The University of Texas at Austin

Law in Popular Culture collection

Address to the jury by Col. John Hallum in self defense in the
              case of the state of Texas against him : an indictment for
              shooting a minister of the Gospel.


The Phoenix Press, Muskogee, Okla. [1911]


 
 

"Foreword." 

     The following speech of Col. Hallum's in self-de- 
fense, is printed by the undersigned for the purpose of 
preserving in print what is considered by the Bar of the 
South, the greatest exposition of the Unwritten Law. 
     The address to the jury certainly belongs to the higher 
class of forensic literature and for purity of diction, 
grandeur of thought and general excellence, is unsur- 
passed in legal literature. 

     The undersigned has sought diligently for two or three 
years for a copy of this masterpiece and finally located 
what is believed to be the last remaining copy in print. 
     This is reprinted for the sole purpose of preservation 
and not for profit. Only enough copies are printed to 
pay cost of publication. Owing to limited number print- 
ed the price must be fixed to pay the expense. 
     Copies of this great speech can be obtained from 
THOS. F. CROSBY, 
623 and 624 Flynn-Ames Building 
Price $1.00.                                      Muskogee,Okla.
 
 
 


State of Texas vs. John Hallum
BOWIE COUNTY, TEXAS 

October Term, 1896, and March Term, 1897 

    Indictment charged assault on W. A. Forbes on the 
29th of July, 1896, with intent to kill and murder. 
     I did shoot him four times and wounded him very dan- 
gerously with deliberate intent to kill him. 
     A large number of my friends, and especially relatives, 
have urged me to permit the publication of my address to 
the jury in my own interest on the trials of the case; but 
until now I have declined because I preferred that the 
trial and all the extraordinary incidents connected with 
it should perish in oblivion. But this passive action 
seems to have invited continuous falsehood by the bigots 
who sought my destruction in the bitterest and most vin- 
dictive persecution in the annals of modern jurispru- 
dence. 

FACTS.

     Forbes is a Missionary Baptist minister and my wife 
(now divorced) was a communicant in his church for two 
years at Lonoke, Ark., and afterwards four years at Tex- 
arkana. 
     He was a frequent and welcome guest in my home very 
often during my professional absence, and I never doubt- 
ed the purity of his intentions until the spring of 1895. 
By some arrangement between him and my wife he ad- 
vanced $680 to pay off a mortgage on my residence, which 
had become a judgment lien, and took an assignment of 
the lien. As additional security I conveyed to him over 
600 acres of land, which he was to sell and apply to the 
debt. 
-3- 

  During my protracted absence at Nashville, Tenn., in 
the spring of 1895, my wife, without consulting me, made
Forbes an absolute deed to our residence, and wrote me 
that it was by express agreement between her and Forbes,
intended simply as a better security for his debt. Under 
this assurance and the implicit confidence I had in 
Forbes, I also signed the deed at Nashville. To my ut- 
ter amazement Forbes immediately after getting the 
deed offered the place for sale at less than one-half its 
cost. This was reported by letter from my wife with the 
contradictory excuses for Forbes' action. 
     I immediately prepared a bill in chancery enjoining 
the sale and asking credit for the land conveyed to 
Forbes and sent it by mail to my wife with instructions 
to file it immediately, and she wrote that she had had a 
conference with Forbes and she refused to file it. 
     This conduct to me disclosed the disloyalty of each, 
and that a conspiracy between them existed to which no 
loyal wife could ever possibly become a party. 
     It is needless to say that my astonishment was only 
equaled by the indignation I felt. I immediately wrote 
to her a caustic letter fully disclosing the unfavorable 
convictions her conduct forced on me. At the same time I 
wrote to Forbes a letter of great severity, forbidding him 
to go to my house or to in any way advise or have commu- 
nication with my wife, and stated that a violation of the 
imperative injunction in any way would be visited with 
personal responsibility, and I sent my wife a copy of that 
letter. Then she wrote me that she was "in helpless and 
hopeless despair," but had gone and filed the bill, and 
enclosed a copy of the fiat of the judge for the injunction 
with her statement that every word in the bill was true. 
     Forbes then lived eighty miles distant from Texar- 
kana. Immediately on receipt of my letter forbidding 
any communication with my wife, he went to my house 
and was graciously received by my wife and held another 
long conference with her, and then went down into the 
city and boasted that his influence with her was greater 
than mine, and stated that the bill against him would not 
be prosecuted. The bill was in the joint names of myself 
and her against him, and she utterly refused to give any

-4- 

evidence or in any way aid in its prosecution, thus con- 
firming the conspiracy and relations that existed between 
them. I then said that I would kill him on sight, and it 
was no secret. I filed an amended bill, setting up the fact 
that she, although a party plaintiff, was secretly aiding 
the defendant, and asked that she be made a defendant, 
and the court so ordered. 
     I left her, of course, and after I left her she turned 
the house over to Forbes, although she had promised 
when she vacated to give me possession. 
     I give these particulars because the prosecution as- 
sumed the lawsuit to be the sole cause of my shooting 
him, when in fact it simply led to a disclosure, full and 
complete, of the criminal relations existing between 
them, for which alone I shot him. 
     She repeatedly refused to give any explanation of her 
conduct. She had a blind or secret opening from the alley 
into the back yard. Forbes often visited Texarkana for 
days at a time without any legitimate business. Finally, 
she read me the story of a soldier taking his wounded 
comrade off of the battlefield, and said: "That is my idea
of fidelity to a friend." To which I replied: "At last 
you give me this miserable explanation of your disloyalty 
to me and shameless fidelity to your paramour," and she 
replied, "You can construe it as you please." 
     Forbes' explanation was that he went to my house in 
violation of my injunction to see after a dress pattern, 
and that he did not think I would shoot him. This on 
cross-examination, and further that his interpretation of 
my letter was that I suspected improper relations be- 
tween him and my wife, and he admitted that he had 
stated that the suit would not be prosecuted. 
     On the second trial on cross-examination he admitted 
renting the Nix residence in Texarkana for a widow and 
her three little children; that he did this as a charity and 
auxiliary to the ladies' aid society, and stated that he had 
carried his wife once to see this widow and her three little 
girl children. He was not then aware that he would be 
compelled to confront an unimpeachable lady witness 
who would state the facts about his visits to and connec- 
tion with these three little girl children

-5- 

     Mrs. Howel, a relative of the sheriff, and many of the 
best citizens of Bowie county, was then put on the stand, 
and stated that the Nix residence, rented by Forbes, was 
the residence where her deceased mother had died, and 
then belonged to an absent sister, whom she represented 
in her absence; that the three daughters of the widow 
who occupied the house with their mother were appar- 
ently aged 16, 18 and 20 years, and that all three of these 
were notoriously lewd women; that she felt much indig- 
nation at the use of the property for any such vile pur- 
pose, and went to Forbes and urged him to take them out 
because of their disreputable characters, which he re- 
fused to do, and still continued his visits to these lewd 
women. That by finesse she got possession of one room 
of the house, and finally succeeded in driving Forbes and 
his tenants out; that she had much trouble and harsh 
words with Forbes, who obstinately persisted in protect- 
ing these lewd women. 
     This evidence came on him like a thunderbolt in a clear 
sky, and, although within reach of rebuttal evidence, if he 
had any, he never produced it nor did he return to the 
witness stand to contradict one word Mrs. Howell had said. 

FACTS IN CONNECTION WITH THE SHOOTING

     I had resolved with unalterable purpose to kill him, 
and the fact that I had so stated was communicated to 
him. I had often visited the depots and places where I 
expected to find him, without success. Finally, I went 
within sight of his residence and sent a negro there to 
find out where he was; found he was at New Lewisville, 
Ark., and went there and stayed one day and night. He 
was engaged in a protracted meeting and I did not see 
him. I knew that he often went to Texarkana; hence I 
went to Texarkana and watched the incoming train to
find and kill him. 
     A friend at Texarkana who knew my purpose and the 
facts which fixed that purpose in my mind, without my 
knowledge or procurement, wrote Forbes a decoy letter 
asking him to come to Texarkana and marry a couple, 
and he received a postal saying he would be there on the

-6- 

morning of the 29th. The friend showed me this reply, 
and I utilized it for all it was worth. Forbes stated that 
the letter was in my handwriting disguised. I told the 
prosecuting counsel and the jury, when on the witness 
stand, the facts as here stated, but added: "I don't want 
any doubt thrown over my statement of facts. You are 
all at perfect liberty, for all the purposes of this trial, to 
consider me the author of this letter." 
     He came and I was watching for him and came very 
near missing him. He did not get off where all the other 
passengers did. The train backs into the depot and he got 
off at the front end of the forward car. I was confident 
he saw me and avoided meeting me in that way, but he 
denies it. I waited for all the passengers to get off and 
failing to see him, rushed ahead of the retiring people 
and turned around to get another view. Then I saw him 
standing still. He looked at me and then turned west 
along the south side of the depot. I followed in haste on 
the north side and headed off his retreat. He faced me 
at the distance of thirty feet, and I said: "Why did you 
go to my house, after I forbid your visits?" and he said, 
"You lie!" and I pulled down on him, and would have 
shot him through the heart, but he turned as I pulled the 
trigger and the ball glanced and lodged against his spine. 
It staggered him, but he recovered and advanced on me, 
and I fired twice more before he reached me, hitting him 
very near the center of his neck. He reached me and 
knocked off the fourth shot, which hit the depot building. 
He struggled a short time for the pistol, and while he 
had the muzzle in hand, under his chin, I fired the fifth 
and last shot, which made the third shot in the neck. He 
staggered and fell in the depot, and before I could get 
out another weapon he was pulled on the floor into an- 
other room. I thought he could not live five minutes. My 
hands were covered with his blood. 
     The little Baptist church at Texarkana (shining mem- 
bers thereof) immediately after their shining brother 
was shot, got together and resoluted anathemas against 
me, in what they called an indignation meeting, and they 
aroused a mob spirit to lynch me, without ever alluding 
to my grievances or stating one fact in my favor. I 

