex of Somatechnics

The Lex of Somatechnics
Joseph Pugliese and Maria Giannacopoulos
207

No-Bodies: Law, Raciality and Violence
Denise Ferreira da Silva
212

What is Due to Others: Speaking and Signifying Subject(s) of Rape Law
Penny Pether
237

Legal Responses to Body Burdens: Discourses on Low-Dose Toxicity
David S Caudill
259

Beyond the Script of Law: Dildos, Tranny Cops and Protesting Anti-Terrorism
Juliet Rogers
269

The War Against Animals: Domination, Law and Sovereignty
Dinesh Joseph Wadiwel
283

Reading the Evidentiary Void: The Body at the Scene of Writing
Trish Luker
298

Preincident Indices of Criminality: Facecrime and Project Hostile Intent
Joseph Pugliese
314

The Nomos of Apologia
Maria Giannacopoulos
331

General Articles
The Constitutional Power to Make War: Domestic Legal Issues Raised by Australia's Action in Iraq
Charles Sampford and Margaret Palmer
350

New Adventures of Old Pauline Law
Tawia Ansah
385

Fatwas: Their Role in Contemporary Secular Australia
Ann Black and Nadirsyah Hosen
405

Reflections on Transgender Immigration
Nan Seuffert
428

Employment Entitlements to Carer's Leave: Domesticating Diverse Subjectivities
Anna Chapman
453

Development in the 'First World': Alleviating Indigenous Disadvantage in Australia — the Dilemma of 
Difference
Odette Mazel
475

Every Body is Different: Regulating the Use (and Non-Use) of Cosmetic Surgery, Body Modification 
and Reproductive Genetic Testing
Tony Bogdanoski
503

INFORMATION FOR AUTHORS
529



INDUSTRIAL LAW JOURNAL: INCLUDING THE INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
Volume 30       October 2009

HIGHLIGHTS OF THE INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
iii

ARTICLES
Self-regulated Corporate Social Responsibility: The Impact on Employment Relations at European 
Corporations in South and Southern Africa: A Preliminary Overview
Darcy du Toit
2227

The Employee's Right to Procedural Fairness in the Context of Transfers of Businesses
Craig Bosch
2253

Implying Fairness into the Employment Contract
Tamara Cohen
2271

NOTES
The Common Law of Contract Adapts to the Twenty First Century: A Note on SA Music Rights 
Organisation Ltd v Mphatsoe, Labournet Payment Solutions (Pty) Ltd v Vosloo and Jafta v 
Ezemvelo KZN Wildlife
A A Landman
2296

Conflicting Interpretations of Section 191(12) of the LRA
June Wilson
2305

INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
TABLE OF CASES
2311

ANNOTATIONS
2313

INDEX
2320

JUDGMENTS
Supreme Court of Appeal
Volvo (Southern Africa) (Pty) Ltd v Yssel
2333

High Court
Gunter v Compensation Commissioner (O)
2341

Majake v Commission for Gender Equality & others (SGJ)
2349

Visagie NO v Vergoedingskommissaris & 'n ander (T)
2366

Labour Appeal Court
Hendor Steel Supplies (A Division of Argent Steel Group (Pty) Ltd formerly named Marschalk 
Beleggings (Pty) Ltd) v National Union of Metalworkers of SA & others
2376

Member of the Executive Council, Department of Education, Eastern Cape Province v Gqebe
2388

Labour Court
Anglo Platinum Ltd v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration & others
2396

Colven Associates Border CC v Metal & Engineering Industries Bargaining Council & others
2406

Corruseal Corrugated Gauteng (Pty) Ltd & another: In re Corruseal Corrugated Gauteng (Pty) Ltd v 
Van Niekerk & another
2412

Datt v Gunnebo Industries (Pty) Ltd
2429

Labournet Payment Solutions (Pty) Ltd v Vosloo
2437

Lekabe v Minister: Department of Justice & Constitutional Development
2444

Niewoudt v All-Pak
2451

Owen & others v Department of Health, KwaZulu-Natal
2461

SA Chemical Workers Union v Unitrans Supply Chain Solutions (Pty) Ltd t/a Unitrans Freight & 
Logistics & another
2469

SA Commercial Catering & Allied Workers Union v Ellerine Holdings (Pty) Ltd t/a Ellerine Furniture 
(Pty) Ltd & Ellerine Trading (Pty) Ltd
2476

