The University of Texas at Austin

Law in Popular Culture collection

The Complete Newgate Calendar
Volume V

APPENDIX

TRIAL BY BATTLE

THE "trial by battle" which was claimed in the case of Abraham Thornton
is thus described:
   When the privilege of trial by battle was claimed by the appellee, the
judges had to consider whether, under the circumstances, he was entitled to
the exercise of such privilege ; and his claim thereto having been admitted,
they fixed a day and place for the combat, which was conducted with the
following solemnities:-
   A piece of ground was set out, of sixty feet square, enclosed with lists,
and on one side was a court erected for the judges of the Court of Common
Pleas, who attended there in their scarlet robes; and also a bar for the ,
learned serjeants-at-law.  When the Court was assembled, proclamation was
made for the parties, who were accordingly introduced into the area by the
proper officers, each armed with a baton, or staff, of an ell long, tipped with
horn, and bearing a four-cornered leather target for defence. The com-
batants were bare-headed and bare-footed, the appellee with his head shaved,
the appellant as usual, but both dressed alike. The appellee pleaded not
guilty, and threw down his glove, and declared he would defend the same
by his body; the appellant took up the glove, and replied that he was ready
to make good the appeal body for body. And thereupon the appellee, taking
the Bible in his right hand, and in his left the right hand of his antagonist,
swore to this effect
   "Hear this, O man, whom I hold by the hand, who callest thyself
[John], by the name of baptism, that I, who call myself [Thomas], by the
name of baptism, did not feloniously murder thy father [William], by name,
nor am anyway guilty of the said felony. So help me God."
   To which the appellant replied, holding the Bible and his antagonist's
hand, in the same manner as the other:
   "Hear this, O man, whom I hold by the hand, who callest thyself
[Thomas], by the name of baptism, that thou art perjured, because that
thou feloniously didst murder my father, [William] by name. So help me
God and the saints ; and this I will prove against thee by my body, as this
Court shall award."
   Next, an oath against sorcery and enchantment was taken by both the
combatants in this or a similar form : " Hear this, ye justices, that I have
this day neither ate, drank nor have upon me either bone, stone or grass ; nor
any enchantment, sorcery or witchcraft, whereby the law of God may be
abased, or the law of the devil exalted. So help me God and His saints."

[325]


   The battle was thus begun, and the combatants were bound to fight till
the stars appeared in the evening.
   If the appellee were so far vanquished that he could not or would not
fight any longer, he was adjudged to be hanged immediately; and then, as
well as if he were killed in battle, Providence was deemed to have deter-
mined in favour of the truth, and his blood was declared attainted. But if he
killed the appellant, or could maintain the fight from sunrising till the star
appeared in the evening, he was acquitted. So also, if the appellant became
recreant and pronounced the word " Craven," he lost his liberam legem, and
became infamous; and the appellee recovered his damages and was for ever
quit, not only of the appeal, but of all indictments likewise of the same
offience. There were cases where the appellant might counterplead, and
oust the appellee from his trial by battle : these were vehement presumption
or sufficient proof that the appeal was true ; or where the appellant was under
fourteen or above sixty years of age, or was a woman or a priest, or a peer,
or, lastly, a citizen of London, because the peaceful habits of the citizens
were supposed to unfit them for battle.
   It is almost needless to add that this remnant of barbarity has now ceased
to exist, an Act of Parliament, the introduction of which was attributable to
the above case, having removed it from the pages of the law-books by which
our courts are governed.

[326]


Newgate Calendar Vol. V Table of Contents / The Complete Newgate Calendar