The University of Texas at Austin

Law in Popular Culture collection

THE CHRISTIANA RIOT

ADDENDA.

NOTE A.

     On page 14 it is stated that there was little fellowship between the
negro and the Pennsylvania-German elements of our local citizenship.
I believe this is a continuing condition. It is not inconsistent with the
historical fact that the Mennonites of Germantown were the first
American Abolitionists; and that their deliverance of February 18,
1868, antedated like action by the Friends. Professor Wilkinson in his
so-called "Vindication of Daniel Webster," recently published, is
authority for the statement that Charles Sumner's social aversion to
the colored race was as pronounced as his political sympathy with it.

NOTE B.

     On page 27 it is stated upon information that William Parker was a
soldier in the war for the Union. I have not been able to absolutely
verify this statement. It is therefore qualified.

NOTE C.

     On page 59 it is noticed that the venire issued to the marshal com-
manding him to return 108 jurors for the term of the treason trial
included a provision that twelve were to be summoned and returned
from Lancaster County. This was in conformity with the Act of Sep-
tember 24, 1789, known as the Federal Judicial Procedure Act, to the
effect that "in cases punishable with death, the trial shall be had in
the county where the offense was committed, or where that cannot be
done without great inconvenience, twelve petit jurors at least shall be
summoned from thence."
     In a recent notable address before the American Bar Association at
Boston on August 30, 1911, Ex-Justice of the United States Supreme
Court Henry R. Brown called attention to the fact that the provision of
this act which required the trial for a capital offense to be held in the
county where it occurred had never been observed. It seems to have
escaped his notice that the statutory direction as to the venue was not
unqualifiedly imperative and that this act had been the subject of
repeated judicial construction, e. g., in the following cases:
     "The Circuit Courts are bound to try all crimes committed within the
district, but not to try them in the County where committed; that is a
matter of which they, must judge in the exercise of their discretion."
U. S. v. Wilson, Bald. 117; U. S. v. Cornell 2 Mason 95-8; U. S. v.
Insurgents (Fries), 3 Dall. (Pa.) 513. In U. S. v. Cornell the Court

[131]

holds that the third Section of the Act of March, 1793, Chapter 22,
operates as a material modification of the Act of 1789 and leaves the
place of the trial in the district to the sound discretion of the judge.
The Act of 1793, Chapter 22, directs that special sessions for the trial
of criminal cases shall be held at any convenient place within the
district nearer to the place where the offenses may be said to be com-
mitted, than the place appointed by the law for ordinary sessions.

NOTE D.

     I have adopted the spelling of Sims's and Scarlet's name with a
single terminal letter instead of the local and family usage--Simms and
Scarlett--because they were thus formally indicted.

NOTE E.

     The best information I have as to the date of William Parker's revisit
to Christiana is that it was during the presidential campaign of 1872.
Peter Woods says he took back with him to Canada the widow of Henry
Sims--one of the defendants in the treason case; presumably he was
then a widower and Mrs. Sims became his second wife.

NOTE F.

     On pages 6 and 12 I have recalled the indisputable fact that Abraham
Lincoln and his party distinctly recognized the legal obligation of the
Fugitive Slave Law even after the war had begun. Striking confirmation
of what heedless readers may be disposed to doubt is found in General
William T. Sherman's "Causes of the War," cited in the Atlantic
Monthly, for September, 1911, where Sherman says: "Mr. Lincoln after
election and installation, asserted repeatedly that slavery was safe in
his hands, that he was sworn to enforce even the Fugitive Slave Law
and soon Congress declared it had no intention to interfere with slavery
in the States."

NOTE G.

     A second and revised edition of this History, substantially bound and
more copiously illustrated, will be put to press shortly. The author will
appreciate the correction of any errors observed in this edition--hur-
riedly put to press--as well as any additions to its statements of facts.
Communications to this effect or orders for copies of the revised edition
may be sent to Box 34, Lancaster, Pa.

[132] 

The Christiana Riot table of contents