SA Music Rights Organisation Ltd v Mphatsoe
2482

Shoprite Checkers (Pty) Ltd v Sebotha NO & others
2491

Solidarity on behalf of Steyn v Minister of Correctional Services
2508

Trustees for the time being of the National Bioinformatics Network Trust v Jacobson & others
2513

Verity v University of the Witwatersrand
2518

Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration
Mashigoane and Imperial Bank Ltd
2526

Nqongwa and Lentaba Meat (Ply) Ltd
2533

OCGAWU on behalf of Members and KLK Landbou Bpk
2538

PETUSA on behalf of Rootman and Absa
2544

Sebati and Rens Security Services
2564

Bargaining Council Arbitration
Chuma and Giflo Engineering (Bop) (Pty) Ltd
2572



JOURNAL OF WORLD TRADE
Volume 43       Number 6       December 2009

The Role of the Chair in the WTO Negotiations from the Potsdam Collapse in June 2007 to July 
2008
Faizel Ismail
1145

The TRIPS Agreement and Its Effects on the R&D Spending of US-Owned Multinational 
Companies in Developing Countries
Darnita York Akers and Sencer Ecer
1173

Green Farm Subsidies Sponsoring Eco Labeling: Is the Separation of Market Access and Subsidies 
Regulation in WTO Law Sustainable?
Laura Nielsen
1193

Definition of the Concept 'International Standard' in the TBT Agreement
Humberto Zúñiga Schroder
1223

Accountability and Legitimacy in Global Health and Safety Governance: The World Trade 
Organization, the SPS Committee, and International Standard-Setting Organizations
Yoshiko Naiki
1255

EU Trade Defence Actions against China and Their Impacts: The Cases of Textiles and Footwear
Louise Curran
1281

Global Governance Quandaries Regarding Transformative Technologies for Bioproducts, Crops, 
and Foods
Stuart Smyth, Peter W.B. Phillips and William A. Kerr
1299

For a New Classification System of Domestic Support in the WTO Agreement on Agriculture
Valentin Zahrnt
1325

Index
1345



LAW & POLICY
Volume 32       Number 1       January 2010

Reorienting Regulation: Pollution Enforcement in Industrializing Countries
Lesley K. McAllister. Benjamin van Rooij, and Robert A. Kagan
1

Fragile Convergence: Understanding Variation in the Enforcement of China's Industrial Pollution 
Law
Benjamin van Rooij and Carlos Wing-Hung Lo
14

Consequences of Decentralization: Environmental Impact Assessment and Water Pollution Control 
in Indonesia
Adriaan Bedner
38

Dimensions of Enforcement Style: Factoring in Regulatory Autonomy and Capacity
Lesley K. McAllister
61

On the Frontlines: Making Decisions in Chinese Civil Environmental Lawsuits
Rachel E. Stern
79

The Fiscal Imperative and the Role of Public Prosecutors in Brazilian Environmental Policy
Bernardo Mueller
104

Greening Industry Without Enforcement? An Assessment of the World Bank's Pollution Regulation 
Model for Developing Countries
Benjamin van Rooij
127

Regulating the Oil Palm Boom: Assessing the Effectiveness of Environmental Governance 
Approaches to Agro-industrial Pollution in Indonesia
John McCarthy and Zahari Zen
153



MCGILL LAW JOURNAL
Volume 54       Number 3       Autumn 2009

PERSPECTIVE
Le rayonnement intellectual de Jean Carbonnier au Québec : le succès d'estime d'un honnête 
homme
Jean-Guy Belley
407

ARTICLES
Canadian Bijuralism and the Concept of an Acquisition of Property in the Federal Income Tax Act
David G. Duff
423

Regulating Greenhouse Gases in Canada: Constitutional and Policy Dimensions
Shi-Ling Hsu and Robin Elliot
463

The Confessions Rule and the Charter
Hamish Stewart
517

Le droit à l’information des patients gardés en établissement: un instrument essentiel de promotion 
des valeurs démocratiques et du statut citoyen
Emmanuelle Bernheim
547



MEDICINE AND LAW
Volume 28       Number 4       December 2009

Health Law
Legal Aspects Of The Withholding And Withdrawing Of Intensive Care In Extremely Premature 
Infants
E. Delbeke
581

Medical Law
Cultural Influences On Medical Law
S. Levy
593

Clinical Guidelines As A Tool For Legal Liability
J. Davies
603

Comparative Analysis Of Medicolegal Compensation For Occupational Cancers In France And 
Other Western European Countries: Development Proposals
B. Clin
615

Medical Ethics
Methodological And Ethical Quality In Phase III — Breast Cancer Trials
V. Thoma et al
637