-7- 

waived examination and was sent to jail by Justice 
Haywood. 
     The next evening I was brought to Texarkana. The 
train on which I came stopped after dark in the outskirts 
of the city, where I was taken in charge by Justice Hay- 
wood and a strong guard of armed men, and was in- 
formed that the Baptists had raised a mob spirit, and 
that I was brought out to protect me against such de- 
struction. I was given a double-barrel shotgun and, 
twenty rounds of blue whistlers, and was taken to the 
city hall, where I stayed an hour, whilst large numbers 
looked at me. They realized that hell was in the air, and 
that it would cost some blood to lynch me besides my 
own and they made "discretion the better part of valor." 
      These good Christians, having the promotion of re- 
ligion so much at heart, then appointed a committee to 
intercede with people to prevent my giving bond, and 
they put a corps of little Baptist preachers in the field, 
who preached hell and damnation and my funeral in
every nook and corner of Bowie county, to prejudice the 
people and make it impossible for me to get an impartial 
jury. 
     I shall ever feel grateful to Justice Haywood and the 
officers and guards he placed over me for their uniform 
courtesy and determination to resist, at the peril of  their 
lives, any violence offered me, and their noble conduct in 
resisting the appeals of deluded ladies of the Baptist 
church to put me in irons; also to Martin Foster who 
made my first bond regardless of the appeals to him not 
to do it. 
     Whilst the indignation meeting was laying its trains 
of explosives, my wife took a hand and left the bedside 
of a sick daughter to visit and instruct the district attor- 
ney and continued her utmost exertions to the end to con- 
vict me. Sympathizing members of the church poured 
consolation into the bosoms of both their criminal mem- 
bers and all concurred in the opinion that "Hallum would 
be consigned to a felon's tomb." She sent my children 
to see and condole with the bleeding libertine. 
     The local press shot skyrockets at me, and the con- 
temptible junto succeeded in boycotting the local bar, 

-8- 

against me, except William Hudgins, who appeared be- 
fore the committal court for me; but not in either trial of 
the cause. And here, lest I do injustice I must except 
Charles Todd, who would have defended me had he been 
present. He has the courage of his convictions, united 
to great talent and integrity of purpose. Judge Dillard, 
of DeKalb, Texas, came into the trial as my counsel, after 
the selection of the jury on the first trial; and he, with his 
personal friends, made my second bond. On the thir- 
teenth day of my imprisonment Martin Foster made my 
bond, and I returned to Little Rock to wait my trial in 
October. A guard accompanied me through the city to 
prevent mob violence, should any be attempted. 
     When I arrived in Texarkana on my way to trial, I 
learned for the first time that I would be required to 
give a new bond. I wrote to the judge and district at- 
torney informing them of that fact, and also that I would 
go back to Arkansas and secure indemnity for my bonds- 
men and return immediately to stand my trial. But the 
little junto of Baptists sent the sheriff after me as a 
fugitive from justice, and columns of sensational criti- 
cism appeared in the press. But they were forced to 
abandon that on the second trial and were sorry they 
urged it on the first, so complete was my refutations of 
the fugitive business. 
      The pulpit and the press had done their dirty work so 
effectively that I could not obtain a change of venue. My 
side of the case had not been tried in either of those jur- 
isdictions. I reserved my strength, and kept my powder 
dry. I applied to many members of the local bar for aid 
at least in selecting a jury, but the highly Christianized 
embargo went with the multitude. Judge Dillard had not 
then appeared in the case. 
     The first trial commenced on the 8th of October and 
ended on the 10th in a mistrial, ten of the jurors being 
for imposing the lowest penalty, a fine of $25, and two 
Baptists for conviction of a felony. It was the universal 
sentiment, without any solitary exception, before I made 
my own defense, that I would be convicted. I never for 
one moment thought so. The Hon. Hiram Glass, a very 
able lawyer, was district attorney, and conducted the 

-9- 

prosecution. Before I had spoken half an hour, it was 
clear to me that a conviction was impossible. The by- 
standers crowded around me and were removed back by 
order of the court four times before I closed. 
     A few weeks before my trial two similar cases had 
been tried in Texas. One resulted in a conviction of felony 
and sentenced for four years; the other in conviction and 
sentence for twenty years. This precedent and public 
opinion manufactured by the spiritual gentlemen were 
overwhelmingly against me. 
     The district attorney was kind enough to say to the 
jury in his reply in his opening sentence, "That speech 
was the finest piece of acting I ever saw on any stage,'' 
and he said afterward, that before my address, he would 
not have given 25 cents to insure conviction. 
     The second trial was on the 9th, 10th and 11th of 
March, 1897. The old officers, Judge Sheppard and Hiram 
Glass, district attorney, had gone out of office in the fall 
elections and were succeeded by Judge Tolbert and Rob- 
ert Hart, district attorney, with whom Pleasant Turner 
was associated in the prosecution. After my first trial I 
had a host of friends in Bowie county. When they saw 
how the public mind had been so grossly abused they re- 
volted at the injustice I had suffered, and manifested 
great interest in my behalf and treated me with the ut- 
most kindness and consideration. Many ladies came to 
hear me on the second trial and manifested much inter- 
est. I shall ever feel a deep sense of gratitude to the 
chivalrous gentlemen and noble ladies of that county for 
their unremitting attention and kindness to me in the 
hour of sorrow and trial. And to Judge W. W. Dillard, 
of DeKalb, Texas, who made my second bond, in connec- 
tion with his friends whom he induced to go on it, and 
who appeared in my behalf in the trials in both instances, 
language can never convey my sense of gratitude and ob- 
ligation to these gentlemen. 
     Herculean efforts were made to convict me of felony. 
Spies were sent to me in the guise of friends to entrap 
and forestall me, but being forewarned was to be fore- 
armed, and they failed to penetrate the veil. 

-10- 

      Elijah Adcock and his noble wife, W. W. Bloxham, Dr. 
H. A. Burrows, Oliver Daniels, J. L. Barfield, T. E. Dow- 
dle, W. P. Lash, Lyman S. Roach, F. M. Brooks, and a 
host of others, both ladies and gentlemen, became the 
best and truest of friends after my first trial. 
     The trial resulted in a fine of $50 and a very large 
bill of costs. But the good people of Bowie county would 
not let me pay one cent. In a few minutes after the jury 
rendered their verdict I was handed a receipt and dis- 
charged from custody. My friends were enthusiastic 
over the result. The Hon. Charles Todd, one of the ablest 
lawyers and best men of Texas, immediately after the 
rendition of the verdict, said "As much as I love my 
native state, if that old man had been convicted of a fel- 
ony I would have folded my tent and left the state. 
     Both Judge Sheppard and Judge Tolbert, before whom 
the trials were had, are very able, upright and impartial 
judges, as their charge to the jury shows, which I give in 
the appendix.*  Mr. Hart, the district attorney, in the 
desperation of his cause, threatened to resign if I was 
not convicted of a felony, but thought better of it after- 
wards and held on to his job. The whole contest was over 
the charge of felony. I did not controvert the fact that 
I was guilty of an assault under the statute. 


ADDRESS TO THE JURY

     Gentlemen I am arraigned before you under circum- 
stances as extraordinary and vindictive as the junto of 
religious bigots and traducers of my good name could 
make it. In the name of the religion they profess and 
disgrace they have stooped to methods low and vile to 
compass my ruin. 
     I know no parallel in the history of American juris- 
prudence since the prosecutions for witchcraft in New 
England in the days of Cotton Mather. Nor do I know 
of a darker parallel in the history of English jurispru- 
dence since the abolition of the ecclesiastical Court of 
High Commission, which in the name of religion, con- 
signed men and women to be burnt at the stake for con- 
scientious religious convictions, and for minor offenses, 

*[Not included in this edition]

-11- 

cropped ears and slit the noses of helpless victims. The 
methods adopted by the infamous court of Star Chamber, 
under the no less infamous reins of the House of Stuart, 
was not the less derogatory to humanity and justice and 
civilization, than the methods adopted by priests and 
their lay coadjutors in this prosecution. 
     I am an utter stranger to this jury and the people of 
your county, from which you have been selected, and you 
know nothing of me except the vile slanders which have 
been filtered through the ulcerated hearts and tongues 
of the members of the Baptist church at Texarkana, and 
their associate priests and laymen, whom they have set 
after me in pulpit, highway and private residence. They 
have industriously preached my funeral all over the 
county for the twofold purpose of rendering it imposs- 
ible to get an impartial jury, and to cover up the infamy 
and shame of the scoundrel I shot and the woman he 
ruined. This hypocritical corporation of priests and lay- 
men have lauded their lascivious brother and fallen sis- 
ter in the church to the skies and have tried to damn me 
to perdition. They have knowingly lied to deceive the 
public. 
     Their indignation meeting to encourage and inspire 
mob violence having failed through their fears to mat- 
erialize, they then tried to poison the public mind against 
me, and succeeded for the time in accomplishing that 
part of the programme. This junto of falsifiers knows no 
more of the true principles of Christianity than a herd 
of hyenas know of political economy. 
     I shot one of their sanctimonious herd of ghouls who 
now poses with them as a martyr before you with per- 
jury on his lips as rank as the crime for which he was 
shot. The same may be said of the junto, who stoop 
to subordinate the vices which pertain to the lower order 
of men for the purpose of covering up the vilest crime. 
When you strike one of these bigots you hit the whole 
guild and they all show their teeth. When evil deeds filter 
through this close corporation of bigots to the public ear, 
its leaders apply for a package of the devil's virus, la- 
beled whitewash and they apply it vigorously. This is 

-12- 

a contest between virtue and vice, between truth and 
falsehood. 
     Not the least of the extraordinary methods resorted to 
by this junto of saints lies in the fact that they succeeded 
in boycotting the local bar by deterring them from de- 
fending me. (Judge Dillard, who appeared is not of the 
local bar. He lives at DeKalb). Charles Todd would 
have defended me had he been present. He is an able 
man, possessed of the courage of his convictions united 
to integrity of purpose. The fact of being deserted by 
the local bar added much to the weight of public opinion 
against me. It shows the weakness of some men. Wil- 
lows bend before the storm, oaks resist the tempest. I 
leave a generous public to judge whether they sustained 
the dignity of a noble profession and that distinguishing 
individuality of character which each member ought to 
possess. You gentlemen occupy the judgment seat, the 
highest position man can assign his fellow mortal. If 
there is a tribunal on earth where all the passions and 
prejudices of men should sink in the presence of all that 
is divine in man it is the judgment seat. Pagan priests, 
jurists and philosophers recognized this many centuries 
before the Christian era, and they represented the god- 
dess of justice as blindfolded, that she might not know 
the contestants nor partake of their passions and preju- 
dices. From this you will readily perceive what I con- 
ceive to be the greatest obstacle in my way, and yet I do 
not entertain the slightest doubt of removing that before 
I get through. Long experience at the bar, from a petty 
justice court to the highest tribunals in the land, con- 
vinces me that the influence of counsel with juries and 
judges rises or falls in a ratio with the ability and can- 
dor with which he deals with facts. And it further justi- 
fies the conviction that it is often a herculean task to re- 
move preconceived prejudices, especially so when tinged 
with religious bigotry and intolerance. But nearly all 
men when removed or lifted above these baneful influ- 
ences will render what they conceive to be a just verdict. 
     Forced to exercise my reserved right under your con- 
stitution to defend myself, I shall ex necessitate rei be 
compelled to say much of myself, like Paul when ar- 

