AUSTRALIAN BAR REVIEW
Volume 32       Number 2       July 2009

Articles
Australian business law in international perspective; Remarks at a book launch
The Hon J J Spigelman AC
133

Beyond the text: A vision of the structure and function of the Constitution
Stephen Gageler
138

Modem approaches to the construction and interpretation of Contracts
F M Douglas
158

Muddying the waters further — Kennon v Spry: 'ownership', 'control' and the discretionary trust
Lee Aitken
173

Undoing unjust contracts: Developments in jurisprudence under the Contracts Review Act 1980 
(NSW)
Mandy Tibbey
182

Judicial attitudes to plain language and the law
Kathryn O'Brien
204

Book Review
Appealing to the Future: Michael Kirby and his Legacy by Ian Freckleton and Hugh Selby (Eds)
M G Sexton SC SG
246

History's Page
251



BANKING & FINANCE LAW REVIEW
Volume 24       Number 3       June 2009

ARTICLES
Economic Rehabilitation: Understanding the Growth in Consumer Proposals under Canadian 
Insolvency Legislation
DR. JANIS SARRA
383

Revisiting the Lender of Last Resort
ANDREW CAMPBELL & ROSA LASTRA
453

Legal Aspects of Credit Transfers and Electronic Payments: a Belgian Perspective
REINHARD STEENNOT
499

RECENT DEVELOPMENTS
CDIC Granted Extraordinary Powers over Troubled Institutions
BLAIR W. KEEFE & WESLEY ISAACS
539

Non-Novel Issues of Letter of Credit Law: An Essay
JOHN F. DOLAN
551

Protection of Home Purchasers in Israel
SHALOM LERNER
579

CASE NOTES AND COMMENTS
Acting in the Rest Interests of the Corporation: To Whom is this Duty Owed by Canadian Directors? 
The Supreme Court of Canada in the Bet Case Clarifies the Duty
ROBERT E. MILNES
601

BOOK REVIEWS
Financial Institutions: The Regulatory Framework
M.H. OGILVIE
619

Banking Laws in China
WEN LI
623

International Economic Law: The State and Future of the Discipline
DAVID COLLINS
629



BOND LAW REVIEW
Volume 21       Number 1       June 2009

Articles
Civil Liberties, Bjelke-Petersen & A Bill of Rights: Lessons for Queensland
Christopher Crawford
1

Section 76(III): 'Of Admiralty and Maritime Jurisdiction
Damien Cremean
25

Does Law Follow Money?
Robin Edwards
41

Herbert Vere Evatt: Jurist, Politician, Person—The Paradox
Scott Guy
65

Estoppel in the Jurisprudence of the ICJ: A principle promoting stability threatens to undermine it
Alexander Ovchar
124

Book Reviews
‘457 Visa Law — Addressing Australia's Skilled Labour Shortage', by Maria Jockel, Lawbook Co, 
2009
Hwee Cheng Goh
158

Restraining Electoral Dictatorship-The Upper House Solution? Edited by Nicholas Aroney, Scott 
Prasser And J R Nethercote, University Of Western Australia Press, 2008
Ian Stevens
159

Attorney And Client: Obligations And Privileges, Edited By P L Jayanthi Reddy, Amicus Books, The 
ICFAI University Press, 2008
Lee Stuesser
161



CANADIAN JOURNAL OF LAW & JURISPRUDENCE
Volume 22       Number 2       July 2009

The Coxford Lecture
Of Living Trees and Dead Hands: The Interpretation of Constitutions and Constitutional Rights
Larry Alexander
227

A Reply to Critics of Constitutional Goods
Alan Brudner
237

Parliamentary Sovereignty and the Constitution
Pavlos Eleftheriadis
267

Separate Persons Acting Together—Sketching A Theory of Contract Law
Martin Hevia
291

The Case for Reasoned Criminal Trial Verdicts
Richard L. Lippke
313

Beguiled By Metaphors: The "Living Tree" and Originalist Constitutional Interpretation in Canada
Bradley W. Miller
331

The 'Responsibility to Prevent': A Remit for Intervention?
Natalie Oman
355

The Impossibility of Textualism and the Pervasiveness of Rewriting in Law
Michael Robertson
381

Re-examining States' External Obligations to Implement Economic and Social Rights of Children
Michael Wabwile
407

Book Review
The Law and The Right: A Reappraisal of the Reality that Ought to Be by Enrico Pattaro
Veronica Rodriguez-Blanco
451



FEMINIST LEGAL STUDIES
Volume 17       Number 2       August 2009

"A View You Won't Get Anywhere Else"' Depressed Mothers, Public Regulation and 'Private' 
Narrative
RUTH CAIN
123

Rethinking 'Rape as a Weapon of War'
DORIS E. BUSS
145

Coercion, Consent and the Forced Marriage Debate in the UK
SUNDARI ANITHA and AISHA GILL
165

Double Lives, Double Narratives: Tracing the Story of the Family in Rousseau, the Swiss Civil Code 
and the Fathers' Rights Debates
PRISKA GISLER, SARA STEINERT-BORELLA and CAROLINE WIEDMER
185

Case Notes
Beyond Couples
ROSEMARY AUCHMUTY
205

Poetic Justice
RALPH SANDLAND
219

Book Reviews
Vanessa Munro, Law and Politics at the Perimeter: Re-evaluating Key Debates in Feminist Theory
JOANNE CONAGHAN
229

Jennifer Temkin and Barbara Krahé, Sexual Assault and the Justice Gap: A Question of Attitude
GEORGINA FIRTH
233

Michael Thomson, Endowed: Regulating the Male Sexed Body
STEVE ROBERTSON
237

Tsachi Keren-Paz, Tons, Egalitarianism and Distributive Justice
WADE MANSELL
239



INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL LAW REVIEW
Volume 9       Number 3       2009

Articles
Regionalizing International Criminal Law?
Charles Chernor Jalloh
445

The Duality of the Proportionality Principle within Asymmetric Warfare and Ensuing Superior 
Criminal Responsibilities
Geert-Jan Alexander Knoops
501

The Relationship between State Sovereignty and the Enforcement of International Criminal Law 
under the Rome Statute (1998): A Complex Interplay
Manuela Melandri
531

The Gravity Threshold under the ICC Statute: Gravity Back and Forth in Lubanga and Ntaganda
Ignaz Stegmiller
547

The Use of Force, Wars of National Liberation and the Right to Self-Determination in the South 
Ossetian Conflict
Noelle Higgins and Kieran O'Reilly
567

Book Reviews
Guénaël Mettraux, The Law of Command Responsibility
CHRIS ENGELS
585

Katherine van Wormer and Clemens Bartollas, Women and the Criminal Justice System, 2nd ed.
NICOLE WESTMARLAND
589



INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISCRIMINATION AND THE LAW
Volume 9       Number 4       2008

Editorial
199

Constitutionalising Equality: The South African Experience
Anne Smith
201

Equal Treatment, Fault-Based Liability and Disability-Related Discrimination: Lewisham London 
Borough Council v. Malcolm [2008] UKHL 43
Michael Connolly
251

Banning Sexism: How Harassment Law May Threaten Freedom of Expression and Undermine Anti-
discrimination Policies
Jogchum Vrielink and Stefan Sottiaux
263



JOURNAL OF WORLD TRADE
Volume 43       Number 4       August 2009

Liberalization of Trade in Television Services: The Negotiation Dilemma and Challenges for the 
Future
Shin-yi Peng
657

The Cost of Transnational Accidents: Lessons from Bhopal and Amoco
Antonio Nicita and Matteo M. Winkler
683

Climate Change and the WTO: EU Emission Trading and the WTO Disciplines on Trade in Goods, 
Services and Investment Protection
Erich Vranes
707

Corruption and the WTO Legal System
Krista Nadakavukaren Schefer
737

Reconciling Free Trade and Safe Trade: New Paradigms for Regulating Imports in the Twenty-First 
Century
Krishanti Vignarandi
771

FTA Outward Processing at the Crossroads
Norio Komuro
797

Reflections on China’s WTO Accession Commitments and Their Observance
Ling-Ling He andRazeen Sappideen
847

The Building Block versus Stumbling Block Debate of Regionalism: From the Perspective of Service 
Trade Liberalization in Asia
Shintaro Hamanaka
873

Book Review
893



OSGOODE HALL LAW JOURNAL
Volume 47       Number 1       Spring 2009

ARTICLES
Policy Preference Change and Appointments to the Supreme Court of Canada
Benjamin Alarie & Andrew Green
1

The Politics of Knowledge Dissemination: Corporate Reporting, Shareholder Voice, and Human 
Rights
Aaron A. Dhir
47

American Citations and the McLachlin Court: An Empirical Study
Peter McCormick
83