The Importance Of The Training Of Ethics Committee Members
G. Ricci and N. Cannovo
649

Patients' Rights
Patient Mobility In The European Union: Pushing For EU Internal Health Market
I. Lang
661

Patient Mobility Migration And Mitigation — The Devil And The Deep Blue Sea
N. Kirby
673

Forensic Psychology
The Field Of Forensic Psychology In Israel — The State Of The Discipline
M. Zaki
688

Pharmaceutical Law
Pharmacists Responsibility And Potential Liability Regarding Generic Substitution
H. Hattingh
697

Nursing Law
Patient Violence Towards Nursing Staff In Closed Psychiatric Wards: It's Long-Term Effects On 
Staff's Mental State And Behaviour
Y. Yarovitsky and N. Tabak
705

End-of-Life
Legal Aspects Of End-Of-Life Decision Policies In Health Care Institutions
S. Tack
725

Euthanasia
They Shoot Horses, Don't They? How Valid Are The Arguments Of Opponents Against Euthanasia?
W. Martens
739

Belgian Act On Euthanasia: Alterations To Be Expected?
M. Van Overstraeten
755

Index
769



SOUTH AFRICAN LAW JOURNAL
Volume 126       Number 2       2009

ABSTRACTS
209

NOTES
Freedom of expression and the statutory regulation of 'political' advertising in the broadcast media
Daniel Malan Pretorius and Livia Dyer
213

Placing human rights at the centre of public health: A critique of Minister of Health, Western Cape v 
Goliath
Marius Pieterse and Adila Hassim
231

Less is more: Senwes and the concept of 'margin squeeze' in South African competition law
Luke Kelly and Tjarda van der Vijver
246

Pre-incorporation contracts: statutory reform
Caroline B Ncube
255

ARTICLES
Breaking the tie: evictions from private land, homelessness and a new normality
Stuart Wilson
270

Costs sanctions: the critical instrument in the development of commercial mediation in South Africa
Ronán Feehily
291

National interest in anti-dumping investigations
Gustav Brink
316

Privacy, HIV/AIDS and public health interventions
Stefanie Roehrs
360

R v Kapp: A model for South African affirmative action jurisprudence?
JL Pretorius
398

Correspondence
422



SYDNEY LAW REVIEW
Volume 31       Number 4       December 2009

Articles
Risks, Rights, Statistics and Compulsory Measures
Denise Meyerson
507

False Imprisonment, Fare Dodging and Federation: Mr Robertson’s Evening Out
Mark Lunney
537

Distinguishing Government and Charity in Australia Law
Matthew Harding
559

Reducing the Burden of Proving Discrimination in Australia
Dominique Allen
579

Case Note
Betting Across Borders—Betfair Pty Limited v Western Australia
Naomi Oreb
607



UNIVERSITY OF TASMANIA LAW REVIEW
Volume 28       Number 1       2009

Keynote Address
Sparing Parents Pain or Spoiling the Child by the Rod: Human Rights Arguments against Corporal 
Punishment
JOCELYNNE SCUTT
1

Articles
To Suspend or Not to Suspend: A Qualitative Analysis of Sentencing Decisions in the Supreme 
Court of Tasmania
LORANA BARTELS
23

Prejudicial Publicity: When Will it Ever Result in a Permanent Stay of Proceedings?
CRAIG BURGESS
63

Charting Opposition to Human Rights Charters: New Arguments or Recycled Objections?
GREG CARNE
81

Case Note
Fauna v Forestry: The Wielangta Forest Litigation
IMRAN CHURCH
125

Book Reviews
Implementing Human Rights Norms: Judicial Discretion and the Use of Unincorporated Conventions
SIMON MCKENZIE
139

Calling out the Troops: The Australian Military and Civil Unrest, the Legal and Constitutional Issues
SARAH BURY
141
CANADIAN BUSINESS LAW JOURNAL
Volume 48       Number 2       December 2009

ARTICLES AND SYMPOSIA
Symposium on the Supreme Court's BCE Judgment
173

Flexibility vs. Certainty: The Law Relating to Arrangements after BCE
Anita I. Anand
174

BCE and the Long Shadow of American Corporate Law
MOhammad Fadel
190

Fiduciary Outs and Maximizing Shareholder Value following BCE
Jeremy D. Fraiberg
213

Indeterminacy and the Canadian Supreme Court's Approach to Corporate Fiduciary Duties
Edward lacobucci
232

BCE and the Peoples' Corporate Law: Learning to live on Quicksand
Jeffrey G. Macintosh
255