-13- 

raigned before Agrippa and Festus, after escaping lynch- 
ing by the Jews, which under other conditions would be 
vulnerable to criticism. 
     I have an interest by inheritance in the history and 
fame of Texas which carries with it a right to be respect- 
fully heard by Texans, whether citizens by birth or adop- 
tion. When Texas, with but a handful of patriots was 
in the toils of war and revolution, led by that great his- 
toric character, Sam Houston, against greatly superior 
members of tyrants her cry of distress and appeal for 
aid to the neighboring commonwealths of the United 
States reached the Hallum family on their native heath 
in that glorious old volunteer state that gave me birth. 
They knew and loved Sam Houston--had fought the sav- 
ages by his side under Jackson in the wilderness. That 
appeal stirred "the heroic tide that poured through their 
dauntless hearts," and they gave Houston and Texas two 
of their generous and heroic sons. 
     The gallant and chivalric Henry Hallum, my father's 
brother, and the Hon. W. R. V. Hallum, known as Ranse 
Hallum, my father's first cousin, like the gallant knight 
of Ivanhoe, traveled many weary miles, and with trusty 
rifles in hand threaded their way through hostile tribes 
of Indians to the camp of Sam Houston and shared 
with him and compatriots the dangers and the fadeless 
glory of San Jacinto. With them they stood sponsors 
to the bloody baptism of Texas into the sisterhood of na- 
tions--with them they lifted the star that thrills your 
patriotism to that exalted firmament where I, with you, 
hope it will forever shine with the undiminished lustre 
of its birth as one of the greatest in the grandest aggre- 
gation of states the world has yet known. Rome, when 
she claimed to be mistress of the world, was a dwarf 
compared to these states. 
     Henry Hallum never returned to his family, whose tear- 
ful farewell on the banks of the historic Cumberland, 
where he buckled on his armor and weighed anchor for 
the distant scene of conflict to fight your battles, was the 
last. But he left an honorable heritage to them, and to 
you, and to all the coming generation of Texas. Soon 
after the battle he sickened and died of disease contract- 

-14- 

ed in your service in the meridian of a splendid manhood, 
and was buried where the city of Houston now stands, 
and his ashes glorifies the soil he fought to redeem. 
     The Hon. W. R. V. Hallum, after filling many places 
of honor and trust, was taken to his fathers, and in all 
the traditions and history of the family there is nothing 
we love more than the simple inscription on the marble 
shaft which marks the spot where he lies awaiting the 
judgment day, "He fought under Houston at San Ja- 
cinto." No truer, no braver men ever drew a sword or 
wore a plume in the carnage of battle, and their heirs  . 
have never bartered the heritage of their fame for a 
Texas land grant. 
     My brother-in-law, Capt. Angus Greenlaw, was 
another one of the heroes of San Jacinto. No braver sol- 
dier ever pulled a trigger or wielded a sword in battle; 
no truer man to all the demands and relations of life ever 
lived. His remains repose in Elmwood, that city of peace 
by the great inland river. I was with him in his expiring 
hour, and with tearful eyes and gentle hands helped to 
lay him away. 
     The chief executive of this nation, under whose admin- 
istration Texas was incorporated into the federal union, 
was related to my family. 
     But the heraldry of these men lend no importance to 
me, if otherwise I am found without meritorious consi- 
deration, wholly my own, and I claim none, but simply 
mention them as inducements  to conviction in your 
minds, that in common with every other man accused of 
crime, I ought not to be denied the guarantee of a fair 
and impartial trial under the organic sanction of your 
laws. 
     I am on trial for shooting a clergymen, who for a ser- 
ies of years had been cordially invited and welcomed to 
the hospitalities of a cultured and refined home. Invited 
there and pensioned on its hospitality because of the re- 
ligion and purity of life he so blandly and artfully pro- 
fessed and disgraced. 
     His duties were by precept, example and exposition to 
teach the exalted doctrine of the gentle Nazarene, who 
"went about the world doing good," and with index fin- 
ger to point and lead the way to God and immortality. 

-15- 

Those duties are beautifully set forth by Goldsmith, the 
Anacreon of Ireland, in his description of the village 
parson: 
"Like the bird each fond endearment tries, 
To tempt its new fledged offspring to the skies; 
He tried each art, reproved each dull delay 
Allured to brighter words and led the way," 
     Every possible  confidence  was reposed in this pen- 
sioner on the charities and bounties of religion. If there 
is one spot on earth luminously marked by the Creator 
as typical of the glorious fruitions of the eternal day; 
if there is one hallowed and consecrated spot, where in 
this transitory life all that is true, lovely and pure in 
human character rises to the surface and banishes every 
sordid infirmity and sanctifies hallowed associations; if 
there is one spot above all others where all that is divine 
in the character of man rises to the surface and sheds its 
beneficient influences for time and eternity it is the fam- 
ily home; whether the humble abode of the cotter or the 
palace that covers a throne. If there is one crime trans- 
cending all others in enormity, it is that of the clergymen 
pensioned on the revenues and confiding hospitalities 
of that home, to promote the culture and practice of true 
Christianity, who uses the opportunities thus afforded to 
lead the wife and mother down to a rayless night and an 
endless hell. 
     There is not, there never can be in the wide world of 
crime, a death so mournfully sorrowful and heartrend- 
ing as the extinction of virtue in a living corpse, once the 
intelligent wife and mother. "The parting of the ways" 
when virtue bids its eternal farewell to all that is exalted 
and pure in earth and heaven; carries all down, down, for- 
ever down in the wreck of time and eternity. All other 
deaths leave hope, virtue, family pride and fame, to sur- 
vive, blended in fond memory with a loving and refining 
sorrow. But when the wife yields to `primrose dalliances' 
of Judas Iscariot in clerical robes and consents to be-
come the faded refuse of a violated bed, nothing is left 
to the household idols that once surrounded her but a 
wilderness of rayless and hopeless sorrow. 
     I once loved that woman with an idolatry surpassing 
oriental idealism, and then, if I had had an empire I 

-16- 

would have placed the crown on her head. Of all men the 
world has known, I am more deeply concerned in the 
chastity and purity of her once noble character than all 
others--but  alas! alas! there is nothing left even for 
rational credulity to base a hope that my convictions 
are not true. If I could be convinced that she is yet the 
pure woman I led to the fatal altar, I would give, if pos- 
sessed of a thousand lives, all for the consolation of that 
conviction. To those who cannot stand in my shoes,
those who cannot suffer as I have suffered, to those who 
cannot feel as I feel, this declaration may appear as an ex- 
travaganza, therfore, I do not ask the jury to believe it 
but I lay it at the foot of the throne that the Great 
Searcher of all hearts may attest its sincerity as He will 
judge me on the final day. 
     My age admonishes me that the record for that inevi- 
table hour is near completion, and I wish to shun the at- 
titude of appearing to make untrue statements. To save 
my innocent children, I am ready to make any sacrifice, 
however great, save that of my honor--to sacrifice that 
would involve them. I wish you to look in on my heart 
as in a mirror; like the sun it has its spots, but what man 
since the creation has escaped imperfection in some de- 
gree? 
     In this fierce contest between virtue and truth on one 
side and vice and falsehood on the other, I rely solely on 
the invincible power of truth. It is the central idea which 
glorifies our God--the pivot on which He has balanced 
the mechanism of the Universe. 
     Though crushed to the earth by multitudes of people 
it will rise again on crystal wings, and in the crisis of a 
conflict like this it needs no aid, but a mind powerful 
enough within its own resources to discover, and expose 
falsehood. It spurns the arts of sophistry and devices of 
the demagogue. Its essence is as pure and eternal as the 
God it glorifies; whilst falsehood rots and perishes and 
forever inspires loathing and contempt in all the better 
types of mankind. 
     "Thrice is he armed whose cause is just," and there 
is a divinity in the nature and character of man when 
true to himself through storm and through sunshine, in 
which I repose the same absolute confidence that Bona- 

-17- 

parte, the man of destiny, did when he seized the eagles 
of France, rallied his recoiling, shattered columns and 
led the victorious charge at Lodi, in the face of a catar- 
act of fire from one hundred pieces of cannon and one 
hundred thousand muskets. 
     I was never born for penal servitude at the behests of 
a junto of a whoring church hypocrites, whose disgrace 
and defame the name of the religion they parade under 
the fiendish devices of hell in the name of purity. 
     Madame Roland, a victim of the French Revolution, 
when on the way to execution passed a statute of liberty, 
and exclaimed, "Ah, liberty, what crimes are committed 
in thy name!" Paraphrased, we may with much greater 
emphasis say, "Ah, religion, What crimes are committed 
in thy name!" 
    Here, lest I be misunderstood, let me say I believe in 
the inspiration of Moses and the prophets and the divinity 
of Christ, and entertain a profound respect for all sin- 
cere Christians of whatever sect, but I have a profound 
contempt for the religious bigot and hypocrite--that it
is only the hypocrite I am now after. He is found in all 
churches, in fact my observation confirms the conviction 
that the churches are composed of two extremes of so- 
ciety--the sincere Christian and the knavish hypocrite 
who "puts on the livery of heaven to serve the devil.'' He
is a goody, goody fellow, who puts up long prayers in 
public and wears a sanctimonious face, and to the out-
ward world assumes a fitness and readiness to be trans- 
lated. They are the men who whitewash libertine clergy- 
men and give them a certificate of exemplary Christian 
character, when the force of public opinion forces their 
removal to another seat of the saints, that they may 
again recruit their theological harem. They are the men 
who held the indignation meeting to incite mob violence 
the morning I shot the libertine they so love and admire. 
     To protect and screen such a man from public scorn 
and the odium his character deserves is the gravest of 
crimes against society, and to do it in the name of reli- 
gion is blasphemy against God and the Savior of man- 
kind. 