COMMENTARY
Appealing Outcomes: A Study of the Overturn Rate of Canada's Appellate Courts
Michael H. Lubetsky & Joshua A. Krane
131

BOOK REVIEWS
The Birthright Lottery: Citizenship and Global Inequality — by Ayelet Shachar
Sasha Baglay
151

The Crisis of Islamic Civilization — by Ali A. Mlawi
Haider Ala Hamoudi
159

Rethinking Juvenile Justice — by Elizabeth S. Scott & Laurence Steinberg
Glenn M. Stuart
167

BOOK NOTES
The Future of the Internet and How to Stop It — by Jonathan Zittrain
Ren Bucholz
175

The Challenge: Hamdan v. Rumsfeld and the Fight over Presidential Power— by Jonathan Mahler
James R. Cheng
177

How Judges Think — by Richard A. Posner
Ahsan Mirza
179

McMafia: A Journey through the Global Criminal Underworld — by Misha Glenny
Steve Molnar
181



UNIVERSITY OF NEW BRUNSWICK LAW JOURNAL
Volume 59       2009

FORUM: Recent Developments in Canadian Labour and Employment law

EDITORS' PREFACE
Rose Campbell & Avril Dymond
12

LABOUR LAW AND THE NEW INEQUALITY
Michael Lynk
14

STRIKING A COLLECTIVE BARGAIN: THE SUPREME COURT DECISION IN B.C. HEALTH 
SERVICES
Buzz Hargrove
41

B.C. HEALTH SERVICES: THE LEGACY AFTER 18 MONTHS
John P. McEvoy
48

ENTER STAGE RIGHT: PLAYERS AND ROLES IN A POST-B.C. HEALTH SERVICES WORLD
Beth Bilson
67

PROSPECTS FOR LABOUR'S RIGHT TO BARGAIN COLLECTIVELY AFTER B.C. HEALTH 
SERVICES
Roy J. Adams
85

HOW DID WE GET HERE? SETTING THE STANDARD FOR THE DUTY TO ACCOMODATE
Dianne Pothier
95

EMPLOYEE FREE CHOICE ACT: ONTARIO EXPERIENCES AND POTENTIAL ECONOMIC 
IMPACT
Michael G. Sherrard & Keith P. Burkhardt
109

IN DEFENCE OF THE RIGHT TO STRIKE
Charlotte A.B. Yates
128

DÉJÀ VU... ALL OVER AGAIN: THE ASSAULT ON WORKERS' RIGHTS IN NEW BRUNSWICK, 
1988-2008
Tom Mann
138

WRONGFUL DISMISSAL—BAD FAITH DAMAGES IN CANADIAN EMPLOYMENT LAW: HONDA 
CANADA INC. v. KEAYS
Daniel A. Lublin
153

DIFFERENT DOESN'T NECESSARILY MEAN DIFFERENT: A DISCUSSION OF HONDA CANADA 
INC. v. KEAYS
Michael P. Fitzgibbon
166

ARTICLES
HOW INTERNATIONALISATION OF THE LAW HAS MATERIALIZED IN CANADA
Michel Bastarache
190

DUNSUIR v. NEW BRUNSWICK: THE PERCEIVED CHOICE BETWEEN FAIRNESS AND 
FLEXIBILITY IN PUBLIC SERVICE EMPLOYMENT
Nicolas Lambert
205

ETHICS IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT: ATLANTIC CANADA CONFLICTS OF INTEREST 
ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS— PATHWAYS OR ROADBLOCKS TO A CULTURE OF ETHICS?
Basile Chiasson
231
COMPANY AND SECURITIES LAW JOURNAL
Volume 27       Number 5       August 2009

EDITORIAL
265

ARTICLES
Still a troublesome area: Legislative and common law restrictions on indemnity and insurance 
arrangements effected by companies on behalf of officers and employees
Perry Herzfeld
267

Replacement of the responsible entity of a managed investment scheme by members
Michael Legg
299

The Australian insider trading regime: Workable or hopelessly complex?
Gill North
310

CORPORATE FINANCE — Paul U Ali
Enforcement of security over special purpose vehicles: Part 1
Richard Hillman
328



COMPANY LAWYER
Volume 30       Number 9       2009

COMMENT
257

ANALYSIS
Not so welcoming? United States cross-border assistance
259

Bank integrity: the case of subprime lending
271

NEWS DIGEST
277

BRIEFING
Enforcement – Briefing
278

Comment from the City
280

INTERNATIONAL
Reverse merger: the Indian perspective
282

Entering the field — an analysis of the Chinese securities lawyer
286



EUROPEAN COMPETITION JOURNAL
Volume 5       Number 2       August 2009

FRAND Commitments—The Case for Antitrust Intervention
Philippe Chappatte
319

Should Developed Countries Require Developing Countries to Adopt Competition Laws? Lessons 
from the Economic Literature
Henry Ergas
347

Interpreting Convergence: Where Antitrust Meets Consumer Law
Cristoforo Osti
377

Methodological Issues of the “More Economic Approach" to Unilateral Exclusionary Conduct. 
Proposal of Analysis Starting from the Treatment of Retroactive Rebates
Leonardo Borlini
409

Single Continuous Infringement of Article 81 EC: Has the Commission Stretched the Concept 
Beyond the Limit of its logic?
Julian Joshua
451

Resale Price Maintenance: A Debate About Competition Policy in Europe?
Alison Jones
479

White Paper on Damage Actions for Breach of the EC Antitrust Rules: Plea for a More Holistic 
Approach to Antitrust Enforcement
Jindrich Kloub
515

Article 86 EC, The EC's Economic Approach to Competition Law, and the General Interest
Gareth Davies
549

The Kerry/Breeo Merger: Two Views of Countervailing Buyer Power The Competition Authority and 
the High Court
Paul K Gorecki
585

Selective Distribution by Luxury Goods Suppliers: A Response to Kinsella et al
Thomas Buettner, Andrea Coscelli, Thibaud Vergé and Ralph A Winter
613

Book Reviews
623



EUROPEAN LAW REVIEW
Volume 34       Number 4       August 2009

Editorial
Is it time to worry yet?
521

Articles
The third wave of third pillar law: which direction for EU criminal justice?
Valsamis Mitsilegas
523

The European Central Bank before the European Parliament: theory and practice after 10 years of 
monetary dialogue
Fabian Amtenbrink and Kees van Duin
561

Interoperability as an "essential facility" in the Microsoft case—encouraging competition or stifling 
innovation?
Arianna Andreangeli
584

Analysis and Reflections
Equal treatment and EU citizens: A new chapter on cross-border educational mobility and access to 
student financial assistance
Síofra O'Leary
612

EC immigration law and EC association agreements: fragmentation or integration?
Steve Peers
628

A freedom reborn? The new yet unclear cope of Article 29 EC
Anthony Dawes
639

Book Reviews
650



INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY QUARTERLY
Number 3       2009

ARTICLES
Against an Integrated Intellectual Property Code: A Response to "Reforming Intellectual Property 
Law: An Obvious and Not-so-Obvious Agenda"
Richard Taylor
281

Protection of Geographical Indications: The Case of Jasmine Rice and Thailand
Jakkrit Kuanpoth and Daniel Robinson
288

University Patent Licensing for the Research and Development of Pharmaceuticals in Developing 
Countries
Gail E. Evans
311

New Zealand Designs Law: The Case for Reform
Anna Kingsbury
345

The Absence of Informed Consent to Commercial Exploitation for Inventions Developed from 
Human Biological Material: A Bar to Patentability?
Amanda Odell-West
373

ELSA Copyright Survey: What Does the Young Generation Believe about Copyright?
Konstantinos Stylianou
391

BOOK REVIEW
Lionel Bently, Jennifer Davis and Jane C. Ginsburg (eds) Trade Marks and Brands: An 
Interdisciplinary Critique
Reviewed by Belinda Isaac
396



JOURNAL OF LEGAL HISTORY
Volume 30       Number 2       August 2009

The Authorship of Bracton: Again
J.L. Barton
117

Sworn on the Dirt of Graves: Sovereignty, Jurisdiction and the Judicial Abrogation of 'Barbarous' 
Customs in New Zealand in the 1840s
Shaunnagh Dorsett
175



RATIO JURIS
Volume 22       Number 3       September 2009

Articles
Beyond the Distinction between Positivism and Non-Positivism
Stephen Perry
311

Was Inclusive Legal Positivism Founded on a Mistake?
Scott J. Shapiro
326

The Relevance of Coercion: Some Preliminaries
Nicos Stavropoulos
339

Beyond Inclusive Legal Positivism
Jules L. Coleman
359

The Shared Perception of Social Contexts and Its Conditions for Possibility
Alessio Lo Giudice
395