BCE Inc. (Re): An Unexamined Question Considered
J. Alex Moore
273

A Comment on BCE Inc.
James C. Tory
285

Ontario Personal Property Security Act Reform: Significant Policy Changes
Michael E. Burke
289

COMMENTARIES
Renewed Friction between Provincial PPSAs and Bank Act Chattel Security Interests
Jacob Ziegel
312

REVIEW ESSAYS AND BOOK REVIEWS
Property Rights in Money, by David Fox
Benjamin Geva
324

Business Organizations: Principles, Policies and Practices, by Robert Yalden, Janis Sarra, Paul D. 
Paton, Mark Gillen, Ronald Davis and Mary Condon
Mohamed F. Khimji
332

General Principles of Canadian Insurance Law, by Barbara Billingsley
Lorraine Lafferty
339



CRIMINAL LAW JOURNAL
Volume 33       Number 6       December 2009

EDITORIAL
Challenges ahead for human rights and criminal justice
305

ARTICLES
Public interest immunity claims in national security trials and the role of special counsel
Trent Glover
309

Hate crime laws in Australia: Are they achieving their goals?
Gail Mason
326

Human rights, human dignity and the right to die: Lessons from Europe on assisted suicide
Brendan Murphy
341

CASE AND COMMENT
Kylie Weston-Scheuber

Totani v South Australia: Organised crime laws under fire
357

VOLUME 33 — 2009
Table of Authors
365

Table of Cases
367

Index
381



DALHOUSIE LAW JOURNAL
Volume 32       Number 1       Spring 2009

Parents, Children, and the Law of Assault
Hamish Stewart
1

Structures of Judgment: How the Modern Supreme Court of Canada Organizes its Reasons
Peter McCormick
35

Principles, Prescriptions, and Polemics: Regulating Conflicts of Interest in the Canadian Investment 
Fund Industry
Dan Awrey
69

A Proposed Transjudicial Approach to s. 15(2) Charter Adjudication
Vanita Goela
109

Caesar’s Faith: Limited Government and Freedom of Religion in Bruker v. Marcovitz
F.C. DeCoste
153

Service to the Nation: A Living Legal Value for Justice Lawyers in Canada
Josh Wilner
177



EDUCATION & LAW JOURNAL
Volume 19       Number 2       December 2009

ARTICLES
A Comparative Study of Environmental Law Clinics in the United States and China
XU WEI
75

Violence in Schools: Examining the Differential Impact of School Climate on Student's Coping Ability
CHIANG-LE HENG, ALAN LESCHIED, AND STEVE KILLIP
95

The Value of Educational Law to Practising Educators
JEROME G. DELANEY
119

CASE NOTES
School Boards May Be Liable for Teachers' Failure to Ensure Students Are Progressively Taught
LAURA JOHNSON
139

MSIP Supervision: Must MSIP Teachers Supervise "Passers-by"?
SIMON BLACKSTONE
143

Committee's Denial of Admission to School for the Deaf Overturned by Ontario Superior Court
ANDREA WOBICK
147

Can Experience Teaching in a Prison be Considered in Determining a Public School Teacher's 
Salary?
NATASHA DE MENNA
151



INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISCRIMINATION AND THE LAW
Volume 10       Number 1       2009

Editorial
1

Direct Discrimination: Limited by Definition?
Jane Mair
3

Equality: a Fundamental Right in the European Union?
Erica Howard
19

Employer’s Legal Liability for Sexual Harassment of Employees by Third Parties
Sam Middlemiss
39

Book review
Discrimination Law: Theory and Context
Nicholas Bamforth, Maleiha Malik and Colm O’Cinneidi
51



JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL MARITIME LAW
Volume 15       Number 4       July-August 2009

EDITORIAL
BIMCO Piracy Clauses
291

DIGEST OF CONTEMPORARY DEVELOPMENTS
293

ANALYSIS AND COMMENT
Important new US second circuit ruling on dangerous cargo
In Re M/V DG Harmony
533 F.3d 83 (2d Cir. 2008)
THOMAS J. SCHOENBAUM
300

Inherent vice as an excluded peril in marine insurance
Global Process Systems Inc and Another v Syarikat Takaful Malaysia Berhad (The Cendor MOPU)
[2009] EWHC 637 (Comm); [2009] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 72
302

ARTICLES
Piracy for ransom: insurance issues
PAUL TODD
307

‘Warships’ in the North Sea Continental Shelf cases: Why the definition of ‘warship’ for determining 
sovereign immunity settled 25 years ago
BRIAN SPIELMAN
322