-18- 

      It is impossible conceive of a greater crime than 
that which he committed against me and mine. Murder, 
arson, robbery, rape and  every other crime leave their 
victims still in possession of the greatest of all posses- 
sions--their virtue. If with dagger in hand, he had stolen 
into my home at the dark and silent hour of midnight 
and murdered all its inmates; it would have been a trans- 
cendent blessing compared to the crime he did commit. 
     This is the caricature on manhood whom this close cor- 
poration of hypocrites preach up all over Bowie county 
as "the greatest man who ever entered the State of 
Texas." The thief crying "Stop thief!" for the purpose 
of deceiving the public and arousing a spirit of indigna- 
tion against me, so as to render it impossible to get an 
impartial jury in this county. 
     Let me say to you, gentlemen, in all sincerity, that I 
would have shot the base-born libertine if the angels 
of heaven had been guarding him when I got within gun- 
shot of him, and that I would have camped on his trail a 
thousand years, if we could have lived that long and it 
had required that time to come up with him. And let me 
say further, that I shot him with all the coolness and pre- 
meditated deliberation that it is possible for a rational 
mind to conceive, and I hope this deliberate statement 
will relieve the gentlemen from all further labored effort 
about malice and premeditation, preparation and de- 
liberation. If it were possible for the same emergencies 
to arise a thousand times, I would repeat the same remedy 
in each case in defiance of all the penal statutes of the 
world. 
     There are some things in which I fix my own stand- 
ards, and this is one of them. The remedy I applied is 
certainly more effectual than sacramental wine or catnip 
tea. There is an over-production of these libertine clergy- 
men just now in this country, and the whitewashing pro- 
cess has indefinitely increased the number beyond its 
preservative virtues, and the hypocrites who employ this 
stale, antiquated remedy must accept mine until his 
satanic majesty furnishes them with a better one. I have 
there on the table before me a record of twenty of these 
high priests in the temple of religion who have tempor- 

-19- 

arily resigned that occupation until they graduate in 
the various preparatory departments in the penitentiary 
reformatories of many states of this union. I simply men- 
tion this to corroborate my statement about the decline 
in the preservative virtues of whitewash and necessity 
for better remedies.
     I am not one of those negative, passive characters, who 
wire and worm their way through life without jostling 
up against any of its rough edges. Such men are incapa- 
ble of coping with the great emergencies of life. There
are sometimes junctures in our lives when to submit to 
indignities would involve hopeless degradation, and the 
injury for which I washed my hands in the blood of the 
libertine is one of them. I would have shot him had I 
known it would have involved my instant death. 
     Has any or all the records of mankind, or of hell, any 
darker or more revolting picture of human depravity 
than that of the libertine priest administering the Lord's 
sacrament to the wife he has ruined? The hero of the 
hypocrites, who shield and laud him, often repeated both 
crimes. He and his junto of hypocrites have induced my 
child to come here with him to influence the selection 
and corruption of this trial jury with the ruined mother's 
sanction. "Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned." 
     I defy and challenge all the records of mankind, all the 
horrid imps of Dante's Inferno, and all the records of hell 
to produce a meaner man than W. A. Forbes. Down, and 
downward, forever hellward, the trend of his degrada- 
tion--to influence a wife and child to seek a husband's 
and father's blood--nay, a thousandfold worse, to see his 
degradation in penal servitude. You gentlemen must re- 
member that this contest is only over the felony charged 
in the indictment and not on the assault embraced in it, 
which I admit. 
     Yea, still more than all this and his heroic lying under 
oath. He has held his innocent wife up as a screen be- 
tween him and the whorehouse he established in Texar- 
kana. You remember he admitted renting the private resi- 
dence of Mrs. Nix, deceased, and placing a widow and her 
three daughters in it. That he swore these daughters 
were little children; that he paid the rent out of his own 
funds as an auxiliary to the ladies' aid society; that he 

-20- 

carried his wife there and was frequently there to see 
them. This had a plausible and charitable phase on it. 
But Mrs. Howel, a witness and lady of irreproachable 
character, who is connected with many of the best fam- 
ilies of your county told you that these little children 
were grown women of notorious ill-fame and that she 
had much trouble in driving them out because of Forbes' 
persistent protection of these loose women. His counsel, or 
that of the syndicate of hypocrites who employed him to 
prosecute in this case, Mr. Turner says, "Forbes had 
private funds of his own, and did not use the church 
money" on the nest of wenches he established in the Nix 
residence. This apology is enough to damn any man. 
     But the advocate says, "His intentions were good." 
Yes, hell is paved with good intentions, and a hypocrite 
was never known to entertain other than good intentions. 
The syndicate of hypocrites who inspired a mob feeling 
against me without the courage to lead it, no doubt had 
good intentions, which assumed an angelic character 
when they found it would cost some blood to execute me. 
It is an awful injury and shock to a refined Christian 
community to shoot an evangelist who takes the Bible in
one hand and his libertine possessions in the other and 
works with both for the benefit of society. 
     Let me say, associated as my lineage is with the best 
people and phase of your history, if I am to be stricken 
down for defending the purity of my home and avenging 
myself on the man who has destroyed and thrown a pall 
of desolation over it, then I would say in the language of 
the gifted Prentiss, "Tear down the star that answers to 
the name of Texas, but let the stripe on your national
ensign remain as an emblem of her degradation." 
     This desolation leaves me and my children standing on 
the sands of a shoreless sea, looking out on the awful 
ruins of a once happy home which God Almighty cannot 
repair. In the dark shadows of that ruin I see two skele- 
tons with fleshless bones and eyeless sockets, and grin- 
ning teeth, mocking God. 
     Often have I read the record of King David's great 
sorrow that will survive the wreck of worlds when that 
greatest man in the lineage of the Savior, from the depths 
of his agonized heart exclaimed, "Absalom, Absalom, oh, 

-21- 

my son Absalom" and as often have my sympathies been 
stirred to their foundation.  Little did I think that a cruel 
and remorseless fate had in store for me a greater sor- 
row, that would cause my soul to quiver on its founda- 
tion in the echo, "Children, children, oh, my innocent 
children."  That they should be carried down in a con- 
flagration set on fire by a priest enjoying the hospitality 
of my household to promote their spiritual welfare, is an 
enormity beyond the endurance of God--much less hum- 
anity.*
     I wish I were a Roman of the iron age, and could this 
hour die like Napoleon's guard at Waterloo. 
     I crave the indulgence of generous mankind for my 
children who are innocent sufferers from agencies wholly 
foreign to any infirmity of their own. They are pure and 
refined and incapable of intentional wrong. With them, 
as with me, the pall falls as heavily as that which shroud- 
ed the cross of Calvary and rent the temple through the 
turpitude of false priests. I am not stoic nor Spartan 
enough to crush back the tears which such calamities 
bring. 
     Their lineage, with the detraction temporarily thrown 
over my name, will pass away and perish with the false- 
hoods in which it originated. Then with filial devotion 
they will bend their pilgrim feet to the humble mound 
where my ashes rest. On it they will drop a rose and a 
tear, from which incense will ascend with their prayers 
to heaven, and they will rise up and feel glorified that 
they were sired by man who defied all the powers of 
earth and hell and rode the storm in defense of their hon- 
est inheritance of a good name--who fought their battles, 
worthy of his own lineage and their filial affection. 
     They have been taught, and they know that "virtue is 
its own reward;" that it is of the essence of God; that it 
shines and flashes like the diamond under all conditions; 
that it is beyond the power of tongue or pen to lend it a 
charm, because its native glories lie beyond their reach 
in a heavenly halo of cloud through which such agencies 

*Here the speaker's emotion overcame him for a few moments,
and the jury and audience were in profound sympathy with him  Re-
covering he proceeded.

-22- 

cannot struggle.  The man who would assail it ought to 
be "whipped with a scorpion's lash" until time is no 
more. 
     The world holds no sorrow greater than ours. They 
have bloomed into beautiful, refined womanhood. I am 
left in advanced age with but one dominant desire on 
earth--the honor of my children and lineage. The future 
holds nothing in store for me this side the dark river. I 
am this hour fighting my last battle for more than an 
empire is worth, either to my children or self. With the 
close of this address my bannor is forever furled. What 
man at my age, laboring under such incurable calamities, 
can forget them in the onrushing tide of human pursuits 
and again essay the higher fields of honorable ambition, 
and give his arrows the sweep of the sun, no matter
how far short of its splendid meridian they may fall.*
     In the expression of sorrow I do not for one moment 
wish you to think it springs from having shot this mon- 
ster of depravity. I did it coolly, deliberately, and with 
preparation adequate to the end; and if the same provo- 
cation could arise a thousand times, I would as often 
repeat the act. It has the entire approval of my con- 
science, the endorsement of all the higher types of man- 
kind in all ages, and the sanction of God. 
     When Moses, the great shepherd prophet, was called 
first to Horeb, and then to the flaming clouds around the 
summit of Sinai, God wrote with his own finger on tab- 
lets of stone a commission to all the children of man to 
destroy the libertine priest who enters the household and 
uproots hallowed family ties and associations. All stu- 
dents and men of any depth of thought and research 
known[sic] that Moses was clothed with both spiritual and 
political power, and that the ten commandments were 
God's organic sanction for the exercise of all that vast 
power and authority in His name. In every book of the 
Pentateuch Moses has denounced the penalty of death 
against these enemies of the human race, going so far 

*At this point the Court suspended proceedings for a 
few minutes, when the sheriff conducted through the bar 
the wife of Rev. Mr. Coleman,  Methodist minister, who, 
with a cordial grasp of the hand, said, "In behalf of the ladies 
present, and myself, I am authorized to say 'God bless you; 
we wish the world had more such men.' " To which I re-
plied, "Tell the ladies 'God bless them for their encouragement; 
that with their endorsement I feel master of the situation.' "

-23- 

in the exercise of his divine authority as to say, "Their 
souls shall be cut off from among men," thus denoun- 
cing the annihilation of these social Judas Iscariots as 
unfit to associate with those undergoing penal servitude 
in hell. In all the seventy cities of refuge established in 
Israel these false priests were not permitted to take re- 
fuge in any of them. 
     The mission of Christ, the great successor of Moses, 
was solely spiritual, and there is not one line or word in 
the Christian dispensation, either directly or impliedly 
repealing the death penalty denounced against these 
social monstrosities who blaspheme the name of God by 
uprooting in His name the dearest and holiest ties which 
ennoble and elevate man. In the sermon on the Mount 
he said, "Thou shalt not kill without a cause." 
     I admit that the Christian dispensation repeals a large 
body of ceremonial and ritual law under the Mosaic dis- 
pensation, including the political power of the priest- 
hood, but the ten commandments are left as they stood 
when handed down from Sinai, and the socially rotten 
priest may be dealt with under the Christian dispensa- 
tion and slain wherever found. 
Whom God hath joined together let no man 
   put asunder."
"Render unto Caesar the things which belong 
   to  Caesar."
     The polluted priest is equally guilty under both dispen- 
sations. The fallacy lies in supposing it to be murder to 
destroy such a reptile. 
     Don't insult my intelligence nor degrade my manhood 
by talking to me in the twaddle of the nursery about the 
possible purity of priest and wife in face of the proved 
and admitted fact he went to my house in defiance of 
my imperative injunction not to go there under penalty 
of death--in face of the fact that the wife had a written 
copy of this injunction when she received him in to my 
house with the cooing blandishments of illicit attach- 
ment. I would have shot him for the violation of that 
injunction, whether he had ever consummated his hell- 
ish purposes or not. 
     The gentlemen need not distress their refined powers 
of hair-splitting logic about the possibility of pure in- 
tentions in these derelict parties. I broaden their plat- 

-24- 

form that they may shuffle their technical feet with 
more grace and less derision. 
     As Brutus said to Cassius, "I would rather be a dog 
and bay the moon," than live with a woman who would 
thus desecrate and soil the consecrated joys of home.
Yes, as Othello in his mournful soliloquy said in the hear- 
ing of Iago, "I'd rather be a toad and feed on the vapors 
of a dungeon'' than keep a wife for another man's use. 
Poor Ophelia, in the great tragedy of Hamlet, said to 
Laertes, "Do not as some ungracious pastors do, show 
me the steep and thorny way to heaven, while he a puffed 
and reckless libertine, himself the primrose path of dal- 
liance treads." 
     How true to life the description of this puffed up 
Judas. When Hooks told him I had threatened his life, 
he swelled up like a toad and said, "I am not hunting a 
fight, but I am here." Judge Byrne and others, he says, 
told him of the same threat. It was no secret., 
     He came down into the city the day he visited my 
house in violation of my imperative injunction not to go 
there, and boasted that the then joint suit of myself and 
wife against him would not be prosecuted, and that he 
had more influence with my wife than I had. On cross- 
examination he admits these statements. 
     I have now said all I care to say of the personal re- 
lations of this case to my children, lineage and self. 
The interest we have in it sinks into utter insignificance com- 
pared to that the great body of the public have in it. 
Society itself is on trial, at a critical period, when virtue 
and morality is on a fearful downward trend, without
any apparent protest against the advance of the social 
revolution which threatens so much to the sanctity of 
the home and to the state itself. 
     I will not waste anymore of my limited time by stand- 
ing here like an old oak defiantly hurling its shattered 
branches to the fierce sweep of the tempest of human 
passions which now roll around me, but like Scipio Af- 
ricanus I will carry the war into Africa, and when the 
smoke of the battle clears away we will see whether 
Rome or Carthage is master of the field of Zama. 
     After I have replied to some of the arguments urged 

-25- 

with more zeal and vehemence than sound judgment, 
against me by Mr. Turner, who opened the prosecution, 
I shall have much to say of a debased clergy and their 
baneful influence on the destinies of mankind.  I will 
then contrast those peoples and nations who hold in the 
highest esteem the virtue of their women with those peo- 
ples who have tolerated either a laxity or a want of vir- 
tue in their women.  It occurs to me that a broad, com- 
prehensive view of these pivotal questions in the des- 
tinies of man will shed much light and enable you to 
pronounce a verdict founded on wisdom and justice. 
     (Turning to Mr. Turner.) Now, sir, hear me; be you 
Saxon thane or Norman lord, I throw down the gage of 
battle to you.  In the audacity of reckless despair and 
falsehood you have attributed to me the basest motives 
that could animate the lowest order of men, in the false 
assertion that I shot this monster of iniqiuity  to vent 
malice growing solely out of a lawsuit. The record shows 
that the letter I wrote to Forbes in the peremptory terms 
commanding him to cease his visits to my house and com- 
munication in any way with the mother of my children, 
was written before the commencement of the lawsuit. 
This fact alone puts the seal of condemnation on that 
false, cruelly false assertion. No innocent man, no gen- 
tleman would ever have violated that injunction. No 
loyal wife would ever have permitted that visit. No gen- 
tleman worthy of the dignity of husband and father 
would have permitted the violation of that injunction to 
go unpunished. 
     No loyal wife would have refused to file the bill, which 
she afterwards states in a letter lying there on the table 
to contain no statements but that which she knows to be 
absolutely true. 
     Her refusal to file that bill; her subsequent conduct 
from that time until this hour in executing the behests 
of the false priest; the secret gate; his going to my house 
and reading the bill I sent her to file; the conference re- 
sulting in the refusal to file until after I had made the 
enormity of this disreputable and disloyal conduct plain 
to her by letter from Nashville; his second visit to my 
house, directly after she had reluctantly filed the bill, 
coupled with his boast, that it would not be prosecuted 

-26- 

and that he had more influence over her than I had, is 
enough to convince every man, but a fool or knave, of 
their improper relations.  The lawsuit simply led to a 
disclosure of these improper relations. 
     The idea, the base assertion that I would destroy the 
woman that I had loved and idolized beyond the power 
of expression, up to that fatal hour; that I would destroy 
that beautiful home that was the center of attraction and 
existence to me on earth; that I would irreparably injure 
the children I loved more than my life; simply to give 
expression to malice, is simply revolting to every sense 
and feeling of humanity above the level of the lowest or- 
der of brute creation.  No human being who knows my 
life which has been an open book, could ever be induced 
to believe me capable of such an enormity, and I dwell on 
the charge and dismiss it with horror arid indignation. 
     On the contrary, what do the undisputed proofs show 
this false priest capable of? Renting a respectable resi- 
dence in the city and establishing a trio of young wenches 
therein; visiting them often under the assumed character 
of an auxiliary aid to the ladies' aid society, and to ward 
off suspicion, taking his innocent wife there as a blind. 
The facts are as eloquent with revolting hypocrisy and 
crime as hell can make them. Ah, religion, what crimes 
are committed in thy name! 
     To those blessed with a liberal mind and education, it 
seems amazing that in a Christian land, under the blaze 
of the nineteenth century, where the arts, science and 
philosophy and every branch of human attainment have 
encircled the world in a halo of light, that a junto of 
howling dervishes could either be found in or imported 
into Bowie county to crawl and hiss their venom at me 
in every nook and corner of the county, pronouncing as 
they advanced from church to church that their "dearly 
beloved Forbes is the greatest man who ever pressed 
his feet to the soil of Texas." "Oh, shame, where is thy 
blush?" Men who adopt such criminal devices to shield, 
protect, and cover up the crimes of the libertine are worse 
enemies to society than the burglar, railroad wrecker and 
robber. 

-27- 

     Lord Bolingbroke gave utterance to a truism when he 
said, "Bigotry is the inseparable companion of cruelty." 
The ancestors of these psalm-singing hypocrites were the 
demons of the dark ages who established the stake with 
its fagot pyre, employed implements of torture and the 
inquisition; and murdered multiplied thousands in the 
name of religion and they would employ the same agen- 
cies today if they had the power. 
     On the witness stand this martyr of the church militant 
told you that his brother, M. D.  Early, came from central 
Texas to his bedside to pour the oil of spiritual consola- 
tion into his wounded carcass. It is said, "A fellow-feel- 
ing makes us wondrous kind." 
     Well, Mr. Witness, who is this Brother Early of yours? 
Answer, "He is the head of the Baptist missionary work 
in the State of Texas." From that publication lying 
there on the table we are told that Early is an ambitious 
divine, particularly in the missionary work; that the 
vastness of his spiritual designs in that direction em-
braces darkest Africa; and that he has already advanced 
so far in his preliminary work as to become the father of 
a negro baby, the offspring of himself and a young wench 
who has sworn to the paternity. The paper also informs 
us that the mother and putative father of this young mis- 
sionary lived under the same roof when the foundations 
were laid. The paper also informs us that this pater- 
familias has not departed from the usual rule in such 
case, made and provided to cover all such accidents-- 
heroic denial. 
     That was enough under the rule to satisfy every block- 
head belonging to the guild of saints in the church mili-
tant. But the great missionary became impressed with 
the idea that all the world would be better satisfied with 
an alibi; so two of his brother ministers, each living one 
hundred miles away, in opposite directions, from the 
scene of action, sent him an alibi. Now, gentlemen, all 
of you may not know what an alibi is. It is a gem of pur- 
est ray serene, a brilliant of more precious value to crim- 
inals, and but few honest people would have one as a 
gift. But to the Snollagoster in religion who makes it a 
trade, the alibi brilliant is of inestimable value. It is 
also one of the variegated Mosaics with which hell is 

-28- 

paved for the accommodation of gentlemen of good in- 
tentions, who get there by misadventure with through 
tickets from the amen corner. 
     These vultures put on the plumage of the birds of para- 
dise and sit in judgment of men who are infinitely their 
superiors in all that constitutes manhood. 
     Another one of these gentlemen in clerical robes, 
named Russell, whilst living in central Arkansas some 
years ago, stole silently and steadily into the bedroom of 
his innocent daughters with lecherous intent. She raised 
the hue and cry and a mob was about to lynch the mon- 
ster, but he was taken in charge by his brothers in the 
church and guarded and spirited away between the set- 
ting and rising sun, furnished with funds and sent West. 
His license to preach was never revoked and he never 
ceased preaching, and today is preaching to a congrega- 
tion in San Francisco. 
     My time is too limited to rehearse a long roster of these 
gentlemen of the clerical gown, who have thus been pro- 
tected by the church instead of expelled, under the bane- 
ful and lawful idea that to expose them would be more 
injurious to religion than to cover up and protect their 
crimes against society. 
     Here in your own judicial district another gentlemen 
of the clerical gown was pulled out of the closet on one of 
your railroads flagrante delicto with a sister of his church. 
     The protection of such monsters by religionists has 
caused an overproduction and a powerful representation 
of hell in the church. They think themselves strong 
enough to crush any injured man who "pumps lead" into 
a criminal of their guild. These are the full-fledged birds 
of paradise who are crying for my blood; who have raised 
a slush fund to procure aid for the district attorney in this 
prosecution. 
     Mr. Turner, who has ,just closed the opening for the 
prosecution, is the fortunate recipient of that fund, which 
has imparted unusual inspiration to his efforts, which 
extended through the mock heroic, high tragedy and low 
comedy--his success being more pronounced in the latter. 
     The slogan of his battle cry is that five minutes is 
ample cooling time for any gentleman laboring under the 

-29- 

outrage that paused me to shoot the martyred saint. The
author of that declaration and all that class of hypocrites 
he represents, "like dead bodies thrown into the Ganges, 
rise as they rot and float on the surface an object of con- 
tagion and contamination.*
     "Touch the Jay and she will wince." 
     Does Ajax cry for quarter? Does Olympian Jove re- 
coil when he hears the rumbling of thunder in the Alps? 
You, sir, have emptied your quiver of poisoned Parthian 
arrows at me and I did not interrupt you. It has never 
been my custom to interrupt an adversary when I had the 
opportunity to reply, although I was advised to stop you, 
because you abandoned the high character of advocate 
for that of an unsworn witness by making statements 
dehors the record which are at war with the evidence and 
truth, to support your unfounded assumptions. I will 
impale you, before I am done with you with the spear of 
Ithuriel. 
     You have made the solemn proclamation to your wife, 
and all the wives and mothers and daughters and sisters 
of this great Southland, that the successful arts of the 
seducer of their virtue, the destroyer of happy homes and 
families ought not to inspire a feeling to destroy such 
monsters of longer duration than five minutes; that in 
that length of time the rage of father, brother, husband, 
ought to quiet down in calm submission to the appalling 
calamity. Such men as you no doubt possess that mastery 
over the passions. But, sir, our native Southland, labor- 
ing yet under the accumulated misfortunes of a long and 
terrible civil war; borne down as it is by the accumulated 
evils engendered by such a conflict, is yet the home of a 
nobler sentiment in the nursery of chivalrous devotion to 
their women and the rights of man; and few there are 
native to the soil which yet produces great men and noble 
women who would father your self-possession for the 
few pieces of silver contributed to you by the Judas 
Iscariots you represent in sentiment and forum. 
     (Turning away from him.)  I pity the little woman 
who bears him children. If his sainted grandmother 
could look down from the portals of heaven on the repres- 
entatives she has left on earth, the angels would gather 

* Here Mr. Turner rose and  protested against the severity of the
language, but the Court did not interfere.

-30- 

around her on the plains of paradise and weep with her 
over her misfortune.*
     Perhaps I have said enough on this line, but it is dif- 
ficult to restrain my indignation at the gentleman's per- 
version of facts to sustain a bastard argument that I 
would kill a man for a piece of dirt or for all the land the 
world contains, and it is equally difficult to restrain my 
indignation at the low brutal estimate the gentleman 
places on virtue and true manhood: but let it pass. 
     Ornithologists and the children of the sea tell me of an 
ocean bird, called the storm king, which spreads his brave 
little wings and bares his breast to the storm when every 
fowl on quivering wings hies away for safety. If there 
is anything I admire in the intellectual combats of the 
forum, it is the noble adversary who plants his standard 
of defiance and comes at me like an eagle cleaving the 
clouds. If there is any character of man I shun in such
conflicts, it is the scuttle-fish who darkens the water with 
his poisonous effluvia to shut out the light. 
     I have had many conflicts with able men in the run of 
a long and busy professional career, but none like the 
present, where so many elements of depravity are con- 
centrated to defeat law and justice and uphold crime. 
     Much has been said by the prosecution about the so- 
called decoy letter which brought Forbes to Texarkana. 
I told you on the witness stand that I am not the author 
of that letter, and that it was written by my friend with-
out my knowledge or procurement. He brought me the 
answer, stating the time Forbes would arrive. I also 
told you on the stand that I would scorn to throw any 
doubt on my veracity by trying to evade any responsi- 
bility which in any way attaches to that letter, that for 
the purposes of this trial you may consider me the author 
of that letter. 
     I was then, and had been for days, camping on the trail 
of the miscreant for the purpose of killing him. That 
letter brought him in range of my gun and I deliberately 
utilized it to take his life, and the first shot would have 
pierced his heart if he had not turned as I pulled the 
trigger. Three other shots struck him in the vital parts 
of his bull neck and I thought him dying when he fell. 

* Here Judge Tolbert in a mild tone of voice said "Col. Hallum,
that is too severe."

-31- 

     I scorn to place my defense on any doubtful or evasive 
ground and give the doubt to the prosecution. My man- 
hood scorns any evasion or equivocation to avoid the res- 
ponsibility attaching to my earnest attempt to kill the 
miscreant who entered my home under the sanction of 
friendship and religion and the hospitality such religion 
fosters, to become the author of its ruin and desolation. 
If I could have lived a thousand years, and it required 
all that time to find him, I would have spent it in camping 
on his trail for the sole purpose of destroying him. 
Again I enlarge the platform of the five-minute gentle- 
man who can cool off and simmer down to the level of 
the brute creation in five minutes. I am not a Darwin- 
ian evolute of recent extraction from ancestors with con- 
spicuous coat of arms to support caudal plumage. 
     You may be surprised when I tell you that stra- 
tegy, both to prevent and to punish with death the crimes 
of the libertine, comes to us with divine sanction, and was 
often practiced by those who are conspicuous in the line- 
age of the Savior. The strategy of which I am accused 
begins with Abraham and Sarah, his wife. 
     These basic rocks in the foundation of nations, dynas- 
ties and empires, whose blood trickled down the Cross of 
Calvary in the greatest tragedy the world ever saw, 
taught mankind that strategy, when employed either to 
protect or avenge virtue, is meritorious. 
     These luminous prototypes embodied many enduring 
virtues in character mingled with some of the infirmities 
incident to human nature. It could scarcely have been 
otherwise. When they entered on that pilgrimage so 
fraught with the destinies of man through time and eter- 
nity, they went to Egypt. When they entered the confines 
of that country Abraham became much alarmed for his 
personal safety, and he said to Sarah:  "Behold now, I 
know thou art beautiful to look upon; therefore, it shall 
come to pass, when the Egyptians see thee, that they shall 
say, `This is his wife,' and they will kill me but will save 
thee alive. Say, I pray thee, thou art my sister, that it 
may be well with me for thy sake, and my soul shall live
because of thee." 
     She was taken by Pharaoh to wife under the impres- 
sion that she was Abraham's sister, and after the Lord 
smote the land with plague and it became known to 

-32- 

Pharaoh that she was Abraham's wife, he delivered her 
up and reproached Abraham for deceiving him, and load- 
ed him with presents and sent him away. He journeyed 
then with his family, servants and herds to the land of 
Gerar, and for the same motive again passed as brother 
and sister, and Abimilech the King took Sarah, and the 
Lord said unto him, "Behold, thou art but a dead man 
if you touch Sarah, for she is a man's wife." Abimilech 
plead innocence of Sarah's wifehood, and the Lord said, 
"I know thou did it in the innocence of thine integrity 
of heart, and I withheld thee from sinning and did not 
suffer thee to touch her, and if thou restore her not thou 
shall die and all that are thine." And Abimilech called 
Abraham and reproved him for deceiving him. 
     Now we have the principal established with the appro- 
val and protection of the Creator. We have but little 
further to look for its application in more serious affairs. 
     When Jacob, the grandson of Abraham, was sojourn- 
ing in the dominions of Prince Hamor, his daughter, 
Dinah, was defiled by Schechem, the son of the prince. 
Dinah had two noble brothers, Simeon and Levi, who felt 
all the indignation that can animate the soul or set the 
brain on fire. 
     The seducer and his princely father offered a largess 
of lands and flocks and marriage as a compromise and 
Jacob was in favor of accepting it, and feared that if any 
violence was offered, the prince and his retinue of retain- 
ers would destroy him and his family; but the noble 
brothers neither feared nor cared for principalities and 
powers; and the seeming odds against them did not shake 
their resolve to kill, destroy and avenge themselves in 
blood. 
     In order to get them in their power they pretended to 
accept the compromise, which included circumcision of 
the prince and retinue. By this strategem they got the 
seducer and his retinue of abettors in their power, and 
with sword smote them to death and burned up the city. 
    Jacob was overpowered with fear and his knees 
smote together like Belshazzar's, and he said to his boys, 
"Ye make me stink among the inhabitants of the land, 
the Canamites and Perezites, and I being few in number, 
they will gather themselves together and destroy me and 
my house." 

-33- 

     The reply of the noble sons has come sounding down
the corridors of time, emblazoned in the tragic heraldry 
which gave the Savior to mankind. "Shall he deal with 
our sister as with an harlot?" That was all. It was 
enough. From that tree of life drips the blood of the 
libertine. Long may their example animate the generous
and chivalrous sons of my native soil.
     A little higher up on this same genealogical tree we 
come again to the house of King David, and find that his 
son Amnon defiled his daughter Tamar, and then her 
brother Absalom schemed and plotted  two years to get
Amnon into his power to slay him and finally succeeded
in having him killed for the crime, and was never called 
to account for slaying the brute.
     Solomon, the son of King David, that great inspired 
sage of Israel, is in the direct lineage of the Savior, and 
was the brother of Absalom, Tamar and Amnon by a dif-
ferent mother, has said to the libertine, "Can a man take 
fire in his bosom and his clothes not be burned! Can 
he go upon hot coals and his feet not be burned? He that 
defileth his neighbor's wife shall not be innocent. He 
that doeth it destroyeth his own soul. A wound shall 
he get, and his reproach shall not be wiped out. For 
jealously is the rage of man; therefore he will not 
spare in the days of vengeance. He will not regard any
ransom, neither will he rest content." God seems to have
overlooked the little Darwinian evolute and the five-min-
ute gentleman from Lilliput, when he created man in his 
own image, with noble aspirations and duties to perform
and made his home life and associations the basic work
of all that is noble and great in his nature.
     The man who can with so much ease and facility shut 
himself up in an iceberg, and calmly look on the con­
flagration of home, that carries down the wife and mother 
in its awful ruins, is excluded by God from the peerage 
of manhood. They can never wear the coronet which 
adorns the higher types of men. They can never drink 
at the Attic fount, nor feel the inspiration of a glorious 
literature, nor can they ever soar on the wings of genius 
to Alpine solitudes. They can never feel nor appreciate 
the divinity of man. They can never understand and ap-
preciate the tremendous influence the love of virtue in 
woman has exerted on the destinies of mankind. To them

-34-

the whited sepulchre in clerical robes is yet a gentleman. 
     Some men, like the youth who fired the Ephesian dome, 
aspire to an immortality of infamy, but happily for man­
kind the contagion of their nature never reaches better 
men.
     What an immeasurable gulf lies between the sparsely 
settled district inhabited by the five minute gentry and 
that class of chivalrous men whose characters were ex-
emplified the other day by Judge Donaldson, of Ken-
tucky, in the trial of a case parallel to this, and under 
a similar statute. He said to the jury: "Gentlemen,
 this case is governed by the higher law, you will render 
a verdict of not guilty." With him the puny statute of 
man repealing an ordinance of God for the government 
of the world was not of primal sanction.
     Such men are the heritage of the state. His name 
ought to be carved in letters of gold on the columns of 
the Pantheon. In delivering that charge he ascended the 
rugged heights of Sinai, and on its flaming summit shook 
hands with his God.
     But I am not making my defense against your statute 
by asking you to disregard it. It is of ample scope, and 
the evidence is sufficiently luminous to repel all idea of 
a felony, as you will see when the judge charges you and 
expounds the law. As to the assault under your statute, 
I am guilty, and I don't ask you to disregard it, but think 
you ought to impose the minimum fine.
     I will only notice one more assertion by the gentleman 
who opened the prosecution. Feeling himself driven into
the last ditch, with his magazine of poison exhausted and
his fortress blown up, he tells you why he insults you and 
the people of Texas.
     He says, "It is felt in the air, and whispered from man to 
man through the halls and corridors of this temple of
justice that Hallum cannot be convicted of a felony." 
Then he threw himself into that melodramatic, serio-
comic attitude for which he is distinguished, and tells 
this jury that "you are scabs! scabs!" Failing to per-
suade, he seeks to intimidate and drive.
     Let me say to the gentleman, that the descendants and 
representatives of Crockett, Travis, and Houston and the 
revolutionary heroes of Texas, who left you a heritage 
of glory and renown to hand down from generation to

-35-

generation as the cycles of time roll on, can neither be 
intimidated nor driven into anything their manhood and 
judgment does not approve:
     In the audacity of despair he tries to drive you to that 
standard he represents and exhibits in himself.
      Whence comes that public opinion, which has risen up
like Banquo's ghost in the pathway of the gentleman, to
thwart the hellish designs of the hellish hypocrites he re-
presents with so much fidelity? It came like the rush of 
mighty waters on my first trial, when the light was turn-
ed on in the robust vigor of unvarnished truth. It came 
when an honest and enlightened people learned that 
their minds had been wretchedly abused by a junto of cal-
umniating priests who did not scruple to sacrifice me to 
cover up the crimes of the basest of mankind. It came 
when the people learned that the prosecution embodied 
all that is wicked and depraved in man.