Notes • Discussion • Book Reviews
Ota Weinberger: In Memoriam
Peter Koller
416

D. Neil MacCormick: Remarkable Friend, Colleague, Scholar, and Political Figure
Robert S. Summers
421



WORLD TRADE AND ARBITRATION MATERIALS
Volume 21       Number 4       August 2009

World Trade Organization (WTO)
WTO Dispute Settlement
United States — Laws, Regulations and Methodology for Calculating Dumping Margins ("Zeroing")
Recourse to Article 21.5 of the DSU by the European Communities
Report of the Appellate Body
14 May 2009
821

Arbitral Awards
International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID)
Bernardus Henricus Funnekotter and others v. Republic of Zimbabwe
Award
22 April 2009
1019
CRIMINAL LAW REVIEW
Number 9       2009

Editorial
615

Articles
Please Don't Call it "Plea Bargaining"
Nick Vamos
617

Gross Negligence Manslaughter and Duty of Care in "Drugs" Cases: R. v Evans
Glenys Williams
631

Prisoners, Pardons and Politics: R. (On the Application of Shields) v Secretary of State for Justice
Hannah Quirk
648

Case and Comment
652

Book Review
684



ISRAEL LAW REVIEW
Volume 41       Number 3       Winter 2008

Lionel Cohen Lecture
Reflections on Holocaust Claims in International Law
Lawrence Collins
402

A Symposium on Constitutional Rights and International Human Rights Honoring Professor David 
Kretzmer
Introduction
Yuval Shany
443

Two Sides of the Same Coin? Democracy and International Human Rights
Henry J. Steiner
445

Establishing a Hierarchy of Human Rights: Ideal Solution or Fallacy?
Eckart Klein
477

The Transformation of Constitutional Law through the European Convention on Human Rights
Jochen A. Frowein
489

The Singarasa Case: Quis custodiet … ? A Test for the Bangalore Principles of Judicial Conduct
Nigel Rodley
500

What's Happening to the Right to a Fair Hearing
Arthur Chaskalson
522

A Skeptical View of Deference to the Executive in Times of Crisis
Fionnuala Ni Aoláin and Oren Gross
545

What Human Rights Law Could Do: Lamenting the Absence of an International Human Rights Law 
Approach in Boumediene & Al Odah
Fiona de Londras
562

Traditionalist Religious and Cultural Challengers—International and Constitutional Human Rights 
Responses
Frances Raday
596

Toward Participatory Equality: Protecting Minority Rights under International Law:
Yousef T. Jabareen
635

Constitutional Rights and their Relationship with International Human Rights in Ghana
A. Kodzo Paaku Kludze
677



INDUSTRIAL LAW JOURNAL: INCLUDING THE INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
Volume 30       May 2009

HIGHLIGHTS OF THE INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
iii

INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
TABLE OF CASES
995

ANNOTATIONS
997

INDEX
1002

JUDGMENTS
Supreme Court of Appeal
National Tertiary Retirement Fund v Registrar of Pension Funds
1011

High Court
De Villiers v Minister of Education & another (C)
1022

Thebe Ya Bophelo Healthcare Administrators (Pty) Ltd & others v National Bargaining Council for 
the Road Freight Industry & another (W)
1031

Labour Appeal Court
All Man Labour Services CC v Services Sector Education & Training Authority
1052

Labour Court
Advancenet (Pty) Ltd v Kropf & others
1062

Airey & others v GE Security (Africa)
1068

Bravo Group Sleep Products (Pty) Ltd & another v Chemical Energy Paper Printing Wood & Allied 
Workers Union & others
1090

ltumele Bus Lines (Pty) Ltd t/a Interstate Bus Lines v Transport & Allied Workers Union of SA & 
others
1099

J D Trading (Pty) Ltd t/a Giddy's Electric Express v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & 
Arbitration & others
1122

Professional Transport Workers Union & others v Fidelity Security Services
1129

Sappi Forests (Pty) Ltd v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration & others
1140

Worldnet Logistics (Cape) (Pty) Ltd v Maritz NO & others
1144

Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration
Britz and Acctech Systems (Pty) Ltd
1150

Maila and Dynamic Marketing Corporation
1176

Modiba and Leeuwkuil Abattoir CC
1181

Ngidi and Fidelity Supercare Services Group (Pty) Ltd
1185

Seti & others and Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University
1199



INDUSTRIAL LAW JOURNAL: INCLUDING THE INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
Volume 30       June 2009

HIGHLIGHTS OF THE INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
iii

INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
TABLE OF CASES
1211

ANNOTATIONS
1213

INDEX
1219

JUDGMENTS
High Court
Hendricks v Cape Peninsula University of Technology & others (C)
1229

National Education Health & Allied Workers Union on behalf of Adekoya v Central University of 
Technology: Free State & others (O)
1261

Van Schalkwyk & others v Mkiva NO & others (O)
1266

Labour Appeal Court
Business & Design Software (Pty) Ltd & another v Van der Velde
1277

Labour Court
City of Matlosana v SA Local Government Bargaining Council & others
1293

Northern Cape Allied Workers Union & others v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & 
Arbitration & others
1299

Police & Prisons Civil Rights Union on behalf of Sifuba v Commissioner of the SA Police Service & 
others
1309

Potgieter v National Commissioner of the SA Police Service & another
1322

Public Servants Association & another v Public Health & Welfare Sectoral Bargaining Council & 
others
1336

SA Municipal Workers Union on behalf of Petersen v City of Cape Town & others
1347

SA Transport & Allied Workers Union & others v Maxi Strategic Alliance (Pty) Ltd
1358

Solidarity on behalf of Botha v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration & others
1363

Southernwind Shipyard (Pty) Ltd v National Union of Metalworkers of SA & others
1369

United People's Union of SA on behalf of Khumalo v Maxiprest Tyres (Pty) Ltd
1379

Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration
Phetlhu and Nuwe Plaas
1389

Thompson and Samaki Beach Lodge
1396

Vorster and B M C Management Trust
1421

Zweni and Transnet National Ports Authority
1428



JOURNAL OF LAW AND SOCIETY
Volume 36       Number 3       September 2009

Articles
The Ties That Bind: Multiculturalism and Secularism Reconsidered
Brenna Bhandar
301

Pornography, Pragmatism, and Proscription
Clare McGlynn and Ian Ward
327

The Dangers of Hanging Baskets: 'Regulatory Myths' and Media Representations of Health and 
Safety Regulation
Paul Almond
352

Diversity in the Judiciary: The Case for Positive Action
Kate Malleson
376

Book Reviews
Neil MacCormick: Practical Reason in Law and Morality
Stefano Bertea
403

Allan C. Hutchinson: The Province of Jurisprudence Democratized
David Fraser
408

Richard Collier and Sally Sheldon: Fragmenting Fatherhood — A Socio-Legal Study
Mervyn Murch
417

Anthony Bradney: Law and Faith in a Sceptical Age
Russell Sandberg
421

Jo Shaw: The Transformation of Citizenship in the European Union: Electoral Rights and the 
Restructuring of Political Space
Daniel Wincott
426



LEGAL STUDIES
Volume 29       Number 3       September 2009

Articles
The use and abuse of taxonomy
Kelvin FK Low
355

Visions of utopia: markets, medicine and the National Health Service
John Harrington
376

Transferred malice in tort law?
Allan Beever
400

Taking due account of religion in sentencing
Chara Bakalis and Peter Edge
421

Clients’ strict liability towards victims of sex-trafficking
Tsachi Keren-Paz and Nomi Levenkron
438

Capacity assessment under the Mental Capacity Act 2005: Delivering on the functional approach?
Mary Donnelly
464

Review article
Technology in the age of anxiety — the moral economy of regulation
Derek Morgan
492

Book review
509

Books received
514



SYDNEY LAW REVIEW
Volume 31       Number 2       June 2009

Articles
Digging Up Fragments and Building IP Franchises
Kathy Bowrey and Natalie Fowell
185

'A tongue but no teeth?’: The emergence of a regional human rights mechanism in the Asia Pacific 
region
Andrea Durbach, Catherine Renshaw and Andrew Byrnes
211

Carbon Rights as New Property: The benefits of statutory verification
Samantha Hepburn
239

The Regulatory Framework for Executive Remuneration in Australia
Kym Sheehan
273

Case Note
Charity Means Business Commissioner of Taxation v Word Investments Ltd
Ian Murray
309

Book Review
A Matter of Conscience: Sir Ronald Wilson, by Antonio Buti
Michael Kirby
331



VICTORIA UNIVERSITY OF WELLINGTON LAW REVIEW
Volume 40       Number 1       June 2009

