The University of Texas at Austin

Law in Popular Culture collection

Legal Studies Forum
Volume 27, Number 1 (2003)
reprinted by permission Legal Studies Forum
 
 
 

POETRY

by

GARY BOTTING
 
 
 

[303]

Small Claims 

Think of yourself
not as a woman at a hearing
   but as an orca diving
   her focus on glistening 
      possibilities, justice 
      hiding among the sea lettuce and the reeds
– and the shore seems not so very far away 
Think of the hearing
not as a hearing but as a sounding
   a plumbing of the depths
   not of dark oceans
      but of pristine coves and bays
      where treasures lie
– and the shore seems not so very far away 
Think of the sounding
not as a sounding but a listening
   deep beneath the waters
   voices distant yet distinct
      mind clear, wits keen
      lips pursed and parted
– and the shore seems not so very far away 
Think of the listening
not as a listening but as a mirror 
   windowing the dark days
   when the rain elbowed out the sun
      years of pretending to bask 
      in other peoples’ glory 
– and the shore seems not so very far away 
Think of the mirror
not as a mirror but as a claim
   made on your heart, your mind, your soul
   and let them understand that your small claim 
      is but a pond by comparison
      to the ocean of grief they have caused you
– and the shore seems not so very far away 

 

[304]

 

Autumn in New York

Remember that fleeting moment 
in Autumn in New York
when Richard and Winona
realize it is the beginning of the end?

In the background rising 
to the distant clouded skyline
two towers once so familiar
peek at their despair. 

This time as I watch the rerun
the moment strikes me as a blast of frost
from a discontented winter 
of lost dreams. 

Who can but weep for the swept horizon?
 
 

[305]

Alternate Routes

Time was when I was merely curious at your containment
marveling at the miracle of your manner
at your selfless, sensitive insistence
on simple love conceived as Either/Or.

You were the beacon-bearer, the lady with 
the lamp lighting divergent pathways
leading not to but through our paradise
(how difficult it must have been to walk alone).

At every crossroads I agonized anew:
shall I follow the mountainous country road
challenging, scenic and rewarding,
or shall I continue to hum along my highway?

I saw the pain on the faces of others 
who endured the ascent
so intent on reaching their destination
that they failed to focus on Nirvana.

How I long to embrace you,
not out of passion but with compassion
knowing my mindless highway-driving has led me 
to reject the gift of thy selfless love!
 
 

[306]

Canabanadaman

sea
to shining C
to shining see
you see?
the sea sees you
do you see me?
the UC has
no seers some say
some say it is no “C” at all
(you see one sea
you’ve seen ’em all)
united we stand
divided we fall

a seersuckered seer
with a secret to hear
with an ear for a secret
given up by the sea
presses his eye or his ear to the shell
and listens to portents of Caliban’s hell
(some say that Caliban
is a C.A.
chartered and charted and carted away
to stare at the stars or the seashore all day
at the shining sign of the see? and the eh?
that betoken the tokens he fingers all day)

can Caliban count?
why he counts not at all
except on his fingers
(some say he’s all thumbs)
he sits on the seashore and silently hums
while Ariel calculates Caliban’s count
and whispers in seashells the total amount

Caliban eats of the calabar bean
who knows what dreams or visions he’s seen?
who knows what dreams or what ordeals
a poisonous calabar bean eater feels?
 
 

[307]

where oh where is Caliban now?
tied to the earth we know not how!
torn between freedom and the ban
on liberty liberty liberty man
liberty ban
liberty ban
who can ban liberty?
liberty can!

in Flanders Fields a poppy blows
(whose woods these are still nobody knows)
the dead of dysutopias?
the dread of red-neck phobias?
all in the name of liberty!
bomb the ban with silver shells
ban the bomb with liberty bells
with bells bong bombs
with bombs bong bells
and the shells shells shells shells shells boom on
(and on and on and on and on)

ban the bomb and banish the Cruise
pan the poet and banish his muse
some say he fibs
some say he lies
some say he lives
some say he dies
Caliban Caliban
Dali in Maliban
reading the riverrun
ending beginagun
again be Finegan
superstone angel
(Hagar the horrible
all too Laurentian)

just as they did in the days of Noah
of the noh and the nada and the do not pass Goa
Rachel’s awailing to her kids
as yahweh waits for higher bids
bids from the US or UK or France
bids from the rising sun
 