The Question in Its Relation to all the 
Higher Types of Manhood.

     Now let us view the question involved in their higher 
relation to society, to nation and the welfare of man. 
Look over the vast landscape of human history in every 
age and development of man, and wherever you find him 
treading the highways of greatness, whether with his 
genius or the sword, you will find that he loves and at 
any sacrifice will protect the virtue of woman, and you 
will find that this love is always especially connected 
with his patrotism and love of country. These primal 
elements in all the higher types of men luminously mark 
the upward and downward trend of nations.
     The Jews under the Mosaic dispensation were a great 
and a patriotic people. They imposed the death penalty
for wife seduction. Read the19th and 20th chapters of 
Judges and you will find the national trait strongly de-
veloped when the tribe of Benjamin refused to deliver up
the miscreants who had defiled one wife. Three great 
battles were fought and 60,000 men were slain, and the
tribe of Benjamin nearly wiped out. True, like all other 
people, they had their decades of corruption and advance
 and decline.
     Look at the history of pagan nations. Long before the
advent of Christianity, Rome had a temple erected for the 

-36-

worship of virtue, where the Vestal Virgins presided. As 
long as their women worshipped in that shrine their 
heroic sons carried the eagles of Rome to conquest and 
empire. No people, ancient or modern, knew better than 
the Romans that the strongest foundations of an endur-
ing state spring from the virtues which bloom around the
sacred altars of home. 
     In the Augustan age of that once mighty people they 
made a law, which was in force six hundred years, au- 
thorizing the injured husband and relatives to slay the 
libertine who invaded his home. The Emperors Augustus 
and Julian both promulgated this law in a pagan age. 
How near they came to God when he handed down the 
tablets from Sinai. 
     The noble Greeks, a thousand years before that, from 
the Areopagos, for the same purposes, promulgated a sim- 
ilar law. It conduced more than all else to make that 
people the focal and the radiating center of a civilization, 
and a literature that has rendered the names of her poets, 
orators, philosophers, statesmen and warriors immortal. 
It was the foundation of that spirit of martial glory that 
carried her banners to the Indus and laid Asia at her feet. 
Their noble women, of all their thirty thousand pagan 
gods worshiped none more than the Vestal Virgins, who 
ministered at the shrine of sexual purity in the radiance 
of light that never died out. The inspiration they trans- 
mitted to their sons crowned them with the laurels of 
of [sic] transcendent achievement. *
     Look at this master representation of the genius of 
Greek character in Parian marble; sculptured by a noble 
Greek three thousand years ago. It is unsurpassed in the 
genius of its execution by either of the great masters, 
Phydias, Angelo or Raphael. Observe the face of the 
False Priest in his dying agony as he is being crushed 
to death with his lecherous victims of lust by the monster 
serpent. That speaks more eloquent than tongue can 
paint of the odium and horrid contempt in which a great 
people held the Judas Iscariot in clerical robes who be- 
trayed confidence in the ruin of women. It was carved 
in marble when Greece was "winging her eagle flight 
against the blaze of every science; with an eye that never 

*Here the speaker uncovered and held up before the jury a fine 
crayon copy of the False Priest. 

-37-

winked and a wing that never tired." Her scrutinizing 
and profound researches in philosophy, her Attic litera- 
ture, clothed in the charms of elevated morality, will de- 
light mankind as long as the higher types inhabit the 
globe. Their love of home and the sanctity of the mar- 
riage relation was powerfully illustrated in the Trojan 
war. Paris, prince of Troy, and son of Priam, king of 
Troy, abducted Helen, the beautiful wife of Menelaus, 
king of Sparta, and carried her to the fortress of Troy, 
and refused to give her up. All the states of Greece con- 
federated against Priam, and brought their land and 
naval forces into action to avenge the outrage. The 
siege of Troy lasted ten years. Ajax, Achilles, Agamem- 
non, Hector and other celebrities were actors in this war, 
and the fortress was finally taken by the strategy of the 
wooden horse. Vast treasure and rivers of blood were ex- 
pended to avenge the injury. That was the foundation 
of Homer's Iliad, the wandering minstrel of Chios Isle, 
who gave the world its finest epic poem. It is not nec- 
essary for me to say to you that the religious, cool head- 
ed, five-minute men were not in it. 
    The Syrians were a great people when the Chaldean 
star gazers were studying the rudiments of astronomy. 
They were a patriotic and heroic people through a long 
cycle of centuries. They fought the Chaldean, the Baby-
lonian, the Persian, the Egyptian and Roman empires. 
But finally "Syria became a country where courage in 
man and virtue in woman were unknown." When the 
virtue of their women became extinct, they became a 
nation of five-minute men, demonstrating what I said 
that virtue in women is inseparable from the heroic vir- 
tues that create great people. 
     "History repeats itself." The Romans with the spoils 
of an hundred nations accumulated vast wealth, and with 
it came that laxity of morals and virtue in both sexes, 
until virtue in their women became the exception and not 
the rule, and courage and patriotism in the men declined 
in a ratio with the loss of virtue in their women, until 
great and powerful Rome, which aspired and claimed to 
be mistress of the world, crumbled into one vast chaotic 
mass of ruin. 
"Ill fares the land to hastening ills a prey, 
where wealth accumulates and men decay." 
-38-

     The Romans, finally became intoxicated with the vast 
power they attained, and although a great people 
they became the assailers of the virtue of women in nearly 
all their conquered provinces, and this abuse of  women 
led to many insurrections.*

   "Heap still the fetters, bar close the gate; 
   Patient as sheep we yield us up unto your love and hate. 
   But by the shades beneath us and by the Gods above;
   Add not unto your cruel hate your still more cruel love. 

   Then leave the poor plebian his single tie to life, 
   The sweet, sweet love of daughter, of sister and of wife. 
   The gentle speech, the balm for all that his vexed soul endures. 
   The kiss in which he half forgets such a yoke as yours. 
   Still let the maiden's beauty swell the father's breast with pride, 
   Still let the bridegroom's arm enfold an unpolluted bride. 
   Spare us in the inexplicable wrong, the unutterable shame. 
   That turns the coward's heart to steel, the sluggard's blood to 
     flame; 
   Lest when our last hope is fled, ye taste of our despair. 
   And learn by proof, in some wild hour, how much the wretched 
     dare."

     The Sabines were a religious and virtuous people and 
for the treachery of the Romans in taking and abusing 
their women, they fought them until blotted from the 
map of Italy, Roman writers have celebrated their vir- 
tues in history and in song. 
     Now we come to the ethnology and chronology which 
carries us to the primeval roots of our own race--the Ger- 
manic. Profound historians and ethnologists--Guizot, 
Arnold, Creasy--agree that we are of the Germanic 
race. The Anglo-Saxons are certainly of Ger- 
man graft; but for them there could not have been an 
English ancestry for Americans. They inhabited the 
countries watered by the Rhine and Mosel. No people in 
Europe ever more loved the domestic virtues which hal- 
lowed their homes; no people ever showed greater res- 
pect to female character.**
     They have always upheld this basic element of great- 
ness with the greatest tenacity of purpose. Overrun, 
overpowered and crushed by the Romans for hundreds of 
years, yet they constantly rose in rebellion at every seem- 

* Macaulay has beautifully and pathetically described the suffer-
ings the libertine patricians brought on the plebians, and the insurr-
ections it caused in the early days of the people.

** The great historian and ethnologist Creasy says of the 
Germanic race: "I allude to their personal freedom and regard for the 
rights of man, and the respect paid by them to the female sex, and the 
chastity for which their women were celebrated among the people of 
the North. These were the foundations of that probity of character, 
self respect and purity of manners which may be traced among the 
Germans and Goths, even during the pagan times, and which, when 
their sentiments were enlightened by Christianity, brought out those 
splendid traits of character which distinguish the age of chivalry and 
romance."

[39]

ing opportune time. Then they had no national or- 
ganization, mere tribal relations. Rome had shattered 
the kingdoms of the world, had surpressed with her 
gigantic power every great rebellion; the great Mithri- 
dates had fallen, and Hannibal, the greatest military 
genius that ever opposed Roman arms, had fallen and it 
looked hopeless to rebel against Rome; but there was a 
mighty genius of that primeval fatherland, the first 
Washington of our race. Arminius, whose wife and child 
had been taken away from him. Other German chiefs 
had suffered similar indignities. Arminius consolidated, 
confederated, organized and led to battle in his master 
genius for war, and utterly annihilated the Roman legions 
and allies under Varus in the year 9. 
     The emperor, Augustus Caesar, in the agonies of des- 
pair beat his head against the wall and cried, "0, Varus! 
give me back my Roman legions." The battle destroyed 
the western empire of Rome, and Germanic stock finally 
conquered and ruled the Roman people 400 years. 
     Like Bonaparte when he crossed the Alps, Arminus[sic] 
was but twenty-seven years old when he tore the plumage 
from the Roman eagles, which they had worn eight hun- 
dred years. 
     Historians and poets love to dwell on the virtue of that 
people and to "linger on the summit" of that great 
chieftain's name. Tacitus, the greatest of Roman his- 
torians, tells us that Thresnelda, the wife of Arminius, 
was possessed of the same great soul of her husband, and 
that Arminius was the liberator of his country. What 
a pleasure it is to look down twenty centuries on the 
heroic virtues and struggles of our primeval ancestors. 
     I am trying to aid you to a thorough insight to the 
comprehensive greatness and designs of the Creator in 
arming his children with divine authority to slay the de- 
stroyer of family ties, and that you may further under- 
stand what it has cost ours, the greatest race of man, to 
crystallize out of the blood, treasures and suffering of 
centuries, the glorious adage, that: "A Man's Home is 
His Castle," where no invasion is tolerated, without the 
sanction of law. I have sworn you that the blood of the 
libertine drips from the family tree of the Savior and I 
think it clearly manifest that the designs of the Creator 
of the higher types of men never could have been accom- 

-40-

plished without planting in his breast the strongest pas- 
sion of love for the purity and sacred character of home. 
And I think it equally manifest that the little creature 
who can keep cool over the destruction of his home, that 
carries down the purity of the wife and mother of his 
children, has never planted his little foot nor made a 
track in the highways of man's greatness, nor has he 
ever written a chapter in the history of the world that is 
not covered with shame. 
     Again, when oriental despotism under the lead of 
Attila, that master mind, and perhaps the most consum- 
mate general the Asiatic races ever produced, was seek- 
ing with powerful strides to change the drama of the 
world with his vast horde of nomadic Huns from the 
high plans of Asia and the subjects of twenty conquered 
kingdoms, a terrible crisis confronted the civilization 
and institutions of Europe. He advanced to the north 
of France and the "terrible renown" of this "scourge 
of the world" sent dismay and despair from the north 
to the Mediterranean sea. 
     The once vast power and resources of Rome was then 
in the sere leaf of decline. She had accomplished her mis- 
sion in the drama of the world and was making her last 
struggle against the seal of fate, and Attila aspired to be 
her successor by establishing oriental despotism in 
Europe. Valentinian III, emperor of the West, and 
Attila knew where the probably decisive power lay, and 
both made overtures to Theodric, king of the Visigoths, 
then the greatest of the Germanic stock. The Romans 
and our primeval ancestors, under Theodric, confronted 
Attila on the plains of Chalons, A. D. 451. Theodric 
commanded the left wing, and crushed the right wing of 
Attila and drove back the center where Attila command- 
ed in person, whilst Aretus, the Roman general, failed 
to break Attila's left wing. The glory of that great bat- 
tle fell to our race and saved Europe from Asiatic des- 
potism. 
     In the year 732, two hundred and eighty years after the 
battle of Chalons, another equally momentous crisis con- 
fronted Europe. The followers of Mohammed, within 
one hundred years after his death, destroyed the eastern 
empire of Rome, crossed into Europe, overran Spain and 
crossed the Pyrenees, spreading terror and desolation, 

-41-

under Abderahman, one of the greatest generals that ever 
fought under the banners of the Koran. They had con- 
quered Persia, Syria, Egypt, Africa and Spain, in an un- 
broken career of victory. With an army of veterans they 
came to lay Europe under the yoke of the Moslem and 
thus precipitate the mighty conflict between the Cross 
and the Crescent. Gaul, because of incompetent rulers 
did not make any appreciable resistance.
     The Austrasian Franks, the bravest of the Germanic 
stock, under Charles Martel, their brave young duke, a 
master general, with an army vastly inferior in numbers, 
met the hitherto victorious Saracens in the decisive bat- 
tle of Tours in the south of Gaul and annihilated the fol- 
lowers of the Koran. 
     The Rhine and Mosel will chant a lullaby to the fame 
of Arminius and Martel as long as their waters roll on 
to the sea. 
     Through mighty struggles and fields of slaughter, we 
find in our race the gradual renaissance of all that was 
glorious and heroic in Greek and Roman character; and 
we find its foundation planted in the enduring chastity 
of their women, whose heroic sons worshiped and defen- 
ded the scanctity[sic] of their family altars and became the 
embodiment of the highest types of man. "The hand 
that rocks the cradle rules the world." 
     The Romans first invaded Britain 55 B. C., and held the 
island 470 years, but our rude ancestors were never con- 
quered; they were overpowered, never subdued. They 
rose again and again on every possible occasion and 
fought the Romans 470 years and countless thousands 
perished by the sword. When beaten in battle they re- 
tired to morass, and from morass to mountain defile, 
half naked and often nearly starved, yet their heroic 
spirit was never conquered. The licentious Romans ab- 
used their women, for whom the Britons cherish a pro- 
found respect. 
     To avenge the abuse of Queen Boadicae and her two 
daughters they arose and in a few days slew 70,000 Rom- 
ans and drove them from the island; but the Romans re- 
turned with an augmented army and fought another great 
battle. Queen Boadicae with her daughters drove down 
the line of battle and lent inspiration to those rude an- 
cestors of ours, worthy the proudest eras of Grecian and 

-42-

Roman history; proud landmarks on the highways of 
time, worthy of the great destiny of the race. The super- 
ior skill of the veteran legions of Rome triumphed, and 
the queen took poison rather than be taken to grace a 
Roman triumph. 
     Through all the shifting scenes of the historic drama, 
for many centuries the people ever struggled to maintain 
the integrity of their women. The time came when the 
feudal lord and a dissolute clergy could appropriate the 
virtue of the common people without responsibility, but 
their struggles continued and they fought hundreds of 
battles to correct that and other abuses and drenched  the 
British Isle in blood. Finally the Saxon and Norman 
lines of our race united into one great national stream 
and rose in rebellion against King John, one of the mean- 
est of the mean kings of the Plantagenet line, and on the 
15th of June, 1215, in that isle in the river of life, the 
Runnymede forced him to sign the great charter of En- 
glish liberties. That instrument and the unyielding ten- 
acity with which our race in every quarter of the globe 
have maintained its integrity, opened up the greatest 
possibilities and has led to the noblest achievements of 
the human race. But the struggle to maintain its inte- 
grity has been great and its invasions many. 
     That chart of freedom crystallized the struggles and 
blood of fifteen centuries into an axiom which is one of 
the glories distinguishing our race, which you and I may
well hope and pray will be transmitted to unborn genera- 
tions. "A Man's Home is His Castle." That axiom,
with its kindred inspirations, was nailed to the masthead 
of the little Mayflower, and came across a tempest-tossed 
ocean with the Pilgrim Fathers to the wilds of New En- 
gland, and to the James with the Cavaliers. It nerved 
a heroic people in a Spartan age. It lighted up the torch 
of a revolution against encroachment at Concord and 
Lexington and it spoke in the thunders which shook the 
earth at Bunker Hill. It sustained a patriot soldiery at 
Valley Forge that awful winter when their naked feet
were bleeding on the frozen ground. It descended with 
the conquering sweep of an eagle on the British army at 
Saratoga, and wreathed King's Mountain in festoons of 
laurel and immortels. 

-43- 

     It rose triumphantly above the rattle of musketry and 
roar of cannon at Yorktown, where it was again canon- 
ized and rebaptized in American blood, and today it 
shines second in luster only to the star of Bethlehem. 
"A Man's Home is His Castle," and I hope that the 
sons of my native soil will maintain it in the integrity 
with which it was proclaimed from the flaming summit 
of Sinai, and written on the hearts of all the higher types 
of man. And I feel assured that they will do it as long as 
they can pull a trigger or drive a dagger to the heart of 
a libertine. Yes, they will do it in defiance of all the puny 
mandates of man, as long as rivers flow to the sea and 
until the ocean heaves her last billow to the storm. 
     We are yet fighting the battles of civilization; my 
struggles today may be yours tomorrow. 

The Clergy.

     These gentlemen in every age and with every people 
have claimed to be the salt of the earth; and a vast ma- 
jority of them have made credulity their capital and re- 
ligion a trade from the little howling evolute in our 
midst, back to the crushing of human bones under the 
wheels of Juggarnaut and the burning of helpless victims 
on funeral pyres in India, to the Egyptian worship of 
storks and onians, crocodiles and bulls, up to the priest- 
hood who condemned and led the Savior to the crucifix- 
ion. 
     When in power they have been relentless tyrants and 
scourgers of the earth. When subject to the favors or 
frowns of authority, they have been fawning sycophants 
at the feet of power and willing instruments of crime. 
     They have never led the vanguard of civilization, but 
have followed in the wake of public opinion, and molded 
creeds to suit the conditions which confronted them. They 
rose into power with the decline and fall of the Roman 
empire, and had the most splendid opportunities ever en- 
joyed by any people or class of mankind, to elevate and 
ennoble the human race. They became the political and 
spiritual masters of all Europe, and used that vast power 
solely for their own aggrandizement. 
     They manufactured a thousand of bigots to where they 
ever enlarged the intellectual foundations of one man, and 
their factories are still running full time. They closed 

-44- 

the schools of philosophy and learning because ignorance 
and credulity was their stock in trade. They laid their 
mailed hand on Galileo, whose splendid genius took for
the scope of his powers the landscape of the solar system 
and the interpretation of the laws governing the universe. 
They suppressed the readings of the Bible, and as far 
as possible all knowledge of the existence of the New 
Testament. Even Martin Luther, the great reformer, did 
not know of its existence until he discovered it by acci- 
dent long after he had been a priest. They turned back 
the dial or human progress a thousand years and brought 
on the Dark Ages. They led the procession at the 
slaughter of Saint Bartholomew and lighted the torch to 
the martyr at Smithfield. They were the greatest state 
criminals during the long rein of the houses of Planta- 
genet, Tudor and Stuart, and did the evil work for those 
evil masters. To protect themselves from the crime of 
adultery they required twelve eyewitnesses to the crime. 
     They ministered to the disgraceful lust of kings in the 
name of religion as their shield and justification. Their 
state crimes led the fathers who founded our government 
to separate their powers from that of the state. 
     I love a pure and undefiled religion, and would not ex- 
change my simple faith in the Redeemer for all the wealth 
and principalities of earth. I know many great and good 
men in the ministry, and large numbers of sincere Chris- 
tians of both sexes, for whom I entertain profound res- 
pect, whilst language is not strong enough to express my 
loathing and contempt for the hypocrite. 
     My time is out, but the court will indulge me a moment 
longer whilst I say something of Judge Dillard in the 
gratitude of my heart. To me he was the Good Samar- 
itan. In him I realize that "kind hearts are more than 
coronets." 
     When that grand old Roman saw the storm and the 
waves dashing around me he came to me without price 
or reward and has been a powerful breakwater in cor- 
recting an abused public sentiment by stating the facts. 
Animated by that love of truth and justice which have 
molded his life into that nobility of sentiment and char-