Foreword
lain Byrne
v

Protecting Human Rights in the Pacific
Petra Butler
vii

I Country Reports
Papua New Guinea: Country Report on Human Rights
Freda Talao
1

Federated States of Micronesia: Country Report on Human Rights
Tina Takashy
25

Australia: Country Report on Human Rights
Jennifer Corrin
37

New Zealand: Country Report on Human Rights
Natalie Baird Justice Susan Glazebrook, and Sasha Holden
57

II Reports from Regional Human Rights Mechanisms
The Experience of the Inter-American Human Rights System
Felipe González
103

Asia's Experience in the Quest for a Regional Human Rights Mechanism
Sou Chiam
127

Legal Pluralism, Customary Law and Human Rights in Francophone African Countries
Jacques Frémont
149

The European Experience: The European Convention on Human Rights
Kevin Boyle
167

III Human Rights in the Pacific
Why do we Need a Pacific Regional Human Rights Commission?
P Imrana Jalal
177

A Pacific Human Rights Mechanism: Specific Challenges and Requirements
Kathryn Hay
195

An Indigenous Pacific Human Rights Mechanism: Some Building Blocks
Natalie Baird and Valmaine Toki
215

Samoan Custom and Human Rights: An Indigenous View
Unasa L F Vaá
237

Implementing Human Rights in the Pacific through National Human Rights Institutions: The 
Experience of Fiji
Andrew Byrnes, Andrea Durbach and Catherine Renshaw
251

Human Rights Mechanisms in Small Pacific States: Implications for Dialogue about Regional Human 
Rights Mechanisms
Joy Liddicoat
279

Human Rights and the Environment
Justice Susan Glazebrook
293

Human Rights and the WT O: Issues for the Pacific
Sarah Joseph
351

A Balancing Act: Modem Equality vs Traditional Nobility in Tonga
Tim René Salomon
369

Land as a Fundamental Right: a Cautionary Tale
Sue Farran
387

Book Review: Human Rights in the South Pacific — Challenges and Changes
Catherine Harwood
403

IV Outcome Statements
Strategies for the Future: Protecting Human Rights in the Pacific, Apia, Samoa, 27-29 April 2008 
Final Statement
409

Regional Workshop on the Establishment of National Human Rights Mechanisms in the Pacific: 
Aims and Outcomes
413

Samoa Declaration
417
EUROPEAN HUMAN RIGHTS
Number 4       2009

OPINION
The European Court of Human Rights after 50 Years
Anthony Lester
461

BULLETIN
479

BULLETIN: COUNTER-TERRORISM AND HUMAN RIGHTS
484

ARTICLES
A Tale of Two Trespassers: Reconsidering the Impact of the Human Rights Act on Rights of 
Residence in Rented Housing: Part Two
Ian Loveland
495

The Equality Bill: A Sheep in Wolf's Clothing or Something More?
Karon Monaghan Q.C.
512

Positive Obligations and Policing in the House of Lords
Gordon Anthony
538

Regulation of Internet Surveillance
Alisdair A. Gillespie
552

CASE ANALYSIS
R. (on the application of Smith) v Oxfordshire Assistant Deputy Coroner: Human Rights and the 
Armed Forces
Ben Silverstone
566

CASES AND COMMENT
Sandra Jankovi? v Croatia (Application No.38478/05)
577

Barraco v France (Application No.31684/05)
580

Colak and Tsakiridis v Germany (Applications Nos 77144/01 & 35493/05)
583

Times Newspapers Ltd v United Kingdom (Application Nos 3002/03 & 23676/03)
586

Ould Dah v France (Application No.13113/03)
588

Natunen v Finland (Application No.21022/04)
590

Sanoma Uitgevers BV v Netherlands (Application No.38224/03)
593

Egeland and Hanseid v Norway (Application No.34438/04)
596

BOOK REVIEW
600



EUROPEAN REVIEW OF PRIVATE LAW
Volume 17       Number 4       2009

Editorial
EWOUD HONDIUS
483

Articles
Farewell to Windscheid? Legal Concepts Present and Absent from the Draft Common Frame of 
Reference (DCFR)
ANTONI VAQUER
487

The Constitutional Momentum of European Contract Law. On the Interpretation of the DCFR in 
Light of Fundamental Rights
CHANTAL MAK
513

The Structure of the Law on Multiparty-Situations in the 2009 Draft Common Frame of Reference
MATTHIAS E. STORME
531

Information Duties and Precontractual Good Faith
CARLO CASTRONOVO
559

The DCFR Rules on Unexpected Difficulties in Performance
KÅRE LILLEHOLT and ANDERS BERNHARD MIKELSEN
573

Right to Specific Performance: Is There a Divergence between Civil- and Common-Law Systems 
and, If So, How Has It Been Bridged in the DCFR?
GERARD DE VRIES
581

Article III.3:302 DCFR on the Right to Enforced Performance of Non-monetary Obligations: An 
Improvement—Albeit Imperfect—Compared with Article 9:102 PECL
MARTIJN VAN KOGELENBERG
599

Foreseeability and Remoteness of Damages in Contract in the DCFR
OLE LANDO
619

Consumer Goods Guarantees in the DCFR
CHRISTIAN TWIGG-FLESNER
641

Financial Leasing unter der UNIDROIT-Convention on International Financial Leasing und dem 
Draft Common Frame of Reference: Eine vergleichende Analyse
ANDREAS FÖTSCHL
659

European Construction Law and the Draft Common Frame of Reference: Selected Topics
BENOÎT KOHL
675

Book VI of the DCFR (Non-contractual Liability Arising Out of Damage Caused to Another) and 
European Private International Law
GUILLERMO PALAO MORENO
703

Fifteen Questions on the Rules Regarding the Acquisition of Movables in Book VIII Draft Common 
Frame of Reference
ARTHUR F. SALOMONS
711

Derivative Acquisition of Ownership of Goods
TORGNY HÅSTAD
725

List of Contributors
743



INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION LAW REVIEW
Volume 12       Number 4       2009

Articles
Europe—Is it Time to Reconsider the Arbitration Exception from the Brussels Regulation?
PROFESSOR PETER F. SCHLOSSER
45

Arbitration and EC Law—An Italian Reaction in the Heidelberg Colloquium
PROFESSOR AVV. CLAUDIO CONSOLO
49

The Future of International Arbitration in Europe: West Tankers and the EU Green Paper
ANDREW PULLEN
56

The Proposed Reform of Regulation 44/2001: A Poison Pill for Arbitration in the European Union?
PHILIPPE PINSOLLE
62

Anti-suit and Anti-arbitration Injunctions in International Arbitration: A Swiss Perspective
MATTHIAS SCHERER & WERNER JAHNEL
66

News Section
An international review of recent cases and developments
N-45



INTERNATIONAL FAMILY LAW
September 2009

Newsline
Summer Travels in Europe
141

Pre-Nuptial Agreements: The International Dimension
142

Forced Marriage Research
143

Law Society EU Society
146

Current Developments in EU Family Law
146

Conference Reports: Cape Town and Singapore
149

Conference Report: Fiji
150

International Law Centre
151

International Family Justice Lecture
151

Features
Legal Representation of Children
Judge Paul Von Dadelszen
152

Certainty and Discretion: EU and English Family Law
Tim Scott
15

Property, Maintenance, and Post-Soviet European Family Law
Olga A Khazova
160

Family Law Down Under: Can the ‘Old World’ Learn from the ‘New’?
Hannah Baker
165

Children, Kindoki and Human Rights
Bridget Martin
174

When the 1980 Hague Child Abduction Convention Does Not Apply: The UK-Pakistan Protocol
Marilyn Freeman
181

Developments in Hague Child Abduction Cases
Anne-Marie Hutchinson
186

Cohabitation in Greece
Haroula Constandinidou and Konstantinos Stavropoulos
190

Farewell Justice Kay
Ian Kennedy AM
192

Briefings
Marital Agreements and Private Autonomy in a Comparative Perspective
David Hodson
196

Law Society Brussels Bulletin: EU Negotiations on Next Five Year Programme
Susan Clements
198

Hague Conference Update
Permanent Bureau
199

Resolution International Committee Update
Charlotte Bradley
201

Book Review
204

International Websites
205

Diary
211



JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION
Volume 26       Number 4       August 2009

ARTICLES
The Practical Impact of Amendment to Article 85-1, Section 2 of the Government Procurement Act
—A Report from Taiwan
Helena H.C. Chen
491

The Necessity for Discovery of Evidence in the Fact-Finding Process of International Tribunals
Dr. Ali Z. Marossi
511

Towards a Hierarchy of Norms in Transnational Law?
Moritz Renner
533

The Settlement of Disputes between the Public Administration and Private Companies by Arbitration 
under Brazilian Law
Arnoldo Wald and Jean Kalicki
557