 

[308]

bids from the stars
bids from ideas of competitive men
bids with a dollar sign
bids with a yen
bids from the widows
and bids from the wives
bids from the Calibans
spending their lives
accounting for ends that have no means
accounting for meanings that have no ends
accounting for all of this endingless mess
the meaningless meanness
the couldn’t care less

Canabanadaman
Canabanadaman
who can kill Canada?
Canada can!

the Calibans don’t have a clue what to do
but they do it they do it they do it again
with phenomenal skill for such ciphers of men
striving anew to renew the accounts
to keep them afloat with minuscule amounts
of “yearning” and “faith” and “the courage to be”
or either/or dicta and theosophy
of “I-Thou” Friday and “Thou-I” me

Canada man
Calibanada man
nothingness does
as nothingness can
reach for the heavens
reach out for a man
reach out for the oceans
and potions
and die
make an example 
of Caliban’s ghost
(take for example Ariel’s host –
some say intelligence flows through his hair
some say it never takes residence there)
 
 

[309]

Caliban dreams dreams he can’t understand
dreams of a force far beyond his command
dreams of a planet polluted and bare
nightmarish dreams of a blinding light
that nights up the heavens
and lights up the night
vanquishing earth with a grinding blight
(some say that Caliban
can’t see at all
Caliban’s own predictable fall)

nada
nada
nada
you see?
sea to shining c
U C?
a secret to hear given up by the sea
the seashell has sputtered in Caliban’s ear
he looks in his conch and finds Ariel near
like a sylph in Belinda’s unlockable hair
(and Ariel
laughing
abandons him there)

Caliban’s groan
passes down to the sky
(for Caliban’s answers are often awry)
aha!  he has doubts! at the end of his tether!
(unreason’s unseasonal lesions of “whether”)
he screams at the seas
he dots all his tees
he crosses his i’s
(some say this is wise)
for Ariel’s gone
and Caliban’s left
blaming poor Prospero for the grand theft
yet nobody prospered
and none takes the blame
for passing out passion
and hatred and pain
 
 

[310]

within the soul of a dying god
a new force stirs
demurs with a nod
and goes back to sleep
(there will be time)
waiting to rise as a phoenix bird dies
to pass beyond nada to meaning again
passing through nada
passing through pain
to an ecstasy born of the seashore again
to an ecstasy born of the
see?
 
 

[311]

Gary Botting  (1943-   ), began his writing career as a journalist with South China Morning Post in Hong Kong in 1961, and joined the editorial department of the Peterborough Examiner under the tutelage of its then publisher, Robertson Davies. After contributing to and editing various literary journals, he published his first collection of poetry in 1969. 
   Botting attended graduate school in Newfoundland (M.A. in English Language and Literature) and Alberta (Ph.D. in English and M.F.A. in playwriting) and then taught English and creative writing at Red Deer College in Alberta for 14 years, publishing or producing some 20 books and 30 plays, many of which won literary prizes. After attending law school in Calgary (1987-90), he was called to the British Columbia bar in 1991 and in his legal practice focused on criminal law and appellate practice. 
   Botting returned to graduate school at the University of British Columbia Faculty of Law in 1998 and the following year, having been awarded an LL.M., became a visiting scholar at the University of Washington School of Law in Seattle. 
   Now living in Deep Bay, Vancouver Island, Botting continues to write plays, novels, poetry and engage in scholarly writing as he completes a dissertation on extradition law for his second doctorate. 

*   *   *

“Canabanadaman” first appeared in Lady of My House (1986). The other poems appear, for their first publication, in the Legal Studies Forum

[312]