NATIONAL REPORT
The civil liability regime for vessel source oil pollution in china
PROFESSOR HONGJUN SHAN & JINLEI ZHANG
340

INTERNATIONAL AND REGIONAL ORGANISATIONS
EU—A snapshot of some recent EU legal developments
358

IMO Legal Committee meeting 5-9 October 2009
361

IOPC Fund meetings 12-17 October 2009
364

BOOK REVIEWS
Scrutton on Charterparties and Bills of Lading (21st edn)
Stewart Boyd CBE, QC; Bernard Eder QC; Andrew Burrows QC (Hon); David Foxton QC; Steven 
Berry QC; Christopher Smith
367

A Practical Guide to International Arbitration in London
Hilary Heilbron QC
368

Index of cases

Index of legislation

Index



JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION
Volume 26       Number 6       December 2009

Issues Relevant to the Termination of Bilateral Investment Treaties
Andrea Carska-Sheppard
755

Anatomy of the Law and Practice of Interim Protective Measures in International Investment 
Arbitration
Régis Bismuth
773

Privilege in International Arbitration: Is It Time to Recognize the Consensus?
Craig Tevendale and Ula Cartwright-Finch
823

Enforcement of Arbitral Awards in Indochina —Law, Practice, and Alternatives
Alastair Henderson
841

Waiver of Sovereign Immunity from Execution: Arbitration is Not Enough
Nicholas Pengelley
859

Swedish Court Decisions on Arbitration, 1999 to 2008
Sigvard Jarvin
873

NOTES AND CURRENT DEVELOPMENTS
Comment on West tankers Inc. v RAS Riunione Adriatica di Sicurta S.p.A. (the Front Comor)
Jacob Grierson
891

Comment on Dallah v. Pakistan: Refusal of Enforcement of an ICC Arbitration Award against a Non-
Signatory
Jacob Grierson and Dr. Mireille Taok
903

INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION EVENTS CALENDAR
909

INDEX
911



JOURNAL OF LEGAL HISTORY
Volume 30       Number 3       December 2009

Felony Forfeiture in England, c. 1170-1870
K.J. Kesslring
201

Controlling Jury Composition in Nineteenth-Century Ireland
Níamh Howlin
227

‘Law Reporting’ in Europe in the Early-Modern Period: Two Experiences in Comparison
Dolores Freda
263

Research Note: The Codification of the Jury Procedure in Hungary
Tamás Antal
279

Major Accessions to Repositories in 2008 Relating to Legal History
299

Table of Contents to Volume 30
309



JOURNAL OF WORLD INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY
Volume 13       Number 1       January 2010

Is the Non-Patentability of "Essentially Biological Processes" Under Threat?
Sigrid Sterckx
1

Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights and Access to Medication: 
Does Egypt Have Sufficient Safeguards Against Potential Public Health Implications of the 
Agreement
Heba Wank
24

Patenting Nanotechnology in Europe: Making a Good Start? An Analysis of Issues in Law and 
Regulation
Maurice Schellekens
47



QUEEN’S LAW JOURNAL
Volume 35       Number 1       Fall 2009

Emerging Paradigms of Rationality
Introduction: Emerging Paradigms of Rationality—Theory and Applications
Cherie Metcalf
1

Beyond Liability: Correcting Optimism Bias Through Tort Law
Barbara Luppi & Francesco Parisi
47

The Contextual Rationality of the Precautionary Principle
David Dana
67

Feel-Good Formalism
Anna Gelpern & Mitu Gulati
97

Embodied Rationality
Barbara A. Spellman & Simone Schnall
117

The Perils of the Partial Spectator
David McGowan
165

Rationality in an Unjust World: A Research Agenda
Claire A. Hill
185

Exploring a Feminist Theory of Harm in the Context of Conflicted and Post-Conflict Societies
Fionnuala Ní Aoláin
219

Expanded Rationality: From the Preferred to the Desirable, with Some Implications for Law
Amir N. Licht
245

Rules, Rationality, and the Significance of Standpoint
Frederick Schauer
305

Leading You Down the Choice Path: Rational Persuasion as Collective Rationality
Bruce Chapman
327

Reason’s Ends: Ecological Rationality and Moral Judgment
William D. Casebeer
359

Tribute
Robert Sutherland: Celebrating the Legacy
Deidré Rowe Brown
401

Comment
Discrimination in the Rules of Indian Status and the McIvor Case
Sébastien Grammond
421

Review
Guy Régimbald, Canadian Administrative Law
Joshua A. Krane
433