NOTES AND CURRENT DEVELOPMENTS
Comments on the Paris Court of Appeal Decision in SNF v. International Chamber of Commerce
Laurence Kiffer
579

Comments on the Paris Court of Appeal Decision in Czech Republic v. Pren Nreka
Pierre Duprey
591

INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION EVENTS CALENDAR
605



JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL BANKING LAW AND REGULATION
Volume 24       Number 9       2009

Opinion
Final Rules on Information about Major Shareholdings
WILLIAM DWYER
435

Articles
Personal Security Rights in the Spanish Insolvency Law Reform 2009
ANGEL CARRASCO
439

Banking Professional Conflicts of Interest in European Securities Markets
JAVIER W. IBÁÑEZ
443

Recent Developments in Mobile Banking and Payments
RHYS BOLLEN
454

UNIDROIT Draft Convention and German securities law—friends or foes?
PETER SCHERER AND RAINER GALLEI
470

Legal Analysis
Protecting the Client—the Future of Prime Brokerage
RICHARD FRASE
477

The Italian Regime to Face the Banking Crisis Through the Issuance of Bonds Subscribed by the 
State
MARCO LANTELME
482

Creative Uses of Chapter 15 of the US Bankruptcy Code to Smooth Cross-Border Restructurings
LOOK CHAN HO
485

Book Reviews
Property Rights in Money
MAREK DUBOVEC
489

Financial Services in Europe: An Introductory Overview
MARKUS HEIDINGER
489

News Section
An International Review of Recent Cases and Legislation
N-75



JURIDICAL REVIEW
Volume 2009       Number 3

ARTICLES
Breaking Down Brennan
Findlay Stark
155

A Call for Legislative Action Against Forced Marriage
Craig B. Callery
171

 “Trips, Slips and Bangs”: Pupil Injury Claims and the Teacher’s Duty of Care
Lesley-Anne Barnes
189

Gillies v Ralph: A Common Law Power of Entry?
Neil Parpworth and Katharine Thompson
209

Reconsidering Economic Loss Arising out of Breach of Arrestment
William J. Stewart
227



LEIDEN JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL LAW
Volume 22       Number 1       March 2009

ARTICLES
The Rhetoric of Fragmentation: Fear and Faith in International Law
Anne-Charlotte Martineau
1

De-territorializing and Re-territorializing Lotus: Sovereignty and Systematicity as Dialectical Nation-
Building in Early Republican Turkey
Umut Özsu
29

International Law and the Objectivity of Value
Emmanuel Voyiakis
51

HAGUE INTERNATIONAL TRIBUNALS
International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia
Is ICTY Sentencing Predictable? An Empirical Analysis of ICTY Sentencing Practice
Barbora Holá, Alette Smeulers, and Catrien Bijleveld
79

International Criminal Court
Is Peace in the Interests of Justice? The Case for Broad Prosecutorial Discretion at the 
International Criminal Court
Kenneth A. Rodman
99

CURRENT LEGAL DEVELOPMENTS
Two for the Price of One: Attempts by the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia to 
Combine Retributive and Restorative Justice Principles
Brianne M. McGonigle
127

US Supreme Court, Medellín v. Texas: More than an Assiduous Building Inspector?
John King Gamble and Christine M. Giuliano
151

BIBLIOGRAPHY
Books and Articles in the Field of the Prevention and Peaceful Settlement of International Disputes 
(Autumn 2008)
Ingrid Kost
171

REVIEW ESSAYS
Exploring the Theory and Practice of the Relationship between International Human Rights Law and 
Domestic Actors
Frans Viljoen
177

Non state Actors, State-Centrism and Human Rights Obligations
Eric De Brabandere
191

BOOK REVIEW
Robert Kolb, Interprétation et création du draft international. Esquisse d'une herméneutique 
juridique moderne pour le droit international public
Fouad Zarbiev
211
CRIMINAL LAW QUARTERLY
Volume 55       Numbers 1 & 2       July 2009

Editorial
Listing and the Law
1

Criminal Appeals in the Supreme Court of Canada
4

Articles and Addresses
Similar Pact Evidence
Richard Mahoney
22

Reasonable Apprehension of Judicial Bias in Trial Proceedings
Wayne Gorman
46

Infanticide: Legislative History and Current Questions
Emma Cunliffe
94

Stifling Dissent through Creative Use of the Criminal Law: The Charge of Wearing a Mask with 
Intent
Jean-Pierre Hachey
120

Cracks in the Façade of Liberty: The Resort to Habeas Corpus to Enforce Part XX.1 of the Criminal 
Code
Janet Leiper
134

Sex Offender Registries: Labelling Folk Devils
Vanessa Amyot
188

Entrench the Bench! Canada's Pressing Need for a Permanent Military Court
Major J. Jason Samson and Lieutenant (Navy) Mike Madden
215

Across the Rubicon and into the Apennines: Privacy and Common Law Police Powers after A.M. 
and Kang-Brown
Jane Bailey
239

Book Review
Sexual Assault and the Justice Gap: A Question of Attitude by Jennifer Temkin and Barbara Krahé
Gilles Renaud
281



NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PUBLIC AND INTERNATIONAL LAW
Volume 6       Number 2       December 2008

Foreword
Claudia Geiringer and Dean R Knight
vii

Public Office Holder's Address
Challenges Facing the Family Court
Judge Peter Boshier
1

Articles
The Facts Available on "Facts Available”: An Analysis of Article 6.8 and Annex II of the WTO Anti-
Dumping Agreement
Michael Andrews
11

Breaking the Silence: An Analysis of Police Questioning Under Section 23(4) of the New Zealand 
Bill of Rights Act 1990
Amelia Evans
43

Untapped Potential: Administrative Law and International Environmental Obligations
Arla Marie Kerr
81

Picking Up the Pieces: Truth and Justice in Sierra Leone
Natalie Pierce
117



TORT LAW REVIEW
Volume 17       Number 2       July 2009

ARTICLES
Negligence law and judicial discretion: A response to Hutchinson and Morgan twenty-five years on
Richard Mullender
65

Pure economic loss and defects in the law of negligence
Po Jen Yap
80

Privacy in pursuit of a purpose?
Patrick O'Callaghan
100

BOOK REVIEW
Causing Psychiatric and Emotional Harm: Reshaping the Boundaries of Legal Liability by Harvey 
Teff
114



TORTS LAW JOURNAL
Volume 17       Number 2       July 2009

Case Notes
Giller v Procopets: Australia's privacy protection shows signs of improvement
Normann Witzleb
121

The fertile imagination of the common law: Yearworth v North Bristol NHS Trust
James Lee
130

The widening gyre of vicarious liability
Susan Watson and Chris Noonan
144

Article
The economic torts as corrective justice
J W Neyers
162

ALBERTA LAW REVIEW
Volume 46       Number 3       June 2009

ARTICLES
Conservation Easements: Pluses and Pitfalls, Generally and For Municipalities
Arlene J. Kwasniak
651

Corporate Directors’ Disqualifications: The New Canadian Regime?
Jassmine Girgis
677

The Legal Status of the Joint Venture
Robert Flannigan
713

After Labaye: The Harm Test of Obscenity, The New Judicial Vacuum, and The Relevance of 
Familiar Voices
Richard Jochelson
741

Assessing Canada’s Regulatory Response to the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2012: Lessons for 
Canadian Policy Makers
Stephen P. Sibold, Q.C.
769

The Rule of Capture: Its Current Status and Some Issues to Consider
Cecilia A. Low
799

Forty Years of the Alberta Law Reform Institute—Past, Present, Future
The Hon. Justice Michael Kirby
831

CASE COMMENT
Family Violence Cases in Alberta: A Snapshot
Jennifer Koshan
847

BOOK REVIEW
Defining Rights and Wrongs: Bureaucracy, Human Rights, and Public Accountability by Rosanna L. 
Langer
Patricia Paradis
859



ARAB LAW QUARTERLY
Volume 23       Number 3       2009

The Independence of the Public Prosecution Service in the UAE: Issues and Proposals for Reform
Ghaith Ghanem Al-Suwaidi
217

Towards a Contemporary View of Islamic Criminal Procedures: A Focus on the Testimony of 
Witnesses
Tarek Badawy
269

Les États Arabes et la Déclaration Universelle des Droits de l’Homme
Nidhal Mekki
307

Mediation in Marital Discord in Islamic Law: Legislative Foundation and Contemporary Application
Sayed Sikander Shah
329

The Role of Intention (Niyya) Under Saudi Arabian Hanbali Law
Nabil Saleh
347



COMMON MARKET LAW REVIEW
Volume 46       Number 4       August 2009

Editorial comments: Karlsruhe has spoken: "Yes" to the Lisbon Treaty, but ...
1023

Articles
The EU Fundamental Rights Agency within the European and international human rights 
architecture: The legal framework and some unsettled issues in a new field of administrative law
A. von Bogdandy and J. von Bernstorff
1035

On "federal" ground: The European Union as an (inter)national phenomenon
R. Schütze
1069

Social blind spots and monocular policy making: The ECJ's migrant worker model
C. O'Brien
1107

The institutional framework of the European System of Central Banks: Legal issues in the practice 
of the first ten years of its existence
B. Krauskopf and C. Steven
1143

Co-ordination of social security in the European Union: An overview of recent case law
V. Paskalia
1177

Case law
A. Court of Justice
Joined Cases C-39/05 P & C-52/05 P, Sweden and Turco v. Council, with annotation by A. Arnull
1219

Case T-256/07, People's Mojahedin Organization of Iran v. Council; Case T-284/08, People's 
Mojahedin Organization of Iran v. Council, with annotation by E. Spaventa
1239

Case C-133/06, European Parliament v. Council, with annotation by P. Craig
1265

Case C-155/07, Parliament v. Council, with annotation by V. Randazzo 1277

Joined Cases C-14/06 & C-295/06, European Parliament and Denmark v. Commission, with 
annotation by A. Türk
1293

Joined Cases C-341/06 P & C-342/06 P, Chronopost SA and La Poste v. Union française de 
l’éxpress (UFEX) and Others, with annotation by P. Vesterdorf
1305

Case C-49/07, Motosykletistiki Omospondia Ellados NPID (MOTOE) v. Elliniko Dimosio with 
annotation by A. Vermeersch
1327

Book reviews
1343

Survey of Literature
1365



DEAKIN LAW REVIEW
Volume 14       Number 1       2009

ARTICLES
Statutory Retention of Title Structures? A Comparative Analysis of German Property Transfer Rules 
in Light of English and Australian Law
Lutz-Christian Wolff
1

The Reality of Non-Adversarial Justice: Principles and Practice
Judy Gutman
29

The Prospects for Corporate Governance Operating as a Vehicle for Social Change in South Africa
Lilian Miles and Mariette Jones
53

Facts, Threats and Reds: Common Law Constitutionalism and the Rule of Law
John R Morss
79

In Defence of the CISG
Christopher Kee and Edgardo Muñoz
99

CASE NOTE
Coming Clean in the Colonial Courts: the 1822 'Confession' Trial of Hatherly and Jackie
Brent Salter
125

BOOK REVIEWS
Animal Law in Australasia by Peter Sankoff and Steven White (eds)
David Glasgow
133

Death of Labour Law? Comparative Perspectives by Martin Vranken
Victoria Lambropoulos
139



INDUSTRIAL LAW JOURNAL: INCLUDING THE INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
Volume 30       April 2009

HIGHLIGHTS OF THE INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
iii

RENAMING OF THE HIGH COURTS
viii

ARTICLES
Deconstructing Chirwa v Transnet
Halton Cheadle
741

Braamfontein versus Bloemfontein: The SCA and Constitutional Court’s Approaches to Labour Law
Paul Benjamin
757

What Is (and What isn’t) a ‘Constitutional Matter’ in the Context of Labour Law
Dawn Norton
772

NOTES
The Quantum of the Agency Fee in Terms of the Agency Shop Agreement in South African Law
Maleka Femida Cassim
791

Power of Withholding a Pension Benefit Confirmed by Supreme Court of Appeal
Naleen Jeram
804

INDUSTRIAL LAW REPORTS
TABLE OF CASES
815

ANNOTATIONS
817

INDEX
822

JUDGMENTS
Supreme Court of Appeal
Shoprite Checkers (Pty) Ltd v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration & others
829

High Court
Crous v Blue Crane Route Municipality & another (Tk)
840

Healy v Workmen's Compensation Commissioner & another (E)
859

Equality Court
Strydom v Nederduitse Gereformeerde Gemeente Moreleta Park
868

Labour Appeal Court
Eberspächer v National Union of Metalworkers of SA on behalf of Skade & others
880

Labour Court
Chesteron Industries (Pty) Ltd v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration & others
888

Eskom Holdings (Pty) Ltd v National Union of Mineworkers & others
894

Naude v Member of Executive Council, Department of Health, Mpumalanga
910

Commission for Conciliation, Mediation & Arbitration
Busakwe and Winskor 158 (Pty) Ltd
937

DENOSA on behalf of Njeza and Cape Peninsula Organisation for the Aged
949

Jansen and SA Transport & Allied Workers Union
958

Prime Cure (Pty) Ltd & another and Ameer
967

Zondi and PPM Security Services (Pty) Ltd
981

Bargaining Council Arbitration
Matjipa and Crazee Steel Dezines CC
986



JOURNAL OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW & PRACTICE
Volume 4       Number 9       September 2009

Editorial
Caveat Caritas!
Jeremy Phillips
603

JIPLP Express
604

Current Intelligence
Doing things by the (Orange) Book: how to avoid an injunction for unlicensed use of 
standard/essential patents
Pat Treacy and Sophie Lawrance
607

Infringement of product-by-process claims in US clarified
Charles R. Macedo
608

Trade mark infringement by resale of luxury goods in discount stores
Frédéric Glaize
611

Canadian distillery permitted to register 'Glen Breton' to describe single malt whisky originating from 
Nova Scotia
Emir Aly Crowne Mohammed
612

Keywords, search engines, and the potential for trade mark infringement
Andrew Sharples
614

ECJ rules on jurisdiction for IP licence disputes
Paul Joseph
616

China—Intellectual Property Rights and the criminalization of trade mark counterfeiting and 
copyright piracy under the TRIPS Agreement
Bradly J. Condon
618

Respect for the commercial meaning of franchise restrictive covenants: do the UK and Canada 
diverge?
James Tumbridge
619

Practice Point
Obtaining useful patent protection for nucleotide and amino acid sequences in the USA
Marc Tritel
623

Articles
Community design invalidity: the issues, as viewed through the case law
Pedro Rodinger
629

Protection of trade marks against dilution: a semiotic perspective
Katya Assaf
643

Patent term extensions for human drugs under the US Hatch-Waxman Act
Jeffrey S. Boone
658

Should Singapore follow the EU in creating sui generis protection for databases?
Md. Rizwanul Islam
665

Marks as imitations of State emblems 'from a heraldic point of view'
Grzegorz Pacek
673

IP in Review
A concise and practical guide to IP in the pharmaceutical industry
Duncan Bucknell
680

A final shot in the arm
Phillip Johnson            
681

In Person
Felicity Hide
682



SOUTH AFRICAN LAW JOURNAL
Volume 125       Number 4       2008

ABSTRACTS
629

NOTES
Arms deals, bribery and political interference: How (im)potent the (rule of) law?
Francois Venter
633

Complaints in sexual offences
D T Zeffertt, A P Paizes and J S Grant
642

A dangerous precedent indeed —A response to C R Snyman's note on Masiya
K Phelps
648

Reconsidering Carmichele
Anton Fagan
659

K v Minister of Safety and Security and the increasingly blurred line between personal and vicarious 
liability
Stephen Wagener
673

Pre-emption as an option? The saga continues in Van Aardt v Weehuizen
Deeksha Bhana
680

ARTICLES
Constitutionalization and the International Criminal Court: Whither individual criminal liability for 
aggression?
Gerhard Kemp
694

The duration of the duty to maintain and of a maintenance order
M F T Botha
715

Post-resignation duties of directors: The application of the fiduciary duty not to misappropriate 
corporate opportunities
Rehana Cassim
731

Corporate law and the Constitution: Towards binding human rights responsibilities for corporations
David Bilchitz
754

The Harmony — Gold Fields take-over battle
A L Christison and R C Williams
790



UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO FACULTY OF LAW REVIEW
Volume 67       Number 1       Winter 2009

ARTICLES
BEYOND THE GOUDGE INQUIRY: IS THE CORONER PART OF “THE CROWN" FOR 
STINCHCOMBE DISCLOSURE OBLIGATIONS?
ANDREW FLAVELLE MARTIN
9

FIXING WHAT AIN'T BROKE: IN DEFENCE OF CANADIAN POISON PILL REGULATION
RONALD PODOLNY
47

SENIOR BOARD NOTES, COMMENTS AND REVIEWS
CASE COMMENT: WIC RADIO V. SIMPSON
STEVEN FRANKEL
93

OVERHAULING THE ONTARIO HUMAN RIGHTS SYSTEM: RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN CASE 
LAW AND LEGISLATIVE REFORM
TIFFANY TSUN
115

CLARITY AND CONFUSION IN EMPLOYMENT LAW REMEDIES: A COMMENT ON HONDA 
CANADA INC. V. KEAYS
PAUL-ERIK VEEL
135

WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION?
JACOB WEINRIB
165

PROFESSIONAL CARDS
BANKING & FINANCE LAW REVIEW
Volume 25       Number 1       September 2009

ARTICLES
2009 IIC Symposium Issue: Introduction and Overview
STEPHANIE BEN-ISHAI & ANTHONY DUGGAN
1

Asset Backed Commercial Paper: Why the Courts Got it Right
FRED MYERS & ALEXA ABISCOTT
5

Canada’s Asset Backed Commercial Paper Restructuring: 2007-2009
JEFFREY CARHART & JAY HOFFMAN
35

Bank Bankruptcy in Canada: A Comparative Perspective
STEPHANIE BEN-ISHAI
59

Discussion on Claim Purchasing
DENIS FERLAND
75

Developments and Trends in Stakeholder Rights: Labour as a Gatekeeper
AUBREY KAUFFMAN & STUART BROTMAN
93

Expedited Debt Restructuring in Canada
KEVIN MCELCHERAN & HEATHER MEREDITH
121

Classification, Consolidation and Context: A Canadian Approach to Substantive Consolidation
MICHAEL MACNAUGHTON
141

Unilateral Disclaimer of Collective Agreements: Exploring the Constitutional Implications
STEVEN MEURRENS
167

The Resurrection of Goods and Services Tax Claims in Bankruptcy
ROGER P. SIMARD
193



CANADIAN JOURNAL OF CRIMINOLOGY AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE
Volume 51       Number 3       July 2009

Articles
L’Emprisonnement avec sursis au Québec: impact de l’arrêt Proulx
Sandra Lehalle, Mathieu Charest at Pierre Landreville
277

Sursis, récidive et réinsertion sociale: un équilibre précaire
Issabelle F.-Dufour, Renée Brassard et Jean-Pierre Guay
303

Le voile de l’ignorance dans la détermination des sentences
Chloé Leclerc et Pierre Tremblay
329

Inmate Perspectives on the Remand Crisis in Canada
Michael Weinrath
355

Security Officers’ Perspectives on Training
John Manzo
381

Research Note
Student Attitudes toward Wrongful Conviction
Rosemary Ricciardelli, James G. Bell, and Kimberley A. Clow
411

Book Reviews
July 2009
429

Books Received
July 2009
431

Coming Events
433



INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CHILDREN’S RIGHTS
Volume 17       Number 3       2009

Articles
The Synthesis of Age and Gender: Internationality, International Human Rights Law and the 
Marginalisation of the Girl-Child
Nura Taefi
345

Janusz Korczak—His Legacy and its Relevance for Children’s Rights Today
Gabriel Eichsteller
377

Rules in Everyday Life: Teacher Strategies Undermine Pupil Participation
Robert Thornberg
393

Reciprocity, Respect and Responsibility: The 3Rs Underlying Parent-Child Relationships in Ghana 
and the Implications for Children’s Rights
Afua Twum-Danso
415

Child Maltreatment in United States: An Examination of Child Reports and Substantiation Rates
John E. Kesner, Gary E. Bingham and Kyong-Ah Kwon
433

Honourable Traditions? Honour Violence, Early Marriage and Sexual Abuse of Teenage Girls in 
Lebanon, the Occupied Palestinian Territories and Yemen
Pernilla Ouis
445

The Rights of the Child in Islamic Context: The Challenges of the Local and the Global
Masoud Rajabi-Ardeshiri
475

Children and Young People on the UK Sex Offender Register
Terry Thomas
491

A New Childhood Social Studies Curriculum for a New Generation of Citizenship
Steven P. Camicia and Cinthya M. Saavedra
501

Book reviews
Jane Stoll, Swedish Donor Offspring and Their Legal Right to Information
Eric Blyth
519

Nick Axford, Defining and Classifying Children in Need
Michael Freeman
522



JOURNAL OF ENERGY & NATURAL RESOURCES LAW
Volume 27       Number 3       August 2009

Introduction
Nigel Bankes
299

Stability of Contract in the International Energy Industry
Peter D Cameron
305

The Potential Contribution of International Investment Protection Law to Combat Climate Change
Anatole Boute
333

Thomas W Wälde and Fair and Equitable Treatment
Rachael A Hird
377

Energy Charter Treaty and the European Union: is Conflict Inevitable?
Graham Coop
404

Law and Policy in the Russian Oil and Gas Sector
Kaj Hobér
420

Gas Transit in Eurasia: Transit Issues between Russia and the European Union and the Role of the 
Energy Charter
Andrey A Konoplyanik
445

Adjudicating Bribery and Corruption Issues in International Commercial Arbitration
William Fox
487

Game Theory and International Environmental Cooperation
Moshe Hirsch
503

List of publications of Thomas W Wälde
511

General Index
524



MAASTRICHT JOURNAL OF EUROPEAN AND COMPARATIVE LAW
Volume 16       Number 2       2009

Editorial
Limits of Differentiation in European Economic Law: Ne Bis In Idem and Minimum Versus Maximum 
Harmonisation
WOUTER DEVROE
141

ARTICLES
Tracking Judicial Dialogue: The Scope for Preliminary Rulings from the Italian Constitutional Court
MARCO DANI
149

Euro-Chinese Company Models: An Exploratory Journey into the Position of Directors, 
Shareholders and Stakeholders in Chinese and European Company Law
MIEKE OLAERTS
171

Free Movement and Participation in the Parliamentary Elections in the Member State of Nationality: 
An Ignored Link?
DIMITRY KOCHENOV
197

Hedge Funds and Private Equity Funds Under Scrutiny in the Netherlands
JOOST S. HAMENT
225

BOOK REVIEWS
EVA-MARIA KIENINGER (ed.) with the assistance of MICHELE GRAZIADEI, GEORGE L. 
GRETTON, CORNELIUS G. VAN DER MERWE, MATTHIAS E. STORME
Security Rights in Movable Property in European Private Law (The Common Core of European 
Private Law)
239

ERIKA SZYSZCZAK
The Regulation of the State in Competitive Markets in the EU
247

CASE NOTES
Case C-210/06 (16th December 2008) — In re Cartesio
251

Case T-196/04 (17th December 2008) — In re Ryanair
256
AUSTRALIAN JOURNAL OF ASIAN LAW
Volume 10       Number 2       December 2008

Articles
Parties and Decision-making in the Indonesian Parliament: A Case Study of RUU APP, the Anti-
pornography Bill
Stephen Sherlock
159

Is Burmese Law Burmese? John Jardine, Em Forchhammer and Legal Orientalism
Andrew Huxley
184

Inducing a Constructive Press in Singapore: Responsibility over Freedom
Tey Tsun Hang
202

The Ties that Bind: Law, Islamisation and Indonesia’s Prosperous Justice Party (PKS)
Najwa Shihab and Yanuar Nugroho
233

The Newly Introduced Criminal Jury Trial in Korea: A Historic Step Toward ‘Criminal Justice by the 
People’
Kuk Cho
268

Increasing Press Freedom in Indonesia: the Abolition of the Lèse Majesté and ‘Hate-sowing’ 
Provisions
Naomita Royan
290

Book Review
Chinese Law: Context and Transformation
Sarah Biddulph
312



EUROPEAN CONSTITUTIONAL LAW REVIEW
Volume 5       Number 2       2009

Editorial
Internet Piracy and the European Political and Legal Orders
169

Articles
Free Movement, Immigration Control and Constitutional Conflict
Steve PEERS
173

Race judicata: The Ban on the Use of Ethnic and Racial Statistics in France
Mathias MÖSCHEL
197

Handle with Care! The Regional Charters and Italian Constitutionalism's ‘Grey Zone’
Giacomo DELLEDONNE &Giuseppe MARTINICO
218

European Legal Pluralism after Kadi
Samantha BESSON
237

International Law as a Tool for the European Union
Bruno DE WITTE
265

The Role of European Courts in the Development of a Hierarchy of Norms within International Law: 
Evidence of Constitutionalisation?
Erika DE WET
284

International Trade Law: The Impact of Justiciability and Separations of Powers in EC Law
Thomas COTTIER
307

Case Note
Belgium. Constitutional Court. The Limits of Constitutional Dialogue for the Prevention of Reverse 
Discrimination. Judgment 11/2009 of 21 January 2009
Peter VAN ELSUWEGE & Stanislas ADAM
327



FLINDERS JOURNAL OF LAW REFORM
Volume 11       Number 1       June 2009

Articles
Mind Death: South Australia, PVS and the Law
Brian Stoffell
1

Righting Wrongful Convictions with DNA Innocence Testing: Proposals for Legislative Reform in 
Australia
Lynne Weathered and Robyn Blewer
43

Ten Requirements for Successful Law Reform
Hon Michael Kirby
77

Reforming the Surrogacy Law of Australia: Some Thoughts, Considerations and Alternatives
Kathleen Simmonds
97

Book Review
Victims: A Juridical Approach
Michael O’Connell
123



JOURNAL OF THE HISTORY OF INTERNATIONAL LAW
Volume 11       Number 2       2009

Articles
Alberico Gentili and the Criticism of Expansion in the Roman Empire. The Invader’s Remorse
Kaius Tuori
205

Legal Imagination in Vitoria. The Power of Ideas
Pablo Zapatero
221

Nigeria, the British Presence in West Africa and International Law in the 19th Century
Michael Mulligan
273

On the Curious Disappearance of Human Servitude from General International Law
Jean Allain
303

Tracing the Earliest Recorded Concepts of International Law. (4) The Near East in the Late Bronze 
Age (1600-1200 BCE) (concluded)
Amnon Altman
333

Book Review
Time, History and International Law, Matthew Craven, Malgosia Fitzmaurice and Maria Vogiatzi 
(eds.)
Carlo Focarelli
357

Index of Authors
Vol. 1-11/1 (1999-2009)
365

Editorial Procedure
377



LLOYD’S MARITIME AND COMMERCIAL LAW QUARTERLY
Volume 2009       Number 3       August 2009

Case and comment
Consensus, separability and article 23 of the Brussels Regulation
(Deutsche Bank v. APBW)
275

Hazardous and noxious substances: Is the end in sight?
(Proposed Protocol to the HNS Convention 1996)
279

Arrbitration and litigation after West Tankers
(Youell v. La Reúnion Aérienne; National Navigation v. Endesa (The Wadi Sudr))
285

Charting the limits of the nautical fault exemption
(The Tasman Pioneer)
291

A further step towards protecting the performance interest
(Tabcorp Holdings v. Bowen Investments)
295

Articles
Contractual Prohibitions against assignment
Professor Sir Roy Goode QC
300

Reconsidering the defence of illegality in unjust enrichment
Dr Duncan Sheehan
319

The intersection of commercial powers and complaints: the Financial Ombudsman Service, 
consumer protection and the courts
P E Morris
344

The effect of subsequent increases of risk on contracts of insurance
Marcus Smith
366

The value of the salved ship
Francesco Siccardi
389

Book Reviews
Tetley: Marine Cargo Claims
402

Raphael: The Anti-suit Injunction
403

Saidov: The Law of Damages in International Sales: The CISG and other International Instruments
406

Saidov: Contract Damages: Domestic and International Perspectives
406

McLachlan, Shore and Weiniger: International Investment Arbitration: Substantive Principles
409

Cooke and Cornah: Lowndes & Rudoph: General Average and the York-Antwerp Rules (13th edn)
412

McFarlane: The Structure of Property Law
414



OXFORD JOURNAL OF LEGAL STUDIES
Volume 29       Number 3       Autumn 2009

ARTICLES
Private Life and the English Judges
RICHARD BUXTON
413

The Quest for Constitutionalism in UK Public Law Discourse
JO ERIC KHUSHAL MURKENS
427

‘Listing Concentrates the Mind': the English Civil Court as an Arena for Structured Negotiation
SIMON ROBERTS
457

Abstraction and the Rule of Law
WILLIAM LUCY
481

Inducing Breach of Contract, Conversion and Contract as Property
PEY-WOAN LEE
511

Global Error and Legal Truth
BRIAN H. BIX
535

Taking Values Seriously: 'Cowards a Philosophy of EU Law
ANDREW T. WILLIAMS
549

REVIEW ARTICLE
From Myth to Fiction: Why a Legalist-Constructivist Rescue of European Constitutional Ordering 
Fails
MING-SUNG KUO
579



OXFORD UNIVERSITY COMMONWEALTH LAW JOURNAL
Volume 9       Number 1       Summer 2009

Articles
How Far Can Trial Courts and Intermediate Appellate Courts Develop the Law?
J D Heydon
1

Fundamental Common Law Principles as Limitations Upon Legislative Power
Anne Twomey
47

The Implications of Implied Terms in Law in the Common Law Contract of Employment
Frank Carrigan
73

Case Comment
Robertson Quay Investment PTE Ltd v Steen Consultants PTE Ltd
Goh Yihan
101



REVIEW OF CENTRAL AND EAST EUROPEAN LAW
Volume 34       Number 3       2009

Articles
Do Discrimination an Inequality Exist in the Russian Legal System? International Law, National 
Legislation and Judicial Practice
Sergei Iu. Marochkin
211

The Redemption of State Securities: The Intersection of Civil and Budgetary Legislation in Russia
Olga V. Ishutina
239

Receivables Financing in Lithuania: Is the Legal Regulation Suited to Accommodate the Practical 
Needs of the Industry?
Lina Aleknait?
255

Book Reviews
Nataliia Ivanovna Marysheva, Semeinye otnosheniia s uchastiem inostrantsev: pravovoe 
regulirovanie v Rossii
Merja Norros
287

Zoltan Barany, Democratic Breakdown and the Decline of the Russian Army: Military Politics and 
Institutional Decay
Hans Oversloot
295

List of Contributors
301



REVIEW OF CONSTITUTIONAL STUDIES
Volume 14       Number 1       2009

The 19th Annual McDonald Constitutional Lecture: The Future of International Criminal Justice
Justice Richard Goldstone
1

Dismembering Canada? Stephen Harper and the Foreign Relations of Canadian Provinces
Christopher Kukucha
21

Representing People and Not Interests: A Rawlsian Conceptualization of the Right to Vote
Brian M. Studniberg
53

Back to the Future: The Paradoxical Revival of Aspirations for an Islamic State
Review of The Fall and Rise of the Islamic State by Noah Feldman
Mohammad Fadel
105



TEL AVIV UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW
Volume 31       Number 3       June 2009

Expanding Restitution
Ariel Porat
521

Alternative Trading Systems
Uriel Procaccia and Iris Argaman-Belahusky
565

Informed Consent and Duty to Disclose
Assaf Jacob
609

Critical Reflections on the Exemption of Pacifists from Military Service
Daniel Statman
669

More on Critical Reflections on the Exemption of Pacifists from Military Service—Response to 
Daniel Statman
David Enoch
709
CRIMINAL LAW REVIEW
Number 10       October 2009

Editorial
687

Articles
Sale of Alcohol to Children
Colin Manchester
689

The Drink-Drive Legislation and the Breath-Alcohol Cases
P.M. Callow
707

Money Laundering: The Disappearing Predicate
David McCluskey
719

Cases and Comment
723



JOURNAL OF WORLD INVESTMENT & TRADE
Volume 10       Number 4       August 2009

Compensation for the Breach of Relative Standards of Treaty Protection
Stephen Jagusch and Nicole Duclos
515

Revisiting the Necessity Concept
Jacques Werner
549

The Unpredictability Paradox: Punitive Damages and Interest in International Arbitration
John Y. Gotanda
553

Fragmentation of Cohesion? Investment Versus Cultural Protection Rules
Valentina Sara Vadi
573

BIT Clauses Bearing on the Ratione Temporis Jurisdiction of ICSID Tribunals. A Survey on the 
Constituent Elements of Investor-State Legal Disputes under BITs
Eduardo Savarese
601

Is the Erecting of Barriers against Sovereign Wealth Funds Compatible with International 
Investment Law?
Mathias Audit
617

Global Economic Recession and Protectionism: Legitimacy of the Proudly South African and Buy 
Local Campaigns
Joseph M. Senona
629



MODERN LAW REVIEW
Volume 72       Number 5       September 2009

ARTICLES
Straddling Two Worlds: Reflections of a Retired Criminal Cases Review Commissioner
Peter Duff
693

Putting Race and Gender Together: A New Approach to Intersectionability
Iyiola Solanke
723

A Tort-Based Approach to Damages under the Human Rights Act 1998
Jason N.E. Varuhas
750

LEGISLATION AND REPORTS
The United Kingdom’s Immunity from Seizure Legislation
Anna O’Connell
783

The Mortgage Arrears Pre-Action Protocol: An Opportunity Lost
Lisa Whitehouse
793

CASES
N v UK: No Duty to Rescue the Nearby Needy?
Virginia Mantouvalou
815

Strasbourg, the House of Lords of Elected Politicians: Who decides about rights after Re P?
Aileen Kavanagh
828

REVIEW ARTICLE
Law’s ‘Jewish Question’? The Holocaust and Critical Theory
David Fraser
844

BOOK REVIEWS
Ferrari (ed): The CISG and Its Impact on National Legal Systems and A. Janssen and O. Meyer 
(eds), CISG Methodology
867

Fisher: Risk Regulation and Administrative Constitutionalism
873

McFarlane: The Structure of Property